This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports. |
Public Prosecutor v Keh See Hua
[1994] SGHC 80
MA 463/93/01
Yong Pung How CJ
29 March 1994
1 The respondent pleaded guilty in the subordinate courts to 19 charges of employing foreign construction workers without obtaining valid work permits to allow them to work for him. He was charged under s 5(1) of the Employment of Foreign Workers Act (Cap 91A, 1991 Ed) (`the Act`) and was sentenced under s 5(4)(a) of the Act to 38 weeks` imprisonment. He had asked for a sentence of imprisonment as he was unable to pay any fine that might be imposed. This appeal was brought by the public prosecutor against the sentence imposed on the grounds that it was manifestly inadequate. Having heard and considered the arguments on 29 March 1994, I decided to allow the appeal. I imposed 19 sentences of three months` imprisonment each, with three of them to run consecutively and the remaining 16 to be concurrent. My reasons follow.
2 The decision below
3 Section 5(4) provides that:
Any person who fails to comply with or contravenes subsection (1) shall be guilty of an offence and shall -
(a) be liable on conviction to a fine of an amount of not less than 24 months` levy and not more than 48 months` levy or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or to both; and
(b) on a second or subsequent conviction, be punished with imprisonment for a term of not less than one month and not more than one year and shall also be liable to a fine of an amount of not less than 24 months` levy and not more than 48 months` levy.
4 Section 5(1) which creates the substantive offence provides that:
No person shall employ a foreign worker unless he has obtained in respect of the foreign worker a valid work permit which allows the foreign worker to work for him.
5 The difficulty raised in this appeal concerned the interpretation of s 5(8) of the Act, which provides that:
For the purpose of this section, all convictions for the contravention of subsection (1) entered against an employer at one and the same trial shall be deemed to be one conviction.
6 In the court below, the prosecution and the defence had agreed that all the 19 charges were being brought at one and the same trial and that all 19 convictions were deemed, under the provisions of s 5(8), to be one conviction. The district judge held that, where all convictions recorded or entered are deemed by s 5(8) to be one conviction, a separate sentence is not to be passed in respect of each charge brought, for to do so would, in effect, be to impose several separate and distinct sentences for what is, to all intents and purposes, deemed to be one and the same conviction. The district judge`s attention was brought to the speech made in Parliament by the Minister for Labour during the second reading of the Employment of Foreign Workers Bill. The prosecution argued that the only purpose for which s 5(8) was enacted as stated by the minister was to exclude first-time offenders with multiple charges from the mandatory minimum sentence provided under s 5(4)(b). Therefore, s 5(8) would not preclude a court from treating each charge as a separate and distinct offence for which a separate and distinct sentence should be passed. To this contention, the district judge observed that the ordinary meaning of s 5(8) could hardly be said to be ambiguous or obscure, and that there was nothing manifestly absurd or unreasonable in the result. As such, he held that s 9A(2) of the Interpretation Act (Cap 1), which provides for the consideration of extraneous material in the interpretation of a written law, was inapplicable. The district judge also placed emphasis on the words `For the purpose of this section` in s 5(8) and held that s 5(8) was thus applicable to the whole of s 5, including s 5(4)(a). In the result, the district judge sentenced the respondent to 38 weeks` imprisonment for his single conviction, which was made up of 19 convictions deemed to be one. The district judge however, went on to say in the next breath that the basis of the sentence imposed was two weeks` imprisonment for each of the 19 workers illegally employed.
7 The present appeal
8 There is nothing in the Act which expressly prevents each of the charges from being treated as a separate and distinct offence for which a separate and distinct sentence should be passed. This is especially so if an analogy with fines is drawn. In the event that a court imposes a fine in the circumstances of a particular case, the relevant levy for the particular foreign worker(s) must be ascertained. This is because the amount of the fine is pegged to the levy of the individual worker(s). To this end, the Employment of Foreign Workers (Levy) Order 1990 (as amended) specifies a levy at the appropriate rate in respect of each class of foreign workers. For instance, the levy payable in respect of a `skilled marine worker` or an `unskilled construction worker` would be $250 and $400 respectively for every calendar month.
9 Therefore, should a person face multiple charges for illegally employing more than one class of foreign workers or more than one worker of the same class, the fine to be imposed (if the court so pleases) must vary in accordance with the levy rate payable for each worker. In such a case, each of the charges would thus have to be treated as a separate and distinct offence for which a separate and distinct fine must be imposed. This analysis is supported by s 5(5) of the Act which defines `levy` as the monthly rate of levy applicable to the foreign worker at the date when he was found working without a valid work permit (emphasis is mine). The district judge himself alluded to this when he held that `as far as fines are concerned, they are calculated according to the levies payable, and the levies for the various foreign workers can be toted up without restriction ...`.
10 It thus follows that if the court wishes to impose imprisonment, each charge (in respect of each foreign worker illegally employed) must attract the maximum of one year`s imprisonment term as provided for under s 5(4)(a) of the Act. In other words, the court can impose imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year for each of the charges the accused faces. Otherwise, as pointed out by the DPP, the maximum punishment would be the same under all circumstances regardless of the number and severity of the offences.
11 At the same time, however, an ordinary reading of s 5(8) would seem to dictate that the effect of s 5(8) is that, regardless of the number and severity of the charges, the multiple convictions must be deemed as one and only one conviction for which there could only be one sentence passed, and if this be or includes imprisonment, it should not exceed the maximum of one year prescribed under s 5(4)(a). Faced with two differing interpretations, I was of the opinion that there was an ambiguity in the interpretation of s 5(8). By virtue of s 9A(2) of the Interpretation Act, consideration may be given to material like records of Parliamentary proceedings if these be capable of assisting in the ascertainment of the meaning of s 5(8). To throw light upon the problematic effect of s 5(8) of the Act, I have had recourse to the Parliamentary debates during the second reading of the Employment of Foreign Workers Bill. In moving the Bill, the Minister for Labour stated:
An employer will be charged for each illegal worker employed. He could, therefore, be convicted at the same trial of several charges for the illegal employment of several foreign workers. To protect a first offender from the mandatory jail sentence provided for second and subsequent offences, cl 5(8) of the Bill provides that all convictions at one trial will be considered as one conviction.
12 It is thus clear that the sole purpose of s 5(8) of the Act is to place a first time offender with multiple charges under s 5(4)(a), thereby excluding him from the mandatory jail sentence provided under s 5(4)(b). Therefore, even though s 5(8) deems all convictions at one and the same trial to be one conviction, it does not prevent the court from sentencing a first-time offender for each of the charges he faces under s 5(4)(a). It merely means that if a first-time offender is faced with two or more charges simultaneously, his second or other charges will not be considered as `second or subsequent convictions` to visit him with the mandatory minimum sentence under s 5(4)(b).
13 I accordingly allowed the appeal and imposed 19 sentences of three months imprisonment each, with three of them to be consecutive and the remaining 16 to be concurrent.
14 Appeal allowed.
Chay Yuen Fatt (Deputy Public Prosecutor) for the appellant
James Masih (James & Bala) for the respondent