This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports. |
Public Prosecutor
v
Basnayake Keith Spencer
[2026] SGDC 298
District Court— District Arrest Case No. DAC-922278-2024 & 3 Ors
Magistrate’s Appeal No. MA-9204-2026-01
District Judge Shaiffudin Saruwan
21 August 2026
10 September 2026
District Judge Shaiffudin Saruwan:
Introduction
1 In this case, the accused stabbed a priest at St Joseph’s Church with a foldable knife while the priest was administering communion during a mass. The accused was intoxicated at the time, having consumed illicit drugs prior to the attack.
2 The prosecution was conducted by DPP Xu Sijia. The accused was represented by Mr Ashwin Ganapathy and Mr Edwin Ho Wei from the Public Defender’s Officer.
The charges
3 The accused pleaded guilty to voluntarily causing grievous hurt (“VCGH”) to the priest and one charge of possession of the foldable knife without lawful authority.
4 The VCGH charge was brought under s 326 of the Penal Code 1871 (“PC”). The possession charge was brought under s 6(1) of the Corrosive and Explosive Substances and Offensive Weapons Act 1958 (“CESOWA”).
5 Two further charges under the same CESOWA provision were taken into consideration for the purposes of sentencing. These involved the accused being found in possession of two other offensive weapons without lawful authority on the same day, namely a penknife and a mallet.
The facts
6 At the time of the offences, the accused was 37 years old.
The facts in relation to the two proceeded offences
7 On 9 November 2024, St Joseph's Church held a children's mass at around 5.30pm, attended by approximately 900 people. The accused arrived alone and took a seat in the middle of the church hall. Before the mass, he consumed two tablets of Noctin Nitrazepam (5mg), purportedly to help him stay focused. Upon realising it was a children's mass, he consumed a further three tablets of Epam Nitrazepam (5mg), purportedly to calm himself down.
8 When communion began at around 6.15pm, the victim and Father Lourdusamy stood near the altar to distribute communion wafers. The accused initially joined Father Lourdusamy's queue but switched to the victim's queue, eventually becoming the last in line. At around 6.28pm, when it was his turn, the accused suddenly produced a foldable knife from his rear left pocket and thrust it into the victim's mouth with the intention of causing grievous hurt.
9 The victim stepped back, bleeding profusely from his mouth, before grabbing the accused's rear pocket to restrain him. Several bystanders moved in to assist, pinning the accused face-down on the floor. The police was called at around 6.29pm. The accused's hands were then tied behind his back. A subsequent search of his person revealed a butterfly knife and a fishing gaff in his pockets. The accused was placed under arrest by the police at 6.40 pm.
10 The foldable knife was approximately 23cm long with a 10cm blade, one edge of which was serrated. The accused’s bag, which he had left on the bench where he had been seated before joining the queue, was found to contain a penknife and a mallet. The following items were also found inside the bag –
(a) two tablets in a cut blister pack labelled “NOCTIN Nitrazepam BP 5 mg”. Analysis revealed that the tablets contained nitrazepam;
(b) 20 tablets in cut blister packs labelled “Epam Nitrazepam BP 5 mg”. Analysis revealed that the tablets contained nitrazepam;
(c) One red-and-white capsule in a cut blister pack. Analysis revealed that the capsule contained pregabalin.
11 Urine samples were procured from the accused, and analysis revealed that the samples contained the following substances –
(a) 7-Aminonitrazepam;
(b) Codeine;
(c) Modafinil/Armodafinil;
(d) Modafinil sulfone;
(e) Morphine;
(f) Nitrazepam;
(g) Oxazepam;
(h) Pregabalin;
(i) Promethazine; and
(j) Temazepam.
The victim’s injuries
12 The victim was admitted to NUH on 9 November 2024 with severe injuries, including a traumatic stab wound to the floor of the mouth, an 8cm laceration extending deep into the oral cavity, macerated tongue muscle, transection of the right lingual artery, likely transection of the right lingual nerve and submandibular duct, and lacerations to both lips. He underwent extensive emergency surgery to repair the tongue, ligate the lingual artery, excise part of the submandibular gland, and suture the various lacerations. Approximately 800ml of blood was lost in total, and the victim required three units of blood transfusion.
13 Post-operatively, the victim was kept intubated overnight in the Surgical Intensive Care Unit before being progressively stepped down to the High Dependency Unit and then the general ward. He was discharged on 15 November 2024. He was referred to ENT and speech therapy for ongoing follow-up.
14 Recovery was gradual. By late November 2024, the victim’s speech had improved to approximately 70% of baseline and tongue protrusion was limited. By his review on 2 June 2025, his wounds were well healed, articulation had continued to improve, and tongue protrusion had improved to 15mm beyond the incisors. The victim was given a total of 40 days of hospitalisation leave, from 9 November to 18 December 2024.
Antecedent
15 The Accused was not a first offender. He had one relevant previous conviction dated 29 July 2022. He had voluntarily caused hurt by dangerous weapons or means under s 324 of the Penal Code (Cap 224) and was sentenced to 12 months imprisonment. On that occasion, he had used a kitchen knife measuring 34cm in length with a blade of 20cm to stab the victim, his then girlfriend, on her left buttock. The accused was under the influence of methamphetamine at the time of that offence.
The prescribed punishments
16 The prescribed punishment for the VCGH offence is imprisonment for life or for a term up to 15 years, and the offender is also liable to caning, or if not sentenced to life imprisonment, liable to a fine.
17 The prescribed punishment for the CESOWA offence is imprisonment not exceeding three years and caning with not less than six strokes.
The sentence
18 The parties’ proposed sentences are set out below –
Charge | Prosecution’s position | Defence’s position |
VCGH charge | 4 years’ 3 months’ to 4 years’ 11 eleven months’ imprisonment and 3 strokes of the cane. | Less than 4 years’ imprisonment and 3 strokes of the cane. |
CESOWA charge | 7 to 8 months’ imprisonment and 6 strokes of the cane | 7 months’ imprisonment and 6 strokes of the cane. |
19 Both parties were in agreement that the two imprisonment sentences should run concurrently.
The VCGH offence
20 The parties agreed that the applicable sentencing approach, drawn from PP v Miya Manik [2020] SGHC 164 (“Miya Manik”), affirmed on appeal, involved three stages. At the first stage, the court determines an indicative sentence as if the charge were under s 325 PC, based on the seriousness of the injury with reference to PP v BDB [2018] 1 SLR 127 (“BDB”). At the second stage, an uplift is applied based on the dangerous weapon or means used. At the third stage, the sentence is adjusted for aggravating and mitigating factors.
The prosecution’s submissions on sentence
(1) Stage 1 – Indicative sentence on the basis of a s 325 PC offence
21 The prosecution submitted an indicative sentence of around three years' imprisonment, based on the seriousness of the injuries sustained by the victim. These comprised a traumatic stab wound to the floor of the mouth with multiple lacerations, including an 8cm floor-of-mouth laceration, macerated tongue muscle, transected right lingual artery and nerve, and lip lacerations. The victim required emergency surgery involving ligation of the lingual artery, excision of the submandibular gland, and repair of multiple lacerations, followed by intensive post-operative care and 40 days of hospitalisation leave. Recovery was prolonged — as of seven months post-assault, tongue protrusion remained limited and speech articulation had not been fully restored. The prosecution assessed the seriousness of the injuries as at least comparable to PP v Joel Elliot Andrew [2023] SGDC 186 (“Joel Elliot Andrew”), which similarly involved multiple lacerations to a vulnerable body part.
(2) Stage 2 – Uplift for the use of a dangerous weapon
22 An uplift of 10 months' imprisonment was sought on the basis that the accused had used a foldable knife approximately 23cm long with a partially serrated 10cm blade — a weapon likely to cause death and capable of causing far more serious harm. This was consistent with the precedents in PP v Kumaran s/o Tanggapan [2023] SGDC 240 (“Kumaran s/o Tanggapan”)(10-month uplift, knife with approximately 30cm blade) and Joel Elliot Andrew (9-month uplift, 47.5cm knife with serrated blade).
(3) Stage 3 – Aggravating and mitigating factors
23 A further uplift of 26 to 38 months was submitted based on four aggravating factors.
24 First, the attack was wholly unprovoked and brazen — the accused stabbed the victim mid-communion, in a sacred and peaceful setting where the victim was entirely defenceless. Second, the attack occurred in a crowded church hall in front of hundreds of people, including children, creating a significant risk of mass panic and collateral injury. Third, the accused was voluntarily intoxicated, having consumed five nitrazepam tablets before and during the mass. Although he was in a drug-induced psychotic state at the time, he was fully aware of the effects of these tablets — he had previously lost consciousness, heard voices, and experienced bizarre thoughts after taking them — yet chose to consume them anyway. His psychosis was entirely self-induced, and his voluntary intoxication should be treated as an aggravating factor per Wong Hoi Len v PP [2009] 1 SLR(R) 115 (“Wong Hoi Len”) and PP v Soo Cheow Wee and another appeal [2024] 3 SLR 972 (“Soo Cheow Wee”). Notably, his drug-induced psychotic symptoms resolved within a week without antipsychotic medication, and he has no functional psychotic disorder. Fourth, the accused has a prior conviction for voluntarily causing hurt with a dangerous weapon, namely stabbing his then girlfriend with a kitchen knife while under the influence of methamphetamine. The present offence represents a clear escalation in severity, warranting specific deterrence and application of the escalation principle per PP v Low Ji Qing [2019] 5 SLR 769 (“Low Ji Qing”).
25 On the accused's mental state, the prosecution further noted that despite his drug-induced psychosis, he retained situational awareness — he knew he was at a children's mass, recalled placing the knife in his pocket, and deliberately left his bag behind when queuing for communion. He was not of unsound mind. He also has antisocial personality disorder and was assessed to be at high risk of recidivism and dangerousness, given his severe and persistent drug abuse, refusal of treatment, and the compounding interaction between substance abuse and antisocial personality disorder.
(4) Caning
26 Consistent with BDB, caning was appropriate where violence has been inflicted and no exceptional circumstances existed. Given the mandatory minimum of six strokes for the CESOWA charge, the prosecution submitted three strokes of the cane for the VCGH charge.
27 The prosecution identified the accused's plea of guilty as the sole mitigating factor and submitted that an appropriate sentencing discount should be accorded to him. The prosecution submitted a sentence of four years’ three months to four years’ 11 months' imprisonment and three strokes of the cane.
The defence’s submissions on sentence
28 During oral submissions, the defence informed the court that their sentencing position had changed, in that they were now seeking a global sentence of less than four years’ imprisonment, departing from the position of four years’ imprisonment stated in their written submissions. The defence also disagreed with the prosecution’s argument that the accused’s self-induced intoxication was an aggravating factor, and submitted that the accused was not at high risk of dangerousness and recidivism.
(1) Stage 1 – Indicative sentence on the basis of a s 325 PC offence
29 The defence did not take issue with the prosecution's indicative sentence of 3 years' imprisonment, which it accepted was consistent with the case precedents.
(2) Stage 2 – Uplift for the use of a dangerous weapon
30 They submitted for an uplift of nine months’ imprisonment, one month lower than the uplift sought by the prosecution. It highlighted that the total length of the foldable knife and the blade in the present case were approximately half those of the knives involved in Joel Elliot Andrew (knife length 47.5cm, blade length 35cm) and Kumaran s/o Tanggapan (knife length 40cm, blade length 30cm). The difference was substantial, and a shorter knife and blade was capable of causing less harm than a longer one.
(3) Stage 3 – Aggravating and mitigating factors
31 The defence submitted that the accused's voluntary ingestion of the drugs should be treated as a neutral factor rather than an aggravating one.
32 The governing principle from Soo Cheow Wee (at [86]–[87]) was that self-induced intoxication was aggravating only where the offender had consciously embarked on a course of conduct knowing it to be dangerous and foreseeable in its consequences — specifically, where the offender knew that consuming certain substances would trigger psychosis, leading to auditory hallucinations and violent behaviour. The defence submitted that this threshold was not met on the facts.
33 The accused had believed that the nitrazepam tablets helped him to focus and stay calm, consistent with his pattern of use over several months during which he had never experienced violent tendencies. While he acknowledged that the tablets could cause him to "lose his mind", hear voices, and have bizarre beliefs, this fell short of knowing that they would cause violent behaviour. The defence submitted that it was too great a logical leap to equate "deranged thinking" with violent tendencies. This was supported by Dr Kenneth Gerard Koh Wun Wu's (“Dr Koh”) own concession in his Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”) clarification report dated 12 August 2025 that the accused "may not have been aware that, specifically, he would eventually end up stabbing a man while taking these pills." (at [6a]).
34 The defence took issue with the prosecution’s reliance on Dr Koh's opinion that the accused "would have had the capacity to recognise that drug abuse in general could possibly lead him to violence again." It submitted that this was an impermissibly broad-brush view that did not satisfy the specificity required under Soo Cheow Wee (at [87]), which called for evidence that the offender knew the particular substances consumed would trigger the relevant psychotic episode and violent conduct. Dr Koh's opinion was further weakened by his admission in his clarification report (at [11a]) that he had not assessed the accused in relation to the prior stabbing and could not confirm whether that incident arose from drug-induced psychosis, intoxication, or withdrawal. That prior incident also involved methamphetamine — a different drug with different effects — making it prejudicial to conflate the two incidents under a general "drug abuse" rubric.
35 The defence further relied on Soo Cheow Wee (at [66]), which recognised that where an accused was unaware that substance abuse would precipitate violent symptoms, intoxication should not be treated as aggravating and rehabilitation considerations may instead come to the fore. The accused had, during remand, proactively sought psychiatric assistance for his drug abuse disorder and intended to engage the National Addictions Management Service upon release.
36 The defence submitted that an uplift of 24 months at Stage 3 reflected the neutral treatment of the intoxication factor. After applying the 30% discount for the accused's guilty plea, the defence submitted that the appropriate final sentence should be less than four years' imprisonment.
The CESOWA offence
37 Parties were agreed on the proposed sentence for this offence. The usual sentence for a first offender who has pleaded guilty is six months’ imprisonment and six strokes of the cane: Saravanan s/o Ganesan v PP [2003] SGHC 273 (“Saravan s/o Ganesan”)(at [50]). On account of the two similar charges which were taken into consideration for sentencing, the prosecution submitted that an uplift of one to two month’s imprisonment would be appropriate, while the defence submitted that the uplift of one month’s imprisonment was appropriate.
Sentence by the Court
The VCGH offence
38 General deterrence and retribution were the key sentencing considerations. The accused attacked a priest with a foldable knife during a religious mass, in front of hundreds of worshippers including children. This grave breach of public safety warranted a deterrent sentence to discourage similar offences and address public disquiet. The attack was wholly unprovoked and caused severe physical harm to a defenceless man, and the punishment had to reflect the full gravity of the offence.
39 At the first stage of the Miya Manik sentencing framework, I found that an indicative sentence of three years’ imprisonment appropriately reflected the seriousness of the grievous hurt caused. The victim sustained multiple serious stab and laceration wounds requiring emergency surgery and post-operative intensive care, was hospitalised for about a week, and was given 40 days of hospitalisation leave. Even seven months after the assault, his tongue protrusion remained limited, and he continued to require speech therapy and ENT follow-up. The victim’s oral function and speech were affected for an extended period.
40 At the second stage, an uplift of 10 months’ imprisonment was warranted. The accused used a foldable knife approximately 23m long with a 10cm partially serrated blade capable of causing death, and which could have caused far more serious harm had it struck vital organs. This uplift was consistent with the approach taken in Joel Elliot Andrew and Kumaran s/o Tanggapan. In the round, I did not find the difference in the knife length between those cases and the present one to be significant.
41 At the third stage, I identified the following aggravating factors. First, the attack was wholly unprovoked and brazen – the accused struck the victim at the precise moment he was administering a sacred ritual, when he would have been entirely defenceless and unsuspecting. Second, the potential for wider harm was significant, given that the attack occurred in a crowded church hall before hundreds of worshippers including children, creating a real risk of mass panic and further injuries. The defence’s submission that the accused’s swift subdual meant that any potential harm was similarly contained missed the point entirely. The fact that he was subdued so quickly was entirely fortuitous, owing to the alertness and courage of members of the congregation who came forward at considerable personal risk to restrain an accused armed with a dangerous weapon. Their intervention did not negate the potential for serious harm - it merely prevented it from happening.
42 The third aggravating factor – the accused’s self-induced intoxication -became a point of contention. The accused had consumed, among other things, nitrazepam tablets before and during the mass. He had obtained these drugs illicitly. In his psychiatric report dated 26 November 2024, Dr Koh diagnosed the accused with substance abuse disorder, likely involving benzodiazepines and opiates, as well as Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD) evidenced by, among other things, his repeated offending and drug abuse. Dr Koh found that the accused was not of unsound mind at the time of the offence. He further noted that while the accused “[might] have been experiencing hallucinations and delusions at the time of the stabbing, his behaviour was organized [sic] and calculated”. In a second psychiatric report dated 18 December 2024, Dr Koh elaborated that the drugs in the accused’s system “had caused him [to develop] a drug induced psychotic state at the material time”. Dr Koh also observed that the accused was “well aware that the tablets he abused caused him to become deranged in thinking, have fainting episodes and to develop psychotic symptoms.
43 The psychiatric reports made clear that the accused knew from prior experience the effect that these drugs have on him. He had admitted to Dr Koh that he had ended up hospitalised, lost consciousness, and "lost his mind" - experiencing bizarre thoughts and hearing voices - after consuming these drugs. He had also admitted that the tablets worsened his auditory hallucinations and bizarre beliefs. Therefore, he was able to appreciate that the tablets could cause him to have disordered and potentially violent behaviour.
44 Accordingly, I was satisfied that he was fully aware of the deleterious effects these tablets had on him. His culpability lay in the fact that, armed with this knowledge, he nevertheless voluntarily consumed the tablets and knowingly placed himself at risk of losing self-control and awareness at the material time. His culpability was further increased because he had the capacity to recognise that drug abuse in general could possibly lead him to violence again, given his antecedent of having stabbed another person with a knife when under the influence of methamphetamine. For these reasons, I found that his voluntary consumption of nitrazepam constituted an aggravating factor.
45 The case of PP v Mohammad Zam bin Abdul Rashid [2006] SGHC 168, cited by the defence was distinguishable. In that case, the offender was ignorant that alcohol would aggravate his loss of impulse control, and he was unaware he suffered from frontal lobe syndrome - a condition rendering him emotionally labile and unable to control his impulses. The present case was plainly different.
46 The last aggravating factor was the accused’s prior conviction for another stabbing offence committed whilst under the influence of methamphetamine. The present offence represented an escalation in severity, warranting specific deterrence. I also noted that the accused was assessed to be at high risk of re-offending. The assessment, made in 2024, was based on the accused’s severe and persistent drug abuse, his refusal of treatment, and the compounding effect of his comorbid conditions.
47 Taking all of the above into account, I imposed an uplift of 26 months’ imprisonment at the third stage.
48 On caning, it was well established that at least six strokes were typically imposed for such an offence: see BDB. Given that six strokes were already engaged for the CESOWA offence, which prescribed a mandatory minimum of six strokes, I imposed three strokes of the cane for the VCGH offence.
49 Finally, I accorded the accused a 30% sentencing discount for his plea of guilty. In totality, I imposed a sentence of four years’ and three months’ imprisonment and three strokes of the cane.
The CESOWA offence
50 For this offence, the usual starting point for a first offender pleading guilty was six months’ imprisonment and the mandatory minimum of six strokes of the cane. In the present case, a slight uplift in the imprisonment term was warranted on account of the two similar charges taken into consideration for sentencing. I accordingly sentenced the accused to seven months’ imprisonment and six strokes of the cane.
Consecutive/concurrent sentences
51 Applying the one-transaction rule, I ordered both imprisonment terms to run concurrently, as they arose from the same incident. The total aggregate sentence was therefore four years’ and three months’ imprisonment and nine strokes of the cane. I was satisfied that this sentence adequately reflected the accused’s overall criminality and sufficiently addressed the need for both deterrence and retribution.
Conclusion
52 The accused has lodged an appeal against sentence and is presently serving his sentence.
Shaiffudin Saruwan District Judge | | |
DPP Xu Sijia (Attorney-General’s Chambers) for the Prosecution
Ashwin Ganapathy and Edwin Ho Wei (Public Defender’s Office) for the Accused