This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports. |
Guna Segar v Public Prosecutor
[1996] SGHC 50
MA 194/95/01
Yong Pung How CJ
23 March 1996
1 The appellant was convicted in the district court, on two charges as follows:
DAC 21126/94
You, Guna Segar s/o Ramathan ... are charged that you, between 25 March 1994 and 20 August 1994 at Blk 331, Yishun Ring Road #02-1404, Singapore, did employ one Venkadasalam Penarasi (F/1959), an Indian national, as a domestic maid, being a person who had overstayed on her visit pass in contravention of s 15(1) of the Immigration Act (Cap 133) and you have thereby committed an offence under s 57(1)(e), punishable under s 57(1)(ii) of the said Act.
DAC 21127/94
You, Guna Segar s/o Ramathan ... are charged that you, between 25 March 1994 and 20 August 1994, at Blk 331, Yishun Ring Road, #02-1404, Singapore, did harbour one Venkadasalam Penarasi (F/1959), an Indian national, being a holder of social visit pass and who has acted in contravention of s 15(1) of the Immigration Act (Cap 133), by remaining in Singapore after the expiry of the visit pass, and you have thereby committed an offence under s 57(1)(d), punishable under s 57(1)(ii) of the Immigration Act (Cap 133).
2 After hearing both counsel for the appellant and the DPP, I allowed the appeal. I now set out my grounds.
3 It was not disputed that the appellant employed Venkadasalam Penarasi (PW2). However, as PW2 was found in premises solely used for residential purposes, s 57(8) of the Act was not triggered. Hence, the prosecution must prove that the appellant knew that PW2 was an immigration offender. Similarly, the prosecution must prove that the appellant harboured her. If harbouring for a period exceeding 90 days was proven, then the prosecution could rely on the presumption of knowledge in s 57(7).
4 The prosecution`s evidence
5 PW2 was the main prosecution witness. On the essential ingredients of the offences, she was the sole prosecution witness. She gave evidence that she arrived in Singapore on 24 January 1994. She said that the statement of facts relating to her conviction for overstaying, on a guilty plea, was incorrect as it had stated that she arrived in Singapore on 24 March 1994. According to her, she had, on several occasions, given the investigating officer the wrong date because she was afraid and confused.
6 Her passport was kept by one Ramanathan when she arrived. She had not seen it since. Ramanathan found her employment in Singapore. On her arrival at 7pm, Ramanathan took her to the agent`s office. She spent the night there and, the following day, was taken to a house in the Serangoon area to work. From there, she was taken to another place for 15 days, and then to the appellant`s home. She told the court that her agent was Ramanathan.
7 According to PW2, she worked in the appellant`s flat from 25 March 1994, until she was arrested on 24 August. Ramanathan took her there. At the time, the appellant`s wife, DW4, was not in. PW2 remembered that she started work on 25 March, because she `kept an account of the salary` she received. Her evidence was that she lived in the flat.
8 PW2 worked from 6am to 10pm. She looked after the child, cooked, did the laundry and cleaned the flat. From June 1994 onwards, she was given a day off every month. She received a total of $1,000. This was in June. The appellant gave her the money. She slept in the hall, with the appellant`s child. She did not sleep in the rooms because they were let out to tenants.
9 She told the appellant, after a few months, that she wanted to go back to India, as her children were there. The appellant told her to stay for two years as she had paid 17,500 rupees to come to Singapore. She told him that she did not have her passport and air ticket with her, and that she was afraid. The appellant told her not to be afraid as he was a policeman. He also told her not to worry, as she only needed to pay a fine of $200 if she did not have a work permit. He said that, if anybody asked her, she should say that he had taken out a two-year work permit for her. He never asked to see her passport or work permit. She retracted part of her evidence. She told the court that the appellant never said that if she did not have a work permit, she would only have to pay a fine. She claimed she was confused.
10 On 14 August 1994, the appellant and DW4 took her to see a doctor because she had stomach pains. She went to the doctor again on 18 August. This time, DW4 and the appellant`s sister, Shanty (DW3), took her. DW4 told her that the doctor said that she might be suffering from appendicitis, and that he had referred her to the Tan Tock Seng Hospital. After seeing the doctor, they took her to the appellant`s mother`s house. Along the way, PW2 heard them discussing about her illness. DW4 told DW3 that they needed at least $2,000 for the operation. DW3 suggested deducting the amount from PW2`s salary. DW4 then said, `If you don`t have a passport, you cannot be admitted to any hospital.` PW2 did not go to the hospital.
11 When PW2 told the appellant of her illness, he told her that if anything happened to her, he would be in trouble. So she told the appellant that she would go to one Valli`s place for a couple of days. The appellant gave her $20 and sent her off in a taxi. This was on 20 August 1994. Valli was not her agent. Valli was a mere acquaintance whom she had met a few times previously at a shop. The first time they met was in June. PW2 had been to Valli`s home before, when she attended Valli`s brother`s birthday party. She went with the appellant`s daughter. Photographs were admitted showing PW2 with a child at a party. According to PW2, the child was the appellant`s daughter. The appellant gave her permission to attend the party. He had never met Valli before and had never been to Valli`s home.
12 PW2 said that she did not tell the appellant how she could be contacted at Valli`s home. When asked how then could the appellant give the police Valli`s phone number, she said that she gave him the number. She did not know who owned the place Valli lived in. She was given permission to stay there by Valli. She was arrested on 24 August when she went to the appellant`s flat. She went there at 8pm and was arrested at 10pm. She was at Valli`s place on the night of 23 August. She spent four days there.
13 The police asked about Ramanathan. She did not give them Ramanathan`s name. When asked by the court how they obtained the name, she said that she gave the name to them. She had told the police her agent was Lingam. Ramanathan was also her agent. Ramanathan had said that if she had any problem, she was to call Lingam. When asked why she told the police that her agent was Lingam, she replied, `I did not know whose name to say, so I mentioned Lingam`s name as he was one of the persons there.` She never met Lingam. She was given his photograph. The name she gave to the appellant was Lingam. She did not tell him Ramanathan`s name.
14 She had gone back to the appellant`s flat because Valli told her to. This was because PW1, from the police, had called Valli and asked if PW2 was there. Valli said that PW2 should not be at her place as the police were looking for her. When she went back to the flat, DW2, one of the tenants, was there. He opened the door. She did not use the keys given to her by the appellant as she did not bring them.
15 PW2 was cross-examined on her previous employment. When asked about her medical condition, she replied that she had stomach pains. She was taken to a doctor once, when she was with her second employer. She could not remember the second employer`s address. She was confronted with the fact that she went to a clinic, known as the Healthcare Family Clinic, at Dover Crescent. She admitted going there sometime in February. Medicine packets issued by Healthcare indicated that she was there on 31 January. She was taken there by her first employer. When reminded that she had said that the first employer was at Serangoon, she said that she was confused, as it had been a year. She then said that her first employer was at Dover Road.
16 When asked to describe Ramanathan, she said, `She was wearing gold chains and gold rings. She was tall, neither fair nor dark.` Asked where in the appellant`s flat she put her bags, she said, `In the toilet next to my bed.` She said that the master bedroom bathroom was not used. According to her, she, the appellant, DW4, and the tenants all used the same bathroom, which was in the kitchen.
17 She admitted that during her stay with Valli she had gone to see a doctor. She had used Valli`s name to register at the clinic. On the `account` she had kept, PW2 said that DW4 had noted the date in a calendar when she was paid the $1,000. DW4 had done this to show PW2 the number of days she worked. PW2 did not keep the record. It was kept by DW4. DW4 had given her a piece of paper indicating `25 March, 25 April and so on.` This piece of paper was in `the kitchen cabinet, inside a small note book with the picture of [PW2`s] husband.` The notebook was DW4`s.
18 She had not realized that she did not have a work permit until she was told this by the appellant. The appellant told her that the agent had cheated her. He said not to worry and that he would take care of the matter. He also told her that, as a policeman, if he obtained a passport from overstayers he arrested, he would be able to send her back by using the passport of someone who looked similar. She said that the appellant told her she could not get a work permit without a valid passport. She denied she was told this by immigration officers. She claimed that the appellant reported her to the police because he was afraid that she might die, and that he might get into trouble. He told her that it was, `already wrong to keep me in his house.` He said this on the night she was arrested, when she asked him why he called the police. He also said that it was somebody else who called the police.
19 PW2 was subsequently recalled by the prosecution. She gave a rather detailed description of the appellant`s family members.
20 PW1, Sergeant Shamsuddin bin Abdul Aziz, was a senior investigation officer attached to the Ang Mo Kio Police Division. PW1`s conditioned statement was admitted in evidence. In it, he stated that, on 23 August 1994, at about 8.05pm, the appellant lodged a report that some documents, receipts and pawn tickets had been stolen. The documents related to the appellant`s `part-time maid`, PW2. The appellant said that he suspected that the maid had taken them. The appellant gave him the telephone number `2579345`. PW1 called the number and spoke to someone who identified herself as `Valli`. Valli denied knowledge of PW2. PW1 advised her to `inform the maid to return back to the house.`
21 While the appellant was still at the station, he told PW1 that his mother had paged for him. The appellant said that PW2 had gone to his flat. PW1 told the appellant to go home and detain the maid. PW1 went to the appellant`s flat just before midnight with one Corporal Goh. The appellant showed him where the missing items were placed. PW1 asked PW2 for her passport. When she replied that it was with the agent, he placed her under arrest on suspicion that she was an illegal immigrant.
22 PW1 interviewed PW2. PW2 denied taking the items. She gave him her agent`s telephone number, which was `2917535`. The number belonged to Imeco Agency. This was the place identified by PW2.
23 PW3 was Dr Yuen Jye. DW4 was PW3`s assistant. DW4`s working hours were from 8.30am to 4pm, with a lunch break between 12.30pm and 2pm. PW3 gave evidence that he examined PW2 on 14 August 1994. DW4 told him that PW2 was her maid. The clinic`s record card was admitted. The address stated on it was the appellant`s. PW2 was referred to him again on 18 August 1994. PW3 thought she might have appendicitis and wrote a referral letter for her to go to Tan Tock Seng Hospital. He left it to DW4 to do what was necessary. He did not see anybody there with the maid, apart from DW4.
24 Senthamarai V (PW7) was the senior investigating officer from the Immigration Department. On 12 January 1995, solicitors for the appellant wrote to her asking for the appellant`s employment contract for PW2, the agency agreement and the name card of Maheswaran Trading, on which Valli`s address and telephone number were written. The letter was admitted. It stated that the solicitors were instructed that those items had been handed to the Immigration Department. PW7 obtained the name card from the appellant. PW2 told her that she did not know who wrote the words on the card. PW2 said that she could not recall if the card belonged to her. However, I noted that PW2 had testified in court that Valli had written her address and phone number on the card before giving it to her. The appellant told PW7 that he had obtained the card from Maheswaran Agency. He later said it was from Lingam`s Maid Agency.
25 The appellant gave PW7 Valli`s telephone number, `2579345`. PW7 called the number. A woman identifying herself as Valli answered. When PW7 said she was calling from the Immigration Department, the woman hung up. PW7 called again. A man answered. He said that there was no Valli there.
26 PW7 asked PW2 about her date of arrival. PW2 said it was 24 January 1994, and not 24 March 1994. PW2 appeared confused. By then, the appellant had already given PW7 the medicine packet, which was dated 31 January 1994. PW7 could not find the flight manifest from the airlines. It was destroyed after six months. She could not locate PW2`s embarkation card. It meant that someone could have used PW2`s passport to leave Singapore, as the card was kept until the passport holder left.
27 PW7 did not search for PW2`s belongings at the appellant`s flat because it was already one week after her arrest. By this time, the appellant could have removed them. Upon further examination, she admitted that the police referred PW2 to the Immigration Department on 24 August 1994. She said that she had no manpower to go and seize PW2`s belongings. Under cross-examination, she admitted that she did not look for Valli at her address. Her explanation was that she was short of manpower. She had called the subscriber of Valli`s telephone number, but he had said that there was no Valli there. She conceded that Valli would have been a most relevant witness in their investigations.
28 PW7 testified that PW4, Somuthevar Mahalingam, was arrested on 11 August 1994 for supplying illegal maids to a CISCO officer named Ravindran. Ravindran identified PW4 as the agent. PW4 admitted supplying Ravindran the maid. Ravindran was not charged, but merely given a warning. Under cross-examination she denied that she had told the appellant about Ravindran and the fact that he was only given a warning. She denied telling him that he could settle the case by paying a sum of money. She said that her superior wrote to the Attorney General recommending that Ravindran be given a warning. When asked if she had the letter, she replied that she was confused and that they did not write to the Attorney General. She denied that she decided to charge the appellant because he refused to pay any money.
29 PW4 admitted that he was arrested for assisting one Elango to supply maids who were in Singapore illegally. He did not know PW2. He knew Ramanathan, who was an Indian national helping Elango. He did not know the appellant. He never received any call from him. He described Ramanathan: `he is skinny and slightly dark, about 5 feet tall or 35 to 40 years of age.` PW4 assisted Elango at the office of Imeco Agency.
30 PW5 and PW6 were partners in Imeco Agency. Their evidence was that Elango was PW5`s brother-in-law. Elango used to go to their office. They did not know of a Lingam. Neither did they know PW2 or the appellant. PW5 however knew that one Mahalingam worked for Elango. They never received any call from the appellant.
31 The defence`s evidence
32 The appellant gave evidence that he looked for a maid by going through newspaper advertisements. He called Lingam`s Agency. Someone claiming he was Lingam answered. When told that the appellant and his wife were earning $29,000 to $30,000 a year, Lingam said that they were not eligible to employ a foreign maid. Lingam asked for his phone and pager numbers. The appellant gave him his pager number.
33 Sometime after 10 April, Lingam contacted the appellant. Lingam went to the appellant`s flat with PW2 and introduced her to him. He suggested that the appellant employ PW2 as a part time maid until he got the appellant`s application approved. PW2 would work from 7am to 11am, Mondays to Fridays. He signed the agreements with Lingam and paid $600 for an application for a full-time maid. The appellant asked about work permits and was told that this was kept by the agency as the maids were bonded to it.
34 PW2 started work around 20 April 1994. She had paged for him from Valli`s place. One of the numbers given by Lingam was the same as Valli`s. He had written them down. He had given them, as well as copies of the contracts, to the Immigration Department. PW7 did not give him a receipt.
35 In mid-May, PW2 began to come in late or not at all. The appellant complained to Valli. After the appellant`s father died in July, she again did not turn up for work regularly. She complained of abdominal pains. The appellant sent her to the doctor because he did not believe her. She did not turn up for work on 15 August 1994. He complained again to Valli. He also told her that he could never contact Lingam, and that if Lingam did not contact the appellant, he would lodge a police report as he had taken $600 from the appellant for his application for a full-time maid.
36 On 23 August, the appellant went to another agency, Khomet agency. They told him that they would try to get his application approved. On the same day, he lodged the police report at Ang Mo Kio Police station. PW1 made the telephone call to Valli`s place. He asked the appellant to help to detain PW2. The appellant`s mother paged and the appellant`s tenant, DW2, told him that PW2 had gone to the flat. He made the report as documents were missing. These documents were placed on top of a rack, after he had shown them to PW2. He later found some of the documents and the photocopies behind the rack. The original contracts and the receipt from Lingam were still missing. He had handed the photostat copies of the contracts to PW7. He had not searched the place thoroughly the first time.
37 The appellant insisted that PW7 had told him about Ravindran. PW7 asked for $5,000. However, he refused to say whether the $5,000 was supposed to be a bribe for PW7. He lodged a report with the Corrupt Practices Investigation Board (CPIB) on advice from his solicitors. He claimed that PW7 did not record down certain statements he had made to her.
38 Cross-examination revealed that the appellant worked the night shift from 10pm until 10am. He worked on alternate days. However, he also worked overtime on his off days.
39 The appellant claimed that he obtained the number `2579345` from Lingam. The card with Valli`s phone number on it was found by him, after the investigating officer asked him to look for it.
40 DW2, it will be recalled, was the tenant at the appellant`s flat. He worked as an engineer at a construction site and was in possession of an employment pass. He saw the maid after he came back from leave in India, which was between 7 and 30 May 1994. His normal working hours were from 8am to 5pm. However, he worked overtime, so he was at the site till 9pm, and only left for home between 10pm and 11pm. When he left for work in the morning, PW2 had not arrived. However, if he left late at 9am or 10am, because of an exceptionally late night`s work, he would see her. If she had slept in the living room, he would have seen her. He did not see any of PW2`s toiletries in the bathroom.
41 There were three bedrooms in the appellant`s flat. The master bedroom was occupied by the appellant and DW4. DW2 occupied a bedroom. Another tenant occupied the last bedroom. The appellant and DW4 used the bathroom in the master bedroom. DW2 used the kitchen bathroom. He had never seen PW2 sleeping in the appellant`s flat. Neither did he see any of her belongings there. He did not speak to the maid as he did not speak Tamil. He could only speak English and an Indian dialect.
42 On 23 August 1994, he came home at about 10pm. He had left his grocery near the door and had gone to the bathroom to wash his feet. When he returned to collect the grocery, he saw PW2. PW2 asked if the appellant was in, by saying, `Guna, Guna.` PW2 was with another woman. DW2 let PW2 in and went to his room. When the appellant called, he told him that PW2 was there. The appellant returned at about 11pm. There was a heated conversation between the appellant and PW2. At about 11.30pm, two officers came. He closed his door and slept.
43 Under cross-examination, DW2 agreed that he was seldom in the flat, as he was usually at work. He only spent one Sunday a month at the flat. When he returned home, he did not switch on the lights. However, he insisted that, even without the lights, he was able to see if anyone was sleeping in the hall. He had seen a `granny` (meaning the grandmother) sleeping there before. He once saw PW2 taking care of the baby on a Sunday.
44 The appellant`s wife, DW4, testified that PW2 first went to the appellant`s flat at the end of April. She asked the appellant about the levy and was told by him that the agent took care of everything. She saw the agreement two or three days later. The agreement was with Mahalingam`s Maid Agency. She did not see the photocopy or the agency agreement. PW2`s working hours were from 7am to 11am.
45 In mid-May, PW2 was regularly absent. DW4 took her to the clinic on 14 August on the suggestion of the appellant. On 18 August, DW4 arranged to meet PW2 at the clinic. Nobody else was with PW2. The doctor referred PW2 to the Tan Tock Seng Hospital. She did not take PW2 to the hospital. She wanted to inform the appellant first, which she did over the phone. The appellant went home at about 11am and spoke to PW2. He also called Valli, whom she said was PW2`s agent.
46 DW4 did not give PW2 a piece of paper for her to keep an account of her salary. She did not see PW2`s husband`s photograph. Neither did she mark on a calendar the day PW2 started work. She took her bath in the master bedroom toilet. PW2 did not live in the flat. PW2 did not cook. DW4 prepared the meals. She had never spoken to Valli or Lingam. The child in the photographs was not her daughter.
47 DW4 said, under cross-examination, that she sent her child to her uncle`s place nearby if PW2 did not turn up. She waited until 8am for PW2. Sometimes she had to take urgent leave. On other occasions, the appellant cancelled his overtime. When asked about her statement to the Immigration Department, in which she said that the child in the photo looked like her daughter but it was not very clear, she said that she told PW7 that it was not her daughter. However, PW7 told her that since it was not clear, it was best to answer that way. When asked about her statement, made on 1 September, where she had said that she took PW2 to the clinic on 18 August, she initially expressed doubt about whether the signature was hers or PW7`s, as their names were alike. She then confirmed it was hers but said that the place in which the statement was recorded was noisy and that she had wanted to get out of there.
48 She said that she told PW7 about Valli. When asked where in her statements did she mention Valli, she said that PW7 only asked her about Lingam. She insisted that she knew there was an agent called Valli.
49 DW3`s evidence was that she looked after the appellant`s child when PW2 was not around. On those occasions she saw PW2. She did not know whether the appellant and his wife had any problem with PW2. She denied going to the clinic with DW4 and PW2. She first met PW2 during the funeral of her father. She denied that the child in the photograph was the appellant`s child.
50 The prosecution`s additional evidence
51 The prosecution called PW8, Quek Jen Juan, who was an officer with the Ministry of Labour. His evidence was that the Ministry did not permit employment agencies to engage part time maids. He also informed the court what happened when an employer filed an application for a work permit to bring in a foreign maid. An application should only take a couple of weeks to process and not three months, unless there was an appeal. There was no record of a Mahalingam`s Maid Agency.
52 Cross-examined, he confirmed that there had been complaints of agencies keeping maids` passports. If an applicant used an agent to apply for a maid, the agent would usually submit the application, but the employer had to sign the form.
53 The finding below
54 The district judge held that PW2 was a `mature, dignified and completely truthful witness.` She was of the view that it was clear that Lingam and Ramanathan existed and that they had supplied PW2 to the appellant.
55 She felt that the appellant`s evidence about the loss of the documents was `absolutely absurd`, as PW2 could not read English. His evidence was that PW2 had returned the copies to the flat. It showed the extent to which he was prepared to lie. If the documents existed, it could be inferred that they would not be in his favour. She did not accept that PW7 had lost the photocopies. In her view, the appellant lodged a false report with the police to get PW2 arrested, so that she would be repatriated at the Government`s expense. Furthermore, the appellant had tried to discredit PW7 by alleging that she had asked him for $5,000. He faltered when asked to confirm whether she asked for a bribe. Yet he lodged a report about her at the CPIB.
56 The district judge held that DW3 lied as easily as the appellant. Her denial, that she went with PW2 and DW4 to the clinic, was an attempt to counter PW2`s evidence that she had overheard DW3`s conversation with DW4. The district judge was also of the view that DW4 had tailored her evidence to match the appellant`s.
57 In the district judge`s view, DW2`s evidence was not very persuasive. He was away from 7 May to 30 May. He left the flat at 7am and only arrived home between 10pm and 11pm, when the lights were out. When the appellant`s father passed away, the family moved out to stay with his mother for a while. There were days when PW2 did not turn up. DW2 also spent only one Sunday a month in the flat. There were, therefore, not many days on which DW2 could see PW2.
58 PW2`s evidence, that her two bags were `in the toilet next to my bed`, in the district judge`s view, showed that she slept in the master bedroom bathroom. It was not unlikely that, in view of the lack of space, the master bedroom bathroom was used for storage and PW2`s sleeping area. DW2 had never stepped into the master bedroom. In any event, it was not put to PW2 that DW2 had never seen her sleeping in the flat. She was not given an opportunity to challenge DW2`s evidence. She could have slept in the hall only when the male tenants were not around or had retired to bed.
59 The district judge also noted that when PW2 went to see the doctor, her address was stated as that of the appellant`s. This was obviously given by DW4. Throughout the trial, the appellant could not provide any other address except that of Valli`s. Furthermore, PW2 knew the particulars of the appellant`s family very well. She even returned `home` on the night of 23 August.
60 She concluded that the appellant could not cope without a full-time maid. He did not qualify for a foreign maid, so he more cheaply engaged an illegal one. He clearly knew that PW2 was an overstayer when he employed and harboured her. When she fell ill, he was in a quandary and decided to get rid of her, by falsely reporting to the police that she had committed theft. She disbelieved the appellant`s evidence that PW2 was a part-time maid and that he thought that agents of part-time maids kept the work permits and passports. She was, therefore, of the view that it had been proven, beyond reasonable doubt, that the appellant knew that PW2 was an overstayer. The appellant was convicted on both charges.
61 The appeal
62 The appeal was a purely factual one. Taking a broad view of the matter, the district judge`s finding could be said to amount to the following. The appellant could not qualify for a foreign maid, so he engaged an illegal one from a less than reputable agency. The maid fell ill. The appellant found himself in a quandary. Therefore, he decided to get rid of the maid, by making a false police report against her for theft, in the hope that the police would discover that she was an immigration offender and repatriate her.
63 It seemed to me that this story bordered on the incredible. It was hard to imagine how any reasonable person could possibly think that he could distance himself from an overstayer he had employed, and harboured, by reporting her to the police . That would have been the quickest way to draw attention to himself. It would have been much easier to turn her out by telling her that she was no longer needed. After all, being an overstayer, it was unlikely that she would lodge any sort of complaint. As the overall story was unlikely, it was necessary to scrutinize PW2`s evidence carefully. The prosecution`s evidence must be so convincing that it can be believed despite the unlikelihood of its version of events.
64 I was unable to accept the district judge`s assessment of credibility. It was hard for me to see how PW2 could be said to be a truthful and credible witness. Even from the records, it could easily be seen that her evidence was riddled with inconsistencies and contradictions. Furthermore, she changed her position often. There were also a number of improbabilities in her evidence.
65 Her evidence of when she arrived in Singapore clearly did not match the statement of facts, which she had admitted to when she was prosecuted, which stated that she arrived on 24 March 1994. She had even given this date to the investigating officer. Her answer, that she was confused, was hard to accept, in view of the fact that she could not account satisfactorily for the days she had been in Singapore prior to being employed by the appellant. She shifted her position when cross-examined about her previous employment. It seemed clear that she was hiding something. She was less than forthright about her agent, having told the police and the court different versions. There was no reason for her to testify that she did not give Ramanathan`s name to the appellant, and that she had told the appellant that her agent was Lingam. Her earlier testimony was that it was Ramanathan who took her to the appellant. Both versions were giving during examination-in-chief.
66 The fact that her embarkation card could not be found was suspicious. If somebody else had used her embarkation card, then it suggested that the agency, whatever its name, was a fairly sophisticated syndicate. PW5`s and PW6`s evidence was very unsatisfactory. They did not seem to know what happened in their own office.
67 As for Valli, it was hard to believe that she could be in a position to allow PW2 to stay at her place if she was, as the prosecution once suggested below, merely an illegal maid. In any event, that was a difficult suggestion to accept, for according to PW2, she attended Valli`s brother`s birthday party at Valli`s residence. PW7 had herself spoken to someone who claimed that she was Valli. The status of Valli was highly suspect. She was clearly someone who was deliberately avoiding the authorities. If one analysed PW2`s evidence, instead of taking it at face value, she could not have been a mere illegal maid. It was also questionable whether a mere acquaintance would allow PW2 to falsely use her name to see a doctor.
68 Turning to the district judge`s reasoning, I must say, with regret, that I found none of it particularly convincing. The district judge did not accept that the documents could have been stolen by PW2, because PW2 could not read English. However, it was never the appellant`s contention that PW2 stole the documents. All he said was that the documents were missing and he suspected PW2. In any event, PW2 had the keys to the flat. Anybody, including someone from the agency, could have gotten in. It was also never the appellant`s evidence that PW2 returned the photocopies. All he said was that he found them behind the rack. When asked how they got there, he did what he was asked to do, and speculated. The appellant`s evidence about the loss of the documents was `totally absurd` because he was asked things which he claimed no knowledge of. This should be weighed against the suggestion that the appellant wanted to get rid of PW2 by reporting her to the police. Both were just as difficult to accept.
69 It was unfair to penalize the appellant merely because he suspected that something was not right about the alleged request for $5,000. The evidence on this was patchy. It cannot be said whether such an incident did or did not occur. In any event, it was not the proper forum to deal with the matter. Merely because the appellant refused to take a clear stand that it was meant to be a bribe should not prejudice him. He reported the matter to the CPIB because he was advised by solicitors to do so.
70 What was particularly disturbing was DW2`s evidence. DW2`s evidence was unequivocal. There was little reason for him to lie and the district judge could not hold that he did. His evidence was that PW2 did not sleep in the appellant`s flat. With respect, the district judge`s interpretation of PW2`s evidence, that the bags were `in the toilet next to my bed`, as meaning that PW2 slept in the master bedroom bathroom, was without foundation. PW2 had previously given evidence during examination-in-chief that she slept in the hall. In fact, one would have thought that the natural interpretation of that phrase was that the bathroom was next to PW2`s bed and not that she slept in the bathroom. DW2 also said that the appellant and his wife used the master bedroom bathroom. Against this was the suggestion that they shared the kitchen bathroom with the tenants and PW2. One did not have to be in the flat very often to know whether the landlords used the master bedroom bathroom or the kitchen bathroom. DW2`s evidence that he did not see any of PW2`s toiletries in the kitchen bathroom also could not be discounted. It was contradictory for the district judge to scrutinize DW2`s evidence on the basis that there were days when PW2 did not turn up for work. If PW2 was a live-in maid, there would be no question of her not turning up.
71 There was no reason why it should be put to PW2 that DW2 had not seen her sleeping in the hall. It had already been put to her that she was lying and that she never lived in the flat. DW2 was not called to prove that he did not see PW2 sleeping in the flat. He was called to support the contention that PW2 was lying.
72 The burden remained on the prosecution to prove that the appellant harboured PW2. In seeking to do so, the prosecution relied solely on the evidence of PW2. The fact that PW2 knew much about the appellant`s family was neither here nor there. Furthermore, PW2 did not return `home` when told that the police were looking for her. She was told by Valli to go to the appellant`s flat. Against PW2`s evidence was the impartial and clear testimony of DW2. Given the numerous contradictions in PW2`s evidence, it was unsatisfactory to prefer her evidence over that of DW2`s.
73 Even though the district judge had the advantage of observing the demeanour of PW2, it is trite law that, in an appeal, this finding must be analysed in the light of all the objective evidence, especially her own testimony. In PP v Yeo Choon Poh [1994] 2 SLR 867 at p 878, I said in the Court of Appeal:
... the principle is that an impression as to the demeanour of the witness ought not to be adopted by a trial judge without testing it against the whole of his evidence.
74 This applies regardless of whether the witness was the prosecution`s or the defence`s. In the present case, I was of the view that the district judge did not give adequate weight to the contradictions and lies told by PW2, when she came to a conclusion as to PW2`s veracity. I was firmly of the view that PW2 was not a credible witness. With the greatest respect to the district judge, she placed far too little weight on DW2`s evidence. That being so, the finding that the appellant harboured PW2 was against the weight of the evidence.
75 So far as knowledge in relation to the employment charge was concerned, the burden was on the prosecution to prove this beyond reasonable doubt. From the terms of s 57(8), Parliament intended to draw a distinction between one who employed immigration offenders in the course of business and a householder who employed a maid. The former could be expected to know something about the legal requirements and procedures for employing a foreign worker, as well as what to look out for in order to detect an immigration offender. The evidential burden is thus on him to prove that he did not employ the immigration offender knowingly. There is no such burden in the latter case. There was none on the appellant.
76 The prosecution, again, chose to discharge this burden by relying solely on the words of PW2. This might be expected as there would usually be scant evidence. However, PW2`s evidence of how the appellant knew that she had no work permit and was an overstayer was not easy to believe. Her evidence was that she told the appellant that she wanted to go home. For some strange reason, the appellant then told her that she was an illegal worker, a fact which she claimed she did not know until she was told this by the appellant.
77 There was no evidence that the appellant intentionally looked for an illegal overstayer. No meaningful evidence was extracted from anyone remotely connected to the agency, which undisputably existed, and probably operated out of PW5 and PW6`s office. PW8`s evidence was unhelpful to the prosecution. It was quite irrelevant to the issue of whether the appellant knew that PW2 was an illegal worker. On the contrary, his evidence that some agencies kept maids` passports was of some assistance to the appellant.
78 The result then was that much effort was spent on evaluating the credibility of PW2`s evidence. Much time was also spent on whether PW2 was a part-time or a full-time maid. It was not very clear exactly what those terms were intended to mean. It was questionable what assistance this was to the court, as the evidence suggested that although PW2 worked a longer period than from 7am to 11am, as contended by the appellant, she did not do as much work as she said she did.
79 There was little other evidence from which it might be inferred that the appellant knew or shut his eyes to the obvious. Instead, the emerging picture suggested that there was a real possibility that the appellant might have been the victim of a rather sophisticated syndicate, some members of which PW2 and other prosecution witnesses were not willing to expose. The discrepancy between PW2 and PW4`s description of Ramanathan, even allowing for inaccuracies during translation, was remarkable. As has been earlier noted, PW7 abandoned any serious effort to locate Valli. It was, of course, wholly a matter for the investigating authorities whether or not to pursue a particular line of inquiry. Unfortunately, the failure in the present case to investigate Valli exposed a weakness in the prosecution`s case, which in the end turned out to be quite material.
80 No doubt the appellant was a CISCO officer, and on that count, could be said to be someone more worldly wise than most laymen. Thus, he was less than prudent in believing whatever it was that the agency told him. This might have led the district judge to suspect that he did in fact know, or had at least shut his eyes to the fact, that PW2 was an immigration offender. This was exacerbated by what she perceived to be DW4`s obvious desire to help her husband in court.
81 However, the appellant`s action in reporting her to the police was hard to square with this finding. This, together with DW2`s rather clear testimony, PW2`s lack of credibility and the gap in the evidence relating to Valli, must create a reasonable doubt.
82 As in Yeo See Koon Jimmy v PP [1994] 3 SLR 539 , where both the prosecution`s and the defence`s versions of the events were equally tenuous, the benefit of the doubt must be given to the defence, for the burden lay on the prosecution to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. In that case, I said at p 549:
... for, however tenuous that defence might have been, the burden still lay on the prosecution to prove the appellant`s guilt beyond reasonable doubt; and in discharging that burden, it was simply insufficient for them to point to the inadequacies of the appellant`s testimony.
83 Given the totality of the evidence, I was of the view that the prosecution could not be said to have mounted this threshold. At most, there was only a case of grave suspicion that the appellant was guilty. This, however, was not sufficient to discharge the prosecution`s burden. There were too many unexplained queries and unsatisfactory aspects in the case, mainly stemming from PW2`s testimony. The conviction on this charge was unsafe.
84 In the event, although I was most reluctant to disturb a first instance finding of facts, nevertheless, I had to allow the appeal. Accordingly, I quashed both convictions.
85 Appeal allowed.
James Bahadur Masih (James & Bala) for the appellant
Jaswant Singh (Deputy Public Prosecutor) for the respondent