This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

In the High Court of the Republic of Singapore
[1997] SGHC 112
Suit 4141/1983, 4149/1984
Between
Fook Gee Finance Company Limited
… Plaintiff
And
Liu Cho Chit
… Defendant
grounds of decision

This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Fook Gee Finance Company Limited v Liu Cho Chit
[1997] SGHC 112
Suit 4141/1983, 4149/1984
Lai Siu Chiu J
30 April 1997
1 JUDGMENT:
2 Cur Adv Vult
3 The undisputed facts
4 The plaintiff (Madam Lim) in Suit 4149 of 1984 is the wife of Liu Cho Chit (Liu), who is the defendant in Suit 4141 of 1983. Liu was, at the material time one of the contractors of the Housing and Development Board (HDB) and conducted his business through his company, Hoe Huat Construction Pte Ltd.
5 Liu was also the managing director of Peng Ann Realty Pte Ltd (PAR). Together with Koh Chee Chong and Yip Ho Meng, they were the only directors and shareholders of PAR, each holding one share with a par value of $1. Yip Ho Meng was the nominee of one Lok Bok Sim, who was then the managing director of Singapore Finance Limited.
6 Sometime in July 1972, PAR bought a parcel of land situated at Kampong Chai Chee comprising lots 21-26, 4-4, 4-7, 120, 121, 122, 123 and 221 of Mukim 28, having an area of 186.7 acres (the property). The purchase price of $1.09m was financed entirely by a loan of $1.5m from Singapore Finance Limited secured by a legal mortgage on the property and personal guarantees of the three directors.
7 On 20 July 1972, shortly after the purchase of the property, two of the lots, namely Lots 221 and 4-4 with a total area of about 5.8 acres were gazetted by the Government for acquisition. In due course, these two lots were compulsorily acquired. Soon after the gazette notification, Liu and his co-directors of PAR decided to sell the remaining six lots, as they were worried that there would be further acquisition of the remaining lots.
8 In December 1972, Liu was introduced to Tan Geok Tee (Tan), the second defendant in Suit 4149 of 1984, and following negotiations between the two of them, a sale and purchase agreement was made on 23 January 1973 (the Main Agreement) between PAR and Collin Investment Pte Ltd (CIP) whereby PAR agreed to sell to CIP three of the lots, namely Lots 21-26, 4-7 and 123 (the three lots), with a total area of about 178 acres at the price of $2.05m. CIP is one of Tan's family companies and is now known as Lee Kai Investment Pte Ltd (LKI) which is the third defendant in Suit 4149 of 1984.
9 The three lots were within five zones under the master plan, that is, rural, permanent residential, temporary residential, water catchment and open space. The area zoned permanent residential was situated in Lots 21-26 and 4-7. However, it only occupied about 4.6 acres in Lot 21-26. The Main Agreement was signed by Liu on behalf of PAR and by Tan on behalf of CIP.
10 During the negotiations leading to the Main Agreement, Liu and Tan orally agreed to develop jointly the 4.6 acres in Lot 21-26, zoned permanent residential. The terms of the joint venture were subsequently reduced in writing, and made in the names of Liu's wife (Madam Lim) and Tan's daughter (Collin Tan). These terms were embodied in four documents, (the Joint Venture Agreements), all of which were backdated to 23 January 1973. Briefly, the Joint Venture Agreements were as follows:
11 First, there was an agreement (the Sub-sale Agreement) whereby CIP agreed to sell to Madam Lim and Collin Tan part of Lot 21-26 zoned residential and described as "approximately 5 acres" (the joint venture site) for $50,000. This agreement was signed by Tan on behalf of CIP and also on behalf of Collin Tan, and by Liu on behalf of Madam Lim. Clause 7 of the Sub-sale Agreement provided that the purchase "shall be completed on the day when a separate title has been delivered for the property". The agreement also provided, inter alia under cl 9:
12 Special Condition 1
13 The Purchasers on behalf of the Vendor shall immediately after the signing of this Agreement apply to the Chief Planner or other relevant authority for the purpose of obtaining separate title for the property. The costs and expenses in respect of the subdivision and the survey for the purpose of enabling the Vendor to validly convey the title of the property to the Purchasers shall be borne by the Purchasers.
14 Special Condition 4
15 Should the Purchasers fail to obtain approval for the subdivision aforesaid, the property described in the First Schedule hereto shall be developed by the Purchasers in the name of the Vendor and in such event, the Purchasers shall be entitled to all the benefits of the development and responsible for the liabilities incurred thereby.
16 Next, there was an agreement (the Second Agreement) in which Madam Lim and Collin Tan were to procure the incorporation of a company, Collden Realty Pte Ltd (Collden), with an authorised capital of $2m. Clause 5 provided that immediately upon the incorporation of Collden, the parties were required to take steps to procure the sale by Madam Lim and Collin Tan of the joint venture site to Collden.
17 By Clause 8 of the Second Agreement, it was provided (notwithstanding their respective proportions of shareholding in Collden) that Collin Tan would bear 80% and Madam Lim 20% of the development costs of the joint venture site. It was further provided that should Madam Lim fail to contribute her share of 20%, Collin Tan would advance the amount with interest at a rate of 10.8% per annum, provided that she should not be required to contribute such development costs in excess of $1.5m. Again, Tan signed this agreement on behalf of his daughter Collin, and Liu signed on Madam Lim's behalf.
18 A further agreement (the Collden Agreement) provided that Madam Lim and Collin Tan were to convey the joint venture site to Collden in return for 50,000 shares of $1 each, credited as fully paid, with Madam Lim receiving 22,500 shares (representing 45% of the interest in Collden) and Collin Tan receiving 27,500 shares (representing 55% of the interest in Collden). By Clause 2, it was agreed that Collden would accept the conveyance of the joint venture site "from CIP direct". Liu signed the Collden agreement on behalf of Madam Lim whilst Tan signed it on behalf of Collin Tan.
19 Lastly, there was the Fall-back Agreement, which was supplemental to the Sub-sale Agreement; this provided that in the event CIP failed to purchase the three lots under the Main Agreement from PAR, the Sub-sale Agreement would absolutely determine and become null and void and the sum of $50,000 paid thereunder would be forfeited and each party would have no claim against the other. Again, the Fall-back Agreement was signed by Tan on behalf of Collin Tan and by Liu on behalf of Madam Lim.
20 The sale under the Main Agreement was completed on 14 March 1973 and all three lots were conveyed on the written direction of CIP to Collin Development Pte Ltd (CDP), another company of Tan, which is now known as Lee Tat Development Pte Ltd (Lee Tat). The conveyance from PAR to CDP/Lee Tat was executed by Liu on PAR's behalf.
21 On 20 December 1973, Lee Tat, through their architects, Lim Chew Kuan & Associates, applied to the competent authority for planning permission for a proposed condominium development and a golf course on Lots 21-26 and 123. The joint venture site was excluded from the proposed development. The application was refused and a notice of refusal of written permission dated 21 September 1974 was issued. The reasons given for the refusal was that there was no proper access to the site and that the site would be affected by a 'Public Scheme'. An appeal was made to the Minister for National Development but the appeal was unsuccessful, and on 31 March 1975, Lee Tat were informed that the appeal had been disallowed.
22 About a year later, the three lots, except a portion of about 4.2 acres, were acquired by the Government. The unacquired land comprised of about 3.7 acres of the joint venture site and a portion of about 21,808 sq ft of land zoned rural, also part of Lot 21-26, which was immediately outside and adjoining the contemplated boundary of the joint venture site. The unacquired land was subsequently resurveyed and renumbered as Lot 1606. The Pan Island Expressway (PIE) now runs along the northern boundary of Lot 1606.
23 However, the Joint Venture did not materialise and neither Liu nor Tan (nor their respective nominees) took any steps to implement the terms of any of the Joint Venture Agreements. It appears that there were subsequent negotiations between Liu and Tan for the latter to acquire Liu's interest in the joint venture site and this culminated in the dispute before me. Thus, in June 1984, Madam Lim commenced this action in Suit 4149 of 1984. In essence, Madam Lim claimed specific performance of an agreement alleged to have been made whereby Lee Tat and/or Tan agreed to purchase her share in Lot 1606 for $3.8m in which Liu, for and on behalf of Madam Lim, had been paid part of the monies. Tan denied that any monies had been paid for that purpose and in turn claimed that the monies so paid were advanced as a loan to Liu. This latter dispute formed a separate issue which was brought by way of Suit 4141 of 1983. At trial, I decided to hear both suits together as the evidence and events which transpired were inextricably linked.
24 The plaintiff's claim in Suit 4149 of 1984
25 (i) Madam Lim's testimony
26 Madam Lim's testimony was as follows. She explained that she never involved herself in her husband's business affairs. However, she knew that in 1973, Liu had entered into a number of contracts in her name but she could not recall whether Liu had told her before or after the contracts were signed. Madam Lim said that she knew that the contract concerned the purchase of a piece of land and that Liu had informed her that he was buying the land jointly with a Hong Kong national. She did not, however, know of their contents, the price of the property or the outcome of these agreements. Nevertheless she had given her husband full authority to handle the matters pertaining to the purchase of the land. She did not pay for the property and the correspondence between her and any other parties involved had been prepared by Liu and all she did was to sign them without reading the contents. Madam Lim also claimed that she was unaware of Collin Tan's existence until the trial, all she knew was that this transaction pertained to a lady from Hong Kong.
27 (ii) Liu's version of events
28 Next, Liu testified as follows. During the negotiations leading up to the Main Agreement, Liu and Tan had orally agreed to develop the permanent residential zone in Lot 21-26 which was demarcated by Tan and marked as "plus-minus five acres", also known as the joint venture site, because at that time, neither Liu nor Tan knew the exact area of the land. According to Liu, it was Tan's idea to go into the joint venture to test Liu's experience in low cost housing and he wanted Liu to assist him in future projects. Moreover, Tan wanted to see if Liu had any confidence in the land, as if to assure Tan that the land would not also be compulsorily acquired.
29 Liu had agreed to accept less than 50% shareholding in the joint venture as he was not financially sound and would only want a small part in the joint venture. It was also Tan's idea that the project would be in the names of their nominees, Madam Lim and Collin Tan. Liu claimed that he had paid $25,000 under the Sub-sale Agreement and that he and Tan had signed this agreement before signing the Fall-Back Agreement. Moreover, consideration was never an issue between Tan and Liu and at no time between 1973-84 did Tan ever allege that Liu had not paid him the sum of $25,000.
30 On 6 March 1973, Tan nominated CDP another family company controlled by him, to take conveyance of the property in place of CIP. This was evidenced by a letter of that date by Tan, acting on behalf of CIP, authorising PAR to convey the land directly to CDP (see AB42). According to Liu, Tan told him that CDP was his own company and assured him that the rest of the agreements would still be valid even though the property was conveyed to CDP instead of CIP.
31 When queried as to whether his wife knew about the existence of the agreements, Liu said that he had informed her that he would be using her name for the joint venture with Tan but did not tell her anything else. It was normal for Madam Lim not to inquire into his business dealings.
32 Liu then sought to explain why subdivision had not been obtained under the Sub-sale Agreement for the joint venture site. He did not apply for subdivision immediately after signing the Sub-sale Agreement because the joint venture site and the property were still owned by PAR. When the property was conveyed to CDP in March 1973, Liu again did not apply for subdivision because Tan had told him that his company wanted to develop a golf course at the catchment area and houses would be build on land zoned 'rural' and 'residential'. It was agreed between them that Liu would not need to take any step to sub-divide the property under Clause 9 Special Condition 1 of the Sub-sale Agreement until the outcome was known of Tan's proposed application in the name of CDP for planning permission.
33 Pursuant to the arrangement, on 20 December 1973, CDP applied for planning permission for the proposed housing development and golf course on Lots 21-26 and 123. In applying for planning permission, Tan had deliberately excluded from the plans submitted, what was to be the joint venture site. These plans were prepared by the architects Lim Chew Kuan & Associates and were approved and signed by CDP (Plan 2ABD). If the project was approved, access would be provided for the property through Lot 21-26 and it would have facilitated the excision of the joint venture site.
34 However, the application to develop Lots 21-26 and 123 was refused on 21 September 1974 because the site was affected by a public scheme and there was no proper access. Liu advised Tan to lodge an appeal, which CDP did on 15 October 1974 but this appeal was subsequently disallowed. The government had by then embarked on a huge land acquisition exercise. Since the joint venture site, which was part of Lot 21-26 in respect of which the plans were submitted, was affected by the public scheme, Liu and Tan thought that Lot 21-26 together with the joint venture site would be included in the acquisition exercise and decided to wait and see the outcome of this exercise. As such, they had agreed not to do anything further.
35 On 27 July 1976, there was a gazette notification for the acquisition of the three lots as well as its surrounding areas. However, a portion of about 4.2 acres, part of which comprised the joint-venture site, was spared from the acquisition exercise. The parties were fully aware that if the unacquired portion was spared from acquisition, the government would conduct its own resurvey and would give a new title to that piece of land. This was subsequently confirmed when the government re-surveyed the land and the unacquired portion was renumbered as Lot 1606.
36 After the new certified plan for the property was issued for Lot 1606, Liu proceeded to discuss with Tan the development of Lot 1606 and he suggested employing the services of Architects 61. Liu then met up with one Yang Soo Suan (Yang) from Architects 61 to discuss the development of the property. According to Liu, when he first met Yang, he had already told Yang that Tan and he were joint developers of Lot 1606 and Yang had proceeded on that basis.
37 Subsequently, differences arose between Tan and Liu regarding the plans for the development. Tan had wanted to construct luxury flats for rental for long term investment whereas Liu wanted to sell the flats after construction. Tan also wanted better facilities and finish for the flats and this resulted in a rise in the development costs from $22m in October 1980 to around $30m in March 1981.
38 As a result of the differences in policies, Liu, in about February or March 1981, offered to sell his share to Tan. Originally, Liu had asked for $4.5m for his share. This was based on an offer from a third party of $12m for the whole of Lot 1606. Based on that offer, Liu could have asked for $6m for his half share but decided to offer it at a discount to Tan because Liu felt that he should give credit for expenses such as income tax, property tax and architects' fees which would have to be borne by Tan. Moreover, he did not mind suffering a small loss, since they could not agree on the type of development for Lot 1606 and he wanted to get out of the project.
39 Tan then invited Liu to Hong Kong sometime in April 1981, where the discussions were finalised and it was ultimately agreed that Tan would buy out Liu's share for $3.8m, net of tax. Tan agreed to pay $2m by 24 April 1981, and the balance of $1.8m would be paid two months thereafter. Liu said that he was not asked to sign a contract for the buy-out as at that time, Tan was busy and had other commitments, thus he did not ask Liu to enter into a written agreement.
40 On 23 April 1981, Tan handed to Liu two cashier's orders totalling US$642,451.04 (or the equivalent of S$1,368,420.70 at an exchange rate of approximately S$2.13 to US$1/-). Liu was asked to call at Tan's office the following day to collect the balance of the $2m but when Liu went to Tan's office, he was told that it was not convenient for Tan to pay and that Tan would do so at the end of the month. Upon returning to Singapore, Liu called Tan a few times whereupon Tan told him that his wife was not happy as she felt that Tan had purchased Liu's wife's share in the property at a high price. Tan thus asked Liu to sign a letter prepared by Tan Jue Chiu, Tan's general manager in Singapore, dated 28 April 1981, authorising payment by Lee Tat to Liu's bank account with Ka Wah Bank in Hong Kong, in the sum of US$293,555.99 by way of cashier's order (AB115). Tan said that he would pay the said sum once his wife had cooled down, and asked Liu to be patient with him.
41 Neither the sum of US$293,555.99 nor S$1.8m was ever paid by Tan or the other defendants. Curiously, some two years later, Fook Gee Finance Limited instituted proceedings to recover the sum of US$642,451.04 paid to Liu which they claimed was a loan. This is the subject matter of Suit No 4141 of 1983 which will be dealt with later.
42 As Tan's wife, Madam Ching had informed Tan that he was paying too high a price to purchase Madam Lim's share in the property and Liu had not been paid the balance of the sale price of his share to Tan, Liu then had a discussion with Madam Ching. Liu subsequently found an interested buyer who was willing to offer $12m for Lot 1606. Thus, on 2 June 1981, he wrote to Lee Tat informing them of the recent discussion with Madam Ching and of the said offer (AB131). In the same letter, Liu also confirmed the agreement by Lee Tat to purchase Madam Lim's interest in Lot 1606 and acknowledged that he had received the two cashier's orders as part of the agreed purchase price of $3.8m net of tax. The contents of Liu's letter state:
43 re: Mukim XXVIII Lot 1606
44 I refer to your agreement to purchase the interests of my wife in the abovementioned property.
45 I acknowledge that I have so far received on behalf of my wife two payments of US$174,982.49 and US$467,468.55 respectively totalling US$642,451.04 being part payment made by you of the purchase price agreed at S$3,800,000.00 net for my wife's share.
46 I also refer to my recent discussions with your Mrs. Tan and confirm that I have found an interested buyer for the abovementioned property who is prepared to offer S$12,000,000.00. Please let me know whether you are agreeable to sell at that price.
47 When Liu did not receive a reply from Tan or Lee Tat, he sent another letter dated 17 June 1981 to find out if the offer of $12m from the buyers, who were represented by M/s Lee & Lee, was acceptable (AB145); again he received no reply from Lee Tat or Tan.
48 It later transpired that Tan, on behalf of Lee Tat, had in fact replied directly to M/s Lee & Lee on 9 June 1981 (AB141) in respect of the offer to purchase the property at $12m stating that Lee Tat did not at any time own any property with another party. Despite his claim that there was no co-owner for Lot 1606, Tan went to Yang's office the next day and informed Yang personally that he had purchased Liu's share in Lot 1606 and had settled part of the consideration. This was evidenced in a letter (AB150) from Yang dated 26 June 1981 to Tan, which was copied to Liu, and in which it was stated:
49 We refer to the writer's meeting with your goodself on 10th June 1981 and wish to confirm your instruction to discontinue forthwith sending copies of all future correspondence in respect of the subject project to Mr. Liu Cho Chit. We were also advised that you have settled Mr. Liu's holding in the subject project and have settled part of the considerations.
50 Until we receive your further communication to the contrary, we assume that your instructions given on 10th June 1981 remain.
51 As Tan had persistently refused to reply to Liu's letters or pay the balance of the purchase price as agreed, Madam Lim through her lawyers, M/s Boey Ng & Wan gave notice on 23 June 1981 to Lee Tat that she was exercising her rights pursuant to Clause 7 of the Sub-sale Agreement (AB148). Liu's wife asked for completion as Liu was of the view that a separate title had been issued since the government resurvey had been completed and a new lot number had been allotted. Again Liu maintained that there was no response to any of his letters.
52 Meanwhile, on 31 July 1981, Liu also wrote to Yang of Architects 61 to inform Yang that although his wife had agreed to sell her interest in Lot 1606 to Lee Tat, the formalities were not yet completed (AB154). The contents of his letter were as follows:
53 Thank you for your letter of 26th June 1981. I am writing to confirm our conversation on the 2nd July 1981 when I informed you that while my wife has agreed to sell her interest in the above property to Lee Tat Development (Pte) Ltd, the formalities are not yet complete and therefore I would be obliged if you would continue to send me copies of all relevant correspondence until further notice.
54 On 26 August 1981 (AB163), Liu wrote to Lee Tat asking them to pay the balance of the purchase price for his wife's share in the property or to complete the Sub-sale Agreement; the letter reads:
55 I am surprised not to have received the courtesy of a reply to my letter to you dated 2nd June 1981.
56 You will recall that you agreed to purchase my wife's share in the above mentioned property for $3.8 million net of tax and you have so far paid the equivalent of S$1,368,420-70. A further instalment of some S$600,000-00 odd (to make up to S$2 million) was due on 28th April 1981, which you have refused without explanation to pay.
57 I am informed by Architects 61 that you informed them that you had purchased my wife's share and had therefore instructed them to cease sending me the copy correspondence concerning the purposed [sic] development. As you are aware, this is not true as you have yet to pay the balance of the agreed price. I have received a copy of the architects' letter to you dated the 26th June 1981 to which I have since replied.
58 Please let me know, without further delay, when you propose to complete our agreement. If you will instruct your solicitors to prepare the necessary documents, my wife will sign and deliver them to you against the release of the balance of the agreed price.
59 Again, on 14 September 1981, Liu wrote to Lee Tat stating as such (AB 167):
60 I write further to my letters to you concerning the above matter.
61 I now enclose herewith copy of letter from Messrs AR Rajudin, solicitors for an interested purchaser, for you to deal with him directly.
62 In the meantime, I would appreciate a reply to my last letter to you dated the 26th August 1981.
63 Then on 28 May 1984, Liu, through his wife, wrote a further letter giving the defendants a final opportunity to complete the matter and requested for the delivery of the title deeds within seven days. As he did not hear from Lee Tat after that, Liu commenced Madam Lim's present action in June 1984.
64 (iii) Yang Soo Suan's testimony
65 Yang was a senior partner of Architects 61 when he acted for Liu and Tan as the principal consultant of a proposed condominium project on Lot 1606. According to Yang, when he met Tan and Liu, he was told that they were joint developers under the name of Lee Tat and that Lot 1606 was held in Lee Tat's name. Yang also said that from the manner Tan and Liu conducted themselves when dealing with him, he was under the impression that they were co-owners of Lot 1606. For instance, between September 1980 until the plans for the joint development were submitted in March 1981, Liu was present at most meetings which Yang had with Tan. These meetings were mainly held at Tan's office and Liu attended them as a joint developer.
66 Moreover, it would not have been Architects 61's practice to copy letters to Liu if he was not the joint developer as well, especially since some of the letters were marked 'Confidential'. He also explained that Architects 61's practice of addressing its letters to Lee Tat and carbon copying to Liu was because it was his understanding that Lee Tat would be the vehicle for the joint venture.
67 In addition, his belief that Liu had an interest in Lot 1606 was confirmed when Tan personally told him that he had purchased Liu's interest in the project and paid part of the consideration. This was evidenced in the letter of 26 June 1981 from Architects 61 to Tan in which Yang confirmed Tan's instructions to discontinue sending copies of future correspondence in respect of the joint venture project to Liu as Liu's share in the project had been purchased by Tan.
68 When Yang received Liu's letter dated 31 July 1981 informing him that the formalities were not yet completed and that Yang should continue to send copies of relevant correspondence between Architects 61 and Tan/Lee Tat to Liu, Yang decided to write to Tan to clarify the matter (see eg. AB 155, 158). However, Tan did not reply to Yang's letters.
69 Yang had also written numerous times to Tan, between August to November 1981, seeking payment for the work done on the project (see AB 157, 158, 174, 179). No payment was forthcoming but Yang decided to continue with the project since he deemed it important to keep the project alive for the benefit of the developer in the hope that the project would materialise. However, on 20 January 1992, Architects 61 wrote to Lee Tat informing them that since Architects 61 had not received a reply to their demand for payment, their services for this project would be suspended. Architects 61 further stated that should they not receive a reply from Lee Tat within 7 days, their services for the project would be deemed to have been terminated (AB180).
70 Later, it transpired that Tan did not want Architects 61 to carry on with the project. This is evident from Lee Tat's letter to the Commissioner of Lands on 31 March 1983, regarding the proposed condominium project on Lot 1606 in which Lee Tat had instructed the Commissioner of Land to address all future correspondence direct to Lee Tat and not through Architects 61 as was previously done. Yang testified he was not informed by Tan of this nor did he receive a copy of the above letter. To date, Architects 61 have not been paid for their services although Yang had been involved in the project for some 2 years.
71 Yang was also queried about Tan's wife's participation in the project. In Yang's opinion, Mrs Tan was not an active participant in the project but she would occasionally call to see Tan. Hence there was a reference to her in his letter dated 26 May 1981 to Tan (AB129). She would also give her views on the proposed project, and she had mentioned to Yang that his ideas did not make use of the full potential of the land in terms of density.
72 The defendants' case
73 The first, second and third defendants, in their defence in Suit 4149 of 1984, had pleaded as follows. Firstly, Lee Tat and LKI denied that they had entered into any of the Joint Venture Agreements. Tan however admitted that shortly before 23 January 1973, he had orally agreed with Liu to jointly develop the joint venture site on a costs and profit sharing basis in the ratio of 55% to Tan and 45% to Liu. Pursuant to this oral agreement, Liu instructed his solicitors to prepare the Joint Venture Agreements. However Tan alleged that the Joint Venture Agreements were signed by him in reliance on the false and fraudulent representation of Liu that they embodied the said joint development agreement between Liu and him, alternatively, Tan was under a mistake as to their nature and contents and genuinely thought that he was executing instruments of a different kind or nature from that which he intended to execute.
74 Lee Tat and LKI further alleged that Tan had no authority whatsoever to have made the Sub-sale Agreement on their behalf. This allegation was later abandoned at the trial. However, Lee Tat also claimed that as they were only incorporated on 1 February 1973 and had not been in existence at the time of the alleged Sub-sale Agreement, they could not have authorised Tan to enter into the Sub-sale agreement or any of the Joint Venture Agreements on their behalf.
75 The defendants also contended that the Joint Venture Agreements had to be construed together and that the purpose of the agreements was to jointly develop the joint venture site through Collden. However, a period of some twenty years had elapsed since then and no steps had been taken towards the performance of the agreements. As such, the agreements had been abandoned and/or impliedly rescinded. Moreover, the Sub-sale Agreement was conditional upon the subdivision of Lot 21-26 of Mukim 28 being successfully applied for and a separate title for the joint-venture site being obtained by the purchasers as required under Clause 9(1) of that agreement, which the purchasers had failed to do.
76 In addition, the defendants alleged that Collin Tan and Madam Lim had not paid $50,000 under the Sub-sale Agreement; hence, LKI could not be liable to Madam Lim. Finally, the defendants claimed that as Madam Lim's cause of action had accrued more that six years prior to the commencement of these proceedings, her claim was accordingly barred by Section 6 of the Limitation Act (Cap 163). The plaintiff was also guilty of inordinate and inexcusable delay in bringing this action and was thus not entitled to any relief against the defendants.
77 The fourth defendant filed a separate defence. In gist, Collin Tan claimed that she had no knowledge of the Joint Venture Agreements at all. Moreover, in or about June 1981 and in 1984, she was a subject resident of Hong Kong and as such, was a 'foreign person' as defined under the Residential Property Act (Cap 274). Thus, even if the Sub-sale Agreement had been valid and binding, the alleged sale to Madam Lim and her was incapable of being completed as such completion would have contravened the provisions of the Residential Property Act.
78 Madam Ching Mun Fong's testimony
79 Madam Ching, Tan's widow, testified as follows. She was a director of many companies incorporated to acquire real estate for long term investment purposes and to undertake developments on land. Both Lee Tat and LKI were family companies. CIP was incorporated on 14 August 1972 and CDP was incorporated on 1 February 1973. On 28 May 1974, CDP and CIP were renamed Lee Tat and LKI respectively. The first directors of CIP were Collin Tan and herself. On 2 August 1973, she resigned and Tan was appointed director in her place. The first directors of CDP were Tan and Lai Kew Chai. On 2 August 1973, Lai resigned from CDP and Collin Tan replaced him. Madam Ching confirmed that she was at present one of the directors of Lee Tat and LKI.
80 Madam Ching claimed that around 1973, she was seldom involved in Tan's business and he would make the decisions. She also claimed that she did not know of the five agreements dated 23 January 1973. She only found out about them sometime in September 1983 when Tan was in Hong Kong and, after the action was commenced against Liu to recover the sum of US$642,451.04 which Madam Ching claimed had been lent to Liu. This is the subject matter of Suit 4141 of 1983, the facts of which will be dealt with in a while.
81 Madam Ching further stated that she was not aware nor was she involved in the negotiations to purchase the property from PAR. However she was aware that the purchase price was $2.05m and that Tan was buying the land primarily for investment purposes. She also knew that Tan wanted to turn the land into a private golf course.
82 Madam Ching said that she met Liu sometime towards the end of 1972 when she had gone with Tan to view the property. She alleged that Tan did not mention to her that he had entered into a joint venture with Liu to develop the plus-minus 5 acres. In cross-examination however, she admitted that she knew that Liu and Tan had entered into a joint venture.
83 As for the payment of $25,000 from Liu under the Sub-sale Agreement, Madam Ching alleged that Tan had never mentioned to her that he had received that amount from Liu. According to Madam Ching, if a sum of $25,000 had been paid to Tan, it would have been reflected in the company's accounts. Having perused through the accounts of CIP and LKI, no such payment was found to have been made.
84 Madam Ching also denied that both Yang and Liu were frequently at her husband's office to discuss the joint venture project. She also denied ever having any discussion with Liu on the possible sale of Lot 1606 to an interested buyer for $12m, referred to by Liu in his letter to Lee Tat dated 2 June 1981 (AB131). As for the other correspondence referred to -- AB131, 145, 150, 154, 163, 167, 174, 179 and 180, Madam Ching said that she had neither seen nor read them.
85 However, she admitted receiving the letters sent by Liu, where he made reference to the agreement to sell Madam Lim's interest for $3.8m, and although she knew that the letters were sent by Liu, she chose not to read them as she felt that he was an untrustworthy person.
86 Suit 4141 of 1983
87 (i) The plaintiff's case
88 The plaintiff in Suit 4141 of 1983, Fook Gee Finance Ltd (Fook Gee), is a moneylending company which has a licence under the Hong Kong Money Lender's Ordinance; Fook Gee was/is owned by Tan and Madam Ching. Essentially the plaintiff's claim is for the sum of US$642,451.04 which was allegedly lent to Liu who is the defendant, on 23 April 1981.
89 Fook Gee's case was based essentially on Madam Ching's testimony. Madam Ching proceeded to explain the sum of US$642,451.04 which Tan had paid to Liu. She denied that her husband had given Liu that sum of money as part payment for Liu's interest in Lot 1606. Instead, she claimed that the sum of money was a loan from Tan to Liu.
90 Sometime in January 1981, Liu had approached Madam Ching at her office in Singapore to ask for a loan. Liu explained to her that he was a contractor, that he was facing financial difficulties as he could not get payment from HDB and his bank refused to extend a loan to him. Madam Ching did not want to give Liu a loan as she felt that he was not a trustworthy person. Her husband was not then in Singapore.
91 It is common ground that on 23 April 1981, two Bangkok Bank drafts totalling US$642,451.04 were handed by Tan to Liu in Hong Kong. The third draft from Hongkong & Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC) for US$293,555.99 was not then ready and Liu was told to return to Tan's office the following day to collect it. Madam Ching claimed that initially she did not know that her husband had handed the two Bangkok Bank drafts to Liu.
92 It was only on 24 April 1981 when she was at Tan's office, that she was informed by the assistant manager that Liu had come to see Tan to borrow money and also told her about the three drafts. Madam Ching then proceeded to ask her husband whether Liu had provided any security or guarantee for the loan but Tan just kept quiet; Liu responded that he had not brought along any security. Madam Ching then asked Liu for the return of the two Bangkok Bank drafts as he had not provided any security.
93 According to Madam Ching, Liu replied that the two drafts were not with him at that moment but he promised to return them to her later. However, Liu failed to do so. Madam Ching then stopped Tan from handing over the HSBC draft. She also told her husband that although he was the boss and in charge of the family business, whilst she was merely a subordinate, he ought to be careful in how he ran his business. After all, as she testified in court, her husband had a habit of lending money without proper security. Madam Ching requested her husband to demand the return of the two drafts from Liu. Tan's reply was that Liu would return the money when his financial status improved.
94 It later transpired that the money for the two drafts came from Komala Deccoff & Co SA.(see 3AB1). Komala Deccoff was an import and export company owned by Tan and another person. However, Komala Deccoff did not have a moneylending licence and Madam Ching could not say whether her husband would have told Liu that the money which he was lending to Liu had come from this company. Questioned whether there was any evidence of the loan in either the books of Komala Deccoff or Fook Gee, Madam Ching said that she could not locate any evidence of a loan in either company's accounts, nor was she aware of whether there was a company resolution from Komala Deccoff to cover the loan agreement.
95 (ii) The defendant's case
96 Liu denied that the sum of US$642,451.04 was a loan and instead claimed that the money represented part payment under an oral agreement made on or about 23 April 1981 whereby he agreed, on behalf of his wife, to sell her share in Lot 1606 to Tan and/or Lee Tat for S$3.8m net of tax. The purchase price was to be paid by instalments in the following manner:
97 (a) US$642,451.04 on 23 April 1981;
98 (b) US$293,555.99 on or before the end of April 1981; and
99 (c) balance of S$1.8m within a reasonable date thereafter.
100 Liu averred that Tan and/or Lee Tat had refused to pay the second instalment of US$293,555.99 and the final instalment of $1.8m. In the alternative, Liu also claimed that if the sum was a loan to him, the alleged loan would be void and illegal and thus could not be enforced by virtue of ss 18, 22 and 23 of the Hong Kong Money Lender's Ordinance (Cap 163).
101 Liu had all along maintained that the sum of US$642,451.04 was part payment from Tan/Lee Tat for selling Madam Lim's interest in Lot 1606 to Tan/Lee Tat. As Liu had earlier testified, there were differences between Tan and him regarding the development of Lot 1606 and thus he decided to sell his interest to Tan.
102 However, when Liu subsequently offered to sell Madam Lim's share in Lot 1606 to Tan for $3.8m net of tax (for which he had received the first two instalments via the two Bangkok Bank drafts), Tan told him that his wife was not happy as she thought that Tan was buying Liu's share in Lot 1606 for too high a price. As such Tan suggested that Liu gave him a letter of authorisation to credit the remaining sum of money into Liu's bank account in Hong Kong to save Liu the trouble of having to go there again to collect the third and final payment. Tan promised that he would do so once his wife had cooled down. The letter of authorisation dated 28 April 1981, from Liu to Lee Tat, was prepared by Tan Jue Chiu, Tan's general manager in Singapore, and reads as follows:
103 I hereby instruct and authorise you to bank-in the Cashier Order for US$293,555.99 into my bank current account no. 018-6942168742 with the Ka Wah Bank Ltd (Head Office) in Hong Kong.
104 This letter was signed at Lee Tat's office in Singapore. However, Tan/Lee Tat contended that they never saw nor received this letter and the sum of money was never paid to Liu.
105 As Tan had failed to pay Liu the remaining sum due and Madam Ching had complained that the price offered by Liu was too high, Liu decided to look for potential buyers. When he found an interested buyer for $12m, he wrote to Tan/ Lee Tat informing them of the same. In the same letter, Liu also acknowledged the sums of money received as part payment for the purchase of Madam Lim's share in Lot 1606 (AB131).
106 In fact, on 8th June 1981, Messrs Lee & Lee, solicitors for an interested third party wrote directly to Lee Tat stating thus (AB135):
107 We act for Sin Kiaw Land Development Pte Ltd. We are instructed by our clients that you are co-owner together with Mr Liu Cho Chit of the above land. Our clients have met Mr Liu, and were informed that Mr Liu and you are willing to sell the above land to our clients at the price of $12 million.
108 We shall be obliged if you could confirm and let us know the other terms and conditions on which you are prepared to sell the land to our clients.
109 Further evidence that Madam Lim had a beneficial interest in Lot 1606 and that Liu was seeking a buyer for his/her share was found in a letter from a potential purchaser, one Tong It Enterprise Pte Ltd dated 10 June 1981, in which Kee Kah Seah, Tong It's managing director wrote as follows (AB142):
110 With reference to the discussion held at 292-B Macpherson Road, Singapore 1334, on June 9 1981, between your partner Mr Liu Cho Chit, Mr Kee Kah Seah, Mr Jason Lee and the broker Mr Tan Yew Seng, Mr Kee Kah Seah has confirmed that he will purchase the property subject to the following conditions:
111 (1) The purchase price is $12 million.
112 ....
113 Mr Liu have [sic] agreed to the above. Kindly confirm if it is acceptable to you.
114 However, sometime in August 1983 Tan decided to commence proceedings against Liu for the sums allegedly owed by him. The proceedings were commenced in the name of Fook Gee. Liu testified that the first time he had heard of Fook Gee's alleged involvement was 2 years after the two Bangkok Bank drafts were handed to him. This was when Tan sent a letter of demand in Fook Gee's name to Liu dated 15 April 1983 (3AB4) stating:
115 Re: US$642,451.04 (Loan)
116 The above loan of US Dollars Six Hundred Forty-Two Thousand Four Hundred and Fifty-One and Cents Four Only (US$642,451.04) was made to you through our Hong Kong Company, Fook Gee Finance Company Limited by two Cashier's Order from Hong Kong on 23 Apr 81.
117 Interest will be charged at 1.5% per month with effect from 23.4.81 until it is fully paid. I am giving you fourteen (14) days notice to settle in full failing which legal action will be taken without further notice...
118 Liu promptly replied on 27 April 1983 expressing his astonishment at receiving such a letter and at the alleged claim (3AB5). In the letter Liu denied having taken any loan from Fook Gee and stated that he had had no previous dealings with Fook Gee. Another letter of demand was sent by Fook Gee, through their solicitors Messrs Drew & Napier, on 4 May 1983 (3AB6) and following that, Liu's solicitors replied on 11 May 1983 (3AB7) in which they said:
119 ....
120 Our client denies that he is indebted to your clients in the sum of US$873,733.41 or US$642,451.04 or in any other sum. Our client has replied to your clients when they wrote to him on the 15th of April 1983 for the first time concerning a loan allegedly made to him some two years ago. We enclose herewith for your perusal a copy of our client's said reply dated 27th April 1983, the contents of which are self-explanatory.
121 Our client has received on behalf of his wife, S.S. Lim, the sum of US$642,451.04 in or about April 1981 in Hong Kong from Lee Tan Development Pte Ltd. of 2901 UIC Building, 5 Shenton Way, Singapore 0106. The payment was arranged by one Tan Geok Tee, a director of Lee Tat Development Pte Ltd and the sum represented part payment of the agreed purchase price of $3.8 million net of tax for the purchase by Lee Tat Development Pte Ltd of our client's wife's interest in the property known as Mukim XXVIII Lot 1606. Our client desires to make it very clear that he did not obtain the said sum as a loan from your clients. Indeed our client has not had any dealings of whatsoever nature with your clients.
122 ....
123 Messrs Drew & Napier replied on 27 July 1983, refuting Liu's claim (3AB 9) and said:
124 Your client's wife, Madam S.S. Lim, never had any direct interest in the land which you describe in the third paragraph of your letter. This land, and certain other parcels, was purchased by Collin Development (Pte) Ltd (now known as Lee Tat Development Pte Ltd) from Peng Ann Realty Private Limited, in or about March 1973.
125 There was, therefore, no conceivable reason why your client's wife should be paid the sum of US$642,451.04 by Lee Tat Development Pte Ltd in April 1981.
126 In fact, this sum was a loan from your client by our clients, as previously stated, and carries interest at 1.5% per month.
127 As the matter could not be resolved, Suit 4141 of 1983 was commenced by Tan.
128 The decision
129 (i) Suit 4141 of 1983
130 There are two issues in Suit 4141 of 1983 for my consideration. First, whether the sum of US$642,451.04 was a loan from Fook Gee to Liu. Second, if there was a loan, whether it was void and unenforceable as contravening the provisions of the Money Lender's Ordinance of Hong Kong.
131 At this stage, I think it would be best to deal with a preliminary point, that is, whether Fook Gee was the proper party to sue. In cross-examination, Madam Ching revealed that the money had come from two fixed deposit accounts owned by one of her family companies, Komala Deccoff (NE 250). It was also Madam Ching's evidence that it was her husband who had given Fook Gee instructions to institute proceedings. If that is so, then it should be Komala Deccoff and not Fook Gee who should be instituting proceedings. As such, the wrong party had instituted proceedings in Suit 4141 of 1983 and on this preliminary issue alone, the claim must fail.
132 Even if the alleged loan came from Fook Gee and the sum of money was merely, for convenience, issued from Komala Deccoff's accounts, as would seem to be suggested by Madam Ching (see NE 254D), I can find no evidence to suggest that Liu was aware of this. In fact, I can find no evidence to suggest that it was even a loan.
133 Firstly, there is no evidence as to how the money was treated in either Komala Deccoff's or Fook Gee's accounts. Madam Ching claimed that she had not looked at or examined the accounts of either company. In fact, Madam Ching had failed to comply with a Notice to Produce the books of accounts of either of the 2 companies and her explanation was that she could not trace the accounts. It would seem strange that whilst she claimed to have checked the accounts of CIP and LKI and found that no payment of $25,000 from Liu had been made under the Sub-sale Agreement, she could have failed to check the accounts of Komala Deccoff and Fook Gee to see if the sum of US$642,451.04 was lent to Liu, given that the latter sum was much larger than the former. Moreover, she could trace the accounts of CIP and LKI as far back as the early 1970s but could not find the books and accounts of Fook Gee or Komala Deccoff for 1981.
134 According to Madam Ching, Komala Deccoff would transfer funds to Fook Gee whenever the latter had insufficient funds. This bare allegation without any evidence surely cannot stand. Moreover, there was no evidence that there were any resolutions from either Fook Gee or Komala Deccoff covering the alleged loan. There was no evidence in writing either before or soon after the money had been advanced, spelling out the period of the loan, the rates of interest or the terms of repayment.
135 I did accept Madam Ching's evidence on one aspect, that is, she saw Liu in Tan's office in Hong Kong on 24 April 1981 when the two Bangkok Bank drafts were handed to him. However, I could not believe Madam Ching's evidence when she said that Tan had told her that the money was a loan to Liu and that Liu had told him that he would return the money when his financial status improved. I also did not believe her when she said that Liu had promised her that he would retrieve the two Bangkok Bank drafts and return them to her. What must have transpired on that day was that she discovered that Liu had sold his share in Lot 1606 to Tan and she was probably not pleased with the price Tan had offered to pay Liu, thinking that it was too high, as Liu had explained.
136 In any event, I believed Liu's testimony that the two drafts were handed to him by Tan as part payment for Madam Lim's interest in Lot 1606. There was extraneous evidence to support this finding. Firstly, there was the letter from Yang to Tan/Lee Tat dated 26 June 1981, in which Yang confirmed that Tan had purchased Liu's holding in Lot 1606 and had "settled part of the considerations". There was no evidence that Tan had ever disputed that. Furthermore, Yang himself testified that on 10 June 1981, Tan told him that he had bought Liu's share in the project, although he did not tell Yang what that share was, nor the amount he had paid Liu for it. In fact, Yang was under the impression during the entire period in which he was involved in the project, that Liu and Tan were co-owners of Lot 1606. Having observed Yang's demeanour, I accept that he was a forthright and credible witness and found that he had no reason to lie.
137 There was also a letter of authorisation dated 28 April 1981, from Liu to Lee Tat, which was prepared by Tan Jue Chiu, Lee Tat's general manager, whereby Lee Tat was authorised to credit into Liu's Ka Wah Bank account in Hong Kong, a cashier's order for the balance sum representing Madam Lim's beneficial interest in Lot 1606. I do not believe that Lee Tat or Tan never received this letter. In fact, Tan Jue Chiu had deposed in his affidavit that sometime in April 1981, Tan had telephoned him from Hong Kong and informed him that he had bought over Liu's share in Lot 1606 for $3.8m and had paid part of the purchase price. Tan Jue Chiu also knew of the two Bangkok Bank Cashier's Orders and confirmed that Liu had come to his office and asked him to prepare the letter of authority to pay a further sum of US$293,555.99 into his bank account in Hong Kong. I am mindful that Tan Jue Chiu's affidavit was not tested by cross-examination as he was not a witness. However the letter dated 28 April 1981 (AB115) was produced by Liu and I have no reason to doubt that it did exist at the material time, and it supports his version of the events.
138 Based on Liu's testimony, there was also evidence that he had looked for buyers for Lot 1606 when he had disagreement with Tan on the proposed development of Lot 1606; for instance Sin Kiaw Land Development Pte Ltd and Tong It Enterprise Pte Ltd were interested. Liu would not have gone to the trouble of looking for and meeting potential purchasers of Lot 1606 if he did not have an interest in it.
139 Moreover, I did not believe that Tan, being an astute businessman would have handed over the two Bangkok Bank drafts without any documentation of a loan, especially since the sums involved were substantial. After all, when Tan wanted to enter into the joint-venture with Liu, he had protected his interest with a Fall-back Agreement. This showed that he was careful in his business dealings.
140 In any event, it was Fook Gee's burden to prove that they had a claim for the sum of money based on a loan, and this they had failed to discharge. Moreover, as I had stated earlier, it seemed that the wrong party had sued; this claim must fail altogether. There is no necessity to consider whether the loan was unenforceable by virtue of the Hong Kong Money Lenders Ordinance, since I find that there was no loan at all.
141 (ii) Suit 4149 of 1984
142 It is a pity that Tan passed away in May 1993 -- his account of what actually transpired between himself and Liu would have been crucial. As for Madam Lim, I found her evidence to be singularly unhelpful as it was apparent that she did not involve herself in her husband's dealings, but had merely given her husband the authority to use her name for the proposed joint-venture.
143 Fraudulent misrepresentation and mistake
144 The first issue pleaded by the defendants was that the Joint Venture Agreements were signed by Tan in reliance on the false and fraudulent representation of Liu that they embodied the joint-development agreement, alternatively the agreements were void or voidable as they were executed under a mistake as to their nature and contents.
145 I do not think that this point has any merit. The defendants had failed to prove that there was a representation by Liu or Madam Lim which was false or that they or Tan were induced by the representation, if any. In any event, this issue would seem to have been abandoned in the defendants' closing submissions.
146 As for the defence of non est factum, it is trite law that a person of full age and understanding is normally bound by his signature to a document. It was established in Saunders v Anglia Building Society [1971] AC 1004 that although the defence of non est factum is not confined to blind or illiterate persons, any extension in the scope of the plea would be kept within narrow limits. Moreover, it must be shown that the document executed was fundamentally different from that which was believed to be and that the party misled must have taken precautions which a reasonable prudent person would have taken before signing the document (see Lee Siew Chun v Sourgrapes Packaging Products Trading Pte Ltd & Ors [1993] 2 SLR 297).
147 On the facts, this defence cannot succeed. Both Liu and Tan had jointly instructed solicitors, one Ng Kong Yeam, to prepare the Joint Ventures Agreements, they signed the same in Ng's presence. There was no reason to believe that Tan did not understand English, given that throughout, correspondence between Tan/Lee Tat to Architects 61 and to Liu were in English. Moreover, Tan, together with Liu, had placed their initials on all the pages of the agreements, including the plans attached thereto. As such, it was difficult to believe that Tan did not understand what he was signing, especially when he had legal advice.
148 Non-existence of LeeTat at time of the Sub-sale Agreement
149 The defendants then alleged that as Lee Tat was only incorporated on 1 February 1973, and not being in existence at the time of the Sub-sale Agreement, they could not have authorised Tan to enter into the agreement or any of the Joint Venture Agreements on their behalf. Again, I do not think that this contention can succeed. The Sub-sale Agreement and the subsequent agreements dated 23 January 1973, were premised on the basis that PAR would transfer and convey the 178 acres of the property to CIP and that CIP would then sell the plus-minus 5 acres to Madam Lim and Collin Tan for the joint venture development. However, upon Tan's own request, PAR transferred the property to CDP instead of to CIP, CDP being another of his family companies.
150 Moreover, this transfer, authorised by Tan in writing (AB42) on 6 March 1973, was also evident from the conveyance whereby the transferee of the property was CDP (AB42A). The conveyance of transfer was the clearest evidence which settled this issue beyond doubt. At the time of the authorisation, CDP had already been incorporated and it was not in dispute that Tan was the controlling mind and had actual authority to act on behalf of CDP, now Lee Tat. This was apparent from the fact that correspondence in the name of Lee Tat was signed by him. Further, it was Tan representing Lee Tat, and Liu, who had jointly instructed Yang of Architects 61 on the joint venture development of Lot 1606.
151 Whether Madam Lim had a beneficial interest in Lot 1606
152 One of the defendants' contentions was that Madam Lim and Collin Tan had never paid $50,000 under the Sub-sale Agreement, hence, the first and third defendants could not be liable to Madam Lim at all. This is inextricably linked to the question of whether Madam Lim had a beneficial interest in Lot 1606 and I shall deal with both issues together.
153 Having examined the evidence, I came to the conclusion that Liu did not pay $25,000 for his wife's share pursuant to the Sub-sale Agreement, but, for some unknown reason it was mutually agreed between him and Tan that the sum was treated as having been paid -- this must be so, based on their conduct.
154 Firstly, under the Sub-sale Agreement (cl 1), there was an acknowledgement from CIP that the money had been paid. This agreement was signed by both Tan and Liu in the presence of their solicitor Ng Kong Yeam. Secondly, the Fall-back Agreement provided that in the event CIP failed to purchase the three lots under the Main Agreement from PAR, the Sub-sale Agreement would absolutely determine and become null and void and the sum of $50,000 paid would be forfeited and each party would have no claim against the other. If the money was not treated as having been paid, the question of forfeiting the consideration would not have arisen.
155 The fact that Tan had insisted on the Fall-back Agreement showed how careful and astute a businessman he was, and this had been confirmed by Madam Ching in her testimony as follows (NE 265-267):
156 Q: Put that your husband was a man who was extremely careful with his money?
157 A: Yes.
158 Q: So he knew the value of a contract?
159 A: Yes he was very careful with contracts.
160 Q: If for one moment he was not handed any money he would never have acknowledged receipt of the same?
161 A: If money was received, our company would definitely issue a receipt.
162 Q: If your husband did not receive money, he would not have acknowledged receipt?
163 A: Yes.
164 Q: Especially if he had not received money in a written document?
165 A: Explain?
166 Q: (Repeats question)
167 A: Unless it was a blackmail.
168 Q: You testified PW2 [Liu] was untrustworthy. Did he strike you as being a blackmailer as well?
169 A: 100% yes.
170 Q: Has he ever blackmailed you?
171 A: No.
172 A: Has he ever extorted money from you?
173 Q: No.
174 It is clear from Madam Ching's own evidence that her husband would not have acknowledged receipt of a sum of money which he did not receive or treated as received, since he was "very careful with contracts". In any event, Madam Ching's attempt to paint Liu as a 'blackmailer' was a bid to discredit him, since there was no suggestion or evidence that he had blackmailed anyone, let alone Tan. Being an astute businessman, it was curious that Tan had from 1973 until his demise in 1993, never brought up the issue of non payment of the $25,000 nor complained that Liu had not paid the money, not even when he wrote to Lee & Lee on 9 June 1981 stating that Lee Tat did not own any property jointly with anyone else.
175 I also reviewed the conduct of the parties during the attempted joint venture when they employed Architects 61 and the correspondence which flowed therefrom. It was Yang's evidence that he was under the impression from their conduct, that Tan and Liu were co-owners, and subsequently he was also informed by Tan that he had purchased Liu's holding in Lot 1606 and had "settled part of the considerations". This was documented by Yang in his letter dated 26 June 1981 and there was no evidence that Tan had ever disputed that. I would repeat my earlier findings in Suit 4141 of 1983 to support my conclusion that Liu indeed had a beneficial interest in Lot 1606.
176 It is also pertinent to note that when Yang sent a letter to Tan (AB155) on 13 August 1981, enclosing Liu's letter (AB154) (as reproduced above) and asking for his instructions on the matter, Tan had not replied. If indeed Liu was not deemed to have paid the $25,000 under the Sub-sale Agreement, Tan would surely have replied to deny that Liu's wife had an interest in Lot 1606 since she had not paid the $25,000. Even up to 1981, Tan had not claimed that Madam Lim did not have a beneficial interest in Lot 1606. Also, I was satisfied in Suit 4141 of 1983 that Tan had paid Liu the sum of US$642,451.04 as part consideration for Liu's share in Lot 1606. If Liu was not treated as having paid for his share in Lot 1606, it would seem odd for Tan to have agreed to buy-out Liu's interest if the latter had none. There was also no evidence that Tan deducted or intended to deduct the $25,000 owing by Liu from his part payment of US$642,451.04. It was precisely because he had not paid, that Liu agreed to the forfeiture of his $25,000 under the Fall-back Agreement -- he would not thereby be out of pocket, bearing in mind that in 1973 $25,000 was a very substantial sum.. Liu had, in Madam Lim's Reply (para 5) pleaded that he had relied on the acknowledgement of Lee Tat, Tan and LKI that such payment was made, and the parties are thereby estopped from asserting to the contrary; I agree. I would add that it is equally unlikely that Tan paid the other $25,000 on behalf of his daughter.
177 I note that the court in Suit No 1487 of 1987 (see Peng Ann Realty Pte Ltd v Liu Cho Chit & Ors [1994] 3 SLR 576) found that Liu did not pay the $25,000 and the Court of Appeal did not disturb that finding (see Ching Mun Fong & Anor v Peng Ann Realty & Anor [1995] 2 SLR 541) although it reversed the finding of the court below that Tan knew the joint venture site would not be acquired. I arrive at the same finding except that in Suit No 1487 of 1987 I note that the court's finding was made on a different issue -- PAR sued Liu, Tan and others (including Yip Ho Meng) for conspiracy to defraud when they got wind of Madam Lim's present claim and alleged that it was only then that they became aware of the Joint Venture Agreements. The question for determination by the court there was whether Liu and Yip knew at the material time that the joint venture site would not in due course be acquired or could be left out of acquisition and whether Tan was privy to this knowledge when the Main Agreement and the Joint Venture Agreements were signed. In allowing PAR's claim, the court at first instance held, inter alia that, the price of $2.05m in the Main Agreement was 'inordinately low' for the three lots for someone who knew that (what became known as) Lot 1606 would not be acquired and more so when, after acquisition of the surrounding land, the previously landlocked Lot 1606 would have access to the PIE and other public roads, with considerable development potential.
178 As stated earlier, I did not find Madam Ching to be a credible witness; I agree with Liu's counsel that Madam Ching sometimes had a selective memory. Madam Ching had earlier denied that there was a joint venture between Liu and Tan but later changed her story and said that there was. She also denied having had a meeting with Yang where she had discussed the density and plot ratio of Lot 1606. Yet Yang had documented the discussion in his letter dated 26 May 1981 (AB129) and had testified that prior to 22 May 1981, although she was not active in Tan's affairs, she would occasionally call on Tan.
179 On the whole, Madam Ching's (DW1's) testimony was inconsistent and evasive -- for instance, when cross-examined by counsel for Madam Lim (NE 292):
180 Q: All in all I would say you are very pro-active in the management of your companies in Hong Kong and Singapore.
181 A: I am a very conscientious person in my work.
182 Q: I don't dispute that. That is why it is not possible you did not read any of the architects' letters or Liu's letters.
183 A: I don't know the answer.
184 Q: Try telling the truth?
185 A: I have never lied.
186 Court to DW1: Your answers are inconsistent.
187 From her own evidence (NE 273, 290-2), Madam Ching was in fact very active in the management of the family companies. She visited the offices in Hong Kong and Singapore often (NE 290) as well as construction sites (NE 245). Hence, it would seem strange that whilst taking a keen interest in the development of Lot 1606, she had not seen fit to read any letters of Liu or Architects 61 pertaining to the joint-venture.
188 In the light of my findings, I am of the view that Liu was treated as having paid $25,000, pursuant to the Sub-sale Agreement and that Madam Lim had a beneficial interest in Lot 1606. The defendants had failed to rebut this.
189 Whether the joint venture had been abandoned
190 The defendants also pleaded that the plaintiff had failed to take any steps to apply or obtain a separate title, and thus the Sub-sale Agreement had been mutually rescinded or abandoned. Moreover, the defendants alleged that the Sub-sale Agreement was conditional upon the subdivision of Lot 21-26 of Mukim 28 being successfully applied for and a separate title for the joint-venture site being obtained by the purchasers as required under Clause 9(1) of that agreement, which the plaintiff had failed to comply with.
191 Looking at the course of events that transpired after the property was conveyed by PAR to Lee Tat, I am of the view that the Joint Venture Agreements (apart from the Fall-back Agreement) had been abandoned. To elaborate, the Fall-back Agreement would have been fulfilled since PAR did convey the 178 acres of land to CDP, the latter having substituted CIP as the purchaser at the request of Tan. As such, the Fall-back Agreement would be of no relevance to this issue.
192 As for the other agreements between Liu and Tan, there are documents to show that after Lee Tat acquired the property from PAR, they had applied for planning permission for a proposed condominium development and a golf course on Lots 21-26 and 123. The joint venture site was excluded from the proposed development. I accept Liu's evidence that during the negotiations leading up to the Main Agreement, Liu and Tan had orally agreed to develop the joint venture site. I accept his explanation that it was agreed between him and Tan that he need not, under the Sub-sale Agreement, apply for subdivision of the joint venture site until the outcome of Tan's proposed application for planning permission was known. Thereafter, when the government embarked on its land acquisition exercise in 1974, Liu and Tan decided not to do anything further until the outcome of this exercise was also known. As such, it was with both parties' knowledge and consent that the joint-venture was put on hold.
193 However, although I found that Liu had an interest in the joint-venture site, and thus subsequently Lot 1606, neither Tan nor Liu had done anything to convey the property into the joint names of Madam Lim and Collin Tan. In fact, after the government acquisition exercise was finally over, the parties had proceeded to develop the property in the name of Lee Tat up to 1981 when Liu decided to withdraw from the project. I also observed that under the Sub-sale Agreement, the plot of land which was to be used for the joint-venture, which was described as "an approximate area of 5 acres as shown and edged in red in the plan annexed", was no longer the exact same piece of land which later formed the subject of the joint-venture. The latter was Lot 1606 which comprised 3.7 acres of the original joint-venture site as described in the Sub-sale Agreement and a portion of approximately 21,808 sq ft of land zoned rural, which was immediately outside and adjoining the boundary of the joint-venture site.
194 Thus, although the parties may have had intended the same project for Lot 1606 as for the original joint-venture site, and that Liu and Tan had intended to proceed with a joint-venture with both parties holding a respective interest in Lot 1606, nevertheless, I did not think that the parties had intended to proceed with the joint-venture as set out in the Joint Venture Agreements. The land used in the subsequent joint-venture was slightly different, Collden was never incorporated, no land was ever conveyed to Collden and neither Madam Lim nor Collin Tan were ever issued any shares in the company. As such, my only conclusion is that the Joint-Venture Agreements had been abandoned sub silentio (see Chitty on Contracts 27 ed Vol 1 p 1081 para 22-024).
195 This finding however does not affect Liu's beneficial interest in Lot 1606. It merely meant that when Tan refused to pay Liu the remaining purchase price for buying over the latter's share in Lot 1606, Liu could not have insisted on completion under clause 7 of the Sub-sale Agreement or, that the other Joint Venture Agreements be specifically performed.
196 Even if I am wrong on this finding and the joint-venture was still subsisting, it would have come to an end when Tan agreed to buy Liu's share in Lot 1606 for $3.8m in 1981. At this stage, the Joint Venture Agreements were terminated and the mere fact that Tan subsequently failed to pay Liu the remaining purchase price for his share, was irrelevant and could not restore the same. As such, Liu cannot now claim that there was a breach of the Sub-sale Agreement or any of the Joint Venture Agreements to develop the property.
197 The next question is whether the Sub-sale Agreement was conditional upon the subdivision of Lot 21-26 of Mukim 28 being successfully applied for and a separate title for the joint-venture site being obtained by the purchasers, as required under Clause 9(1) of that agreement, which Liu had failed to comply with. This issue would be irrelevant in view of my finding that the Sub-sale Agreement had been abandoned.
198 However, for completeness, I will deal with this contention. In my view, Clause 9(1) of the Sub-sale Agreement is not a condition precedent as the clause does not stipulate that its non-fulfilment renders the contract null and void. If anything, the failure of the purchaser to comply with Clause 9(1) would merely constitute a breach of the terms of the contract, and this would justify the vendor bringing an action on that breach. However, Lee Tat had not done so and in fact, as stated earlier, Tan had by his words and conduct waived Clause 9(1). This was particularly so when Tan and Liu proceeded to jointly develop Lot 1606 in or about 1980. Moreover, Clause 9(4) provided that should the purchasers fail to obtain approval for the sub-division, then the property would be developed by the purchasers in the name of the vendors, and the purchasers would be entitled to the benefits and be responsible for the liabilities incurred thereby. Thus, I am of the view that the Sub-sale Agreement was not conditional upon the subdivision of Lot 21-26 of Mukim 28 being successfully applied for and a separate title for the joint-venture site being obtained by the purchasers, as required under Clause 9(1)
199 The fourth defendant's case
200 The fourth defendant claimed that as she was not a Singapore citizen in 1981 or 1984, she was under a legal disability under the Residential Property Act ("RPA") during that period, to own residential land in Singapore. However, in my view, the RPA is not relevant as it only came into force on 11 September 1973 whereas the various contracts had already been entered into on or about 23 January 1973. There was clearly no disability on Collin Tan's part as at the date of the agreements. In any event, the saving provision under s 33(a)(i) of the RPA would apply. Moreover, the fourth defendant had not objected to her father using her name in this matter, and it would not be equitable for her to now rely on this alleged disability to her advantage. I might also add, that since the Joint Venture Agreements had been abandoned, there was nothing which could be conveyed to Collin Tan and indeed, nothing was ever conveyed to her. Again, this issue would not affect Madam Lim's status as a beneficial owner of Lot 1606 and her entitlement to sell her interest to Tan in 1981.
201 Whether Madam Lim's claim is time-barred
202 Madam Lim's claim against the defendants is essentially for a declaration that Lee Tat holds the property on trust for her and Collin Tan in equal shares, and/or damages for breach of the Second Agreement. In the alternative, the plaintiff also claimed the sum of S$2,431,579.10 which was the balance due from Lee Tat for the purchase of her beneficial share in Lot 1606.
203 In my opinion, Madam Lim's claim for a declaration that Lee Tat holds the property on trust for her is misconceived. She had through Liu, sometime in 1981, agreed to sell her share in Lot 1606 to Lee Tat which the latter had accepted and made part payment thereof. Thus, she no longer had a beneficial interest in the property. The fact that Tan/Lee Tat had failed to pay the remaining sum did not entitle her to revive her beneficial interest, given that she did not rescind the agreement to buy out her share. Thus the issue of this claim being time-barred does not arise.
204 As for damages for breach of the Sub-sale Agreement, the claim is essentially that Lee Tat should have delivered the property to Madam Lim and Collin Tan. Again, this claim would fail. Firstly, Liu had by his own conduct accepted the course of events by agreeing with Tan to develop Lot 1606 without the need to transfer the legal title of the property to Madam Lim and Collin Tan. Even if I am wrong on this point, I do not see what damage Madam Lim/Liu had suffered as a result of the non-transfer. Secondly, as stated earlier, in view of the fact that Madam Lim had sold her share in Lot 1606 to Lee Tat, it implies that the Sub-sale Agreement and the rest of the Joint Venture Agreements would no longer be enforceable as she no longer had an interest in the joint-venture site.
205 However Madam Lim has also claimed for the balance due and owing from Lee Tat for the sale of her interest to Lee Tat of Lot 1606. As I had found that she had a beneficial interest in Lot 1606 which she could transfer to Tan/Lee Tat and as I had also found that there was an agreement to sell that beneficial interest to Lee Tat for $3.8m, I accordingly find that Lee Tat is liable to pay Madam Lim a sum of S$2,431,579.10, being the balance payment due to her. This agreement was not time-barred as it was only breached in May 1981 when the defendants failed to pay the said sum and Suit No 4149 of 1984 was commenced in June 1984.
206 Accordingly, I dismiss Fook Gee's claim in Suit 4141 of 1983 with costs. The plaintiff in Suit 4149 of 1984 is entitled to judgment for $2,431,579.10 against the first defendant Lee Tat only, for the balance sum arising out of the sale of Madam Lim's beneficial interest in Lot 1606 to the company in 1981 at $3.8m, together with interest thereon at 6% per annum from the date of the writ. For the reasons given earlier, Madam Lim cannot succeed in her alternative claims:
207 (i) that the first to third defendants hold the property on trust for her and Collin Tan in equal shares,
208 (ii) for an order that the property be sold by public auction with half the sale proceeds to be paid to her;
209 (iii) for damages against the third defendant (formerly known as Collin Investment Pte Ltd), and
210 (iv) against the fourth defendant Collin Tan.
211 In fairness to all parties, I shall hear further arguments before finalising my order for costs in Suit No 4149 of 1984.
212 Lai Siu Chiu
213 Judge
Lai Siu Chiu J
Michael Khoo (as counsel) with Josephine Low and Jimmy Yap (Donaldson & Burkinshaw) for the plaintiffs in Suit 4141 of 1983 and for the first, second and third defendants in Suit 4149/1984
Woo Tchi Chu (as counsel) and Harpal Singh (Harpal, Wong & M Seow) for the defendant in Suit 4141/1983 and for the plaintiff in Suit 4149 of 1984
Ajaib Haridass and Thomas Tan (Haridass Ho & Partners) for the fourth defendant in Suit 4149/1984
Back to Top

This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

Version No 1: 29 Oct 2026 (23:45 hrs)