This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.
In the state courts of the republic of singapore
[2026] SGDC 377
District Arrest Case No. 904750 of 2026 and another
Public Prosecutor
Against
Rethi d/o Krishnan Reghunayakan
EX TEMPORE judgment
Criminal Law — Offences —Section 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b) of the Children and Young Persons Act 1993 (2020 Rev Ed) — Preschool teacher ill-treating child in her care by slapping the victim’s head
Criminal Procedure and Sentencing — Sentencing — Section 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b) of the Children and Young Persons Act 1993 (2020 Rev Ed) — Preschool teacher ill-treating child in her care by slapping the victim’s head
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Public Prosecutor v Rethi d/o Krishnan Reghunayakan
[2026] SGDC 377
District Arrest Case No. 904750 of 2026 and another District Judge Samuel Wee 20 November 2026
20 November 2026
District Judge Samuel Wee:
Introduction
1 Ms Rethi d/o Krishnan Reghunayakan (“Ms Rethi”) claims that various conditions, including sensitivity to trigger sounds, visual difficulties and psychological distress (“Alleged Conditions”), impaired her emotional regulation and stress tolerance. Despite her Alleged Conditions, Ms Rethi chose to work as a preschool teacher – a role that demanded patience and self-control amid noise and the behaviour of young children. That choice set the stage for the offences she committed and her dismissal from the preschool.
Foot Note 1
SOF_[8].
2 In April 2025, Ms Rethi was caught committing two separate acts of ill-treating children in her care at the preschool:
(a) On 8 April 2025, Ms Rethi slapped the head of a 5-year-old child with autism spectrum disorder (“Victim 1”) twice with the back of her right hand, as Victim 1 was singing loudly on the mattress during nap time, and also pulled Victim 1 backwards by the collar of Victim 1’s shirt. Ms Rethi’s slapping of Victim 1’s head twice is the subject of DAC-904750-2026 for an offence under s 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b) of the Children and Young Persons Act 1993 (2020 Rev Ed) (“CYPA”) for wilfully doing an act which caused Victim 1 unnecessary physical pain (“Proceeded Charge”), to which Ms Rethi has pleaded guilty.
Foot Note 2
SOF_[5]-[6].
The offence was discovered when the preschool reviewed its closed-circuit television footage after receiving a separate complaint from a parent about Ms Rethi, which did not result in a finding of child abuse.
Foot Note 3
SOF_[4].
(b) On 11 April 2025, Ms Rethi pulled the arms of a 4-year-old child (“Victim 2”) towards her, causing Victim 2 unnecessary physical pain. This is the subject of DAC-904751-2026 for an offence under s 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b) of the CYPA for wilfully doing an act which caused Victim 2 unnecessary physical pain, which Ms Rethi admits and consents to being taken into consideration for the purposes of sentencing (“TIC Charge”).
Foot Note 4
SOF_[3].
The offence was witnessed by another preschool teacher before the offence under the Proceeded Charge was discovered.
Foot Note 5
SOF_[3].
3 The Prosecution sought a sentence of 6 to 8 weeks’ imprisonment, while Ms Rethi submitted for the Court to impose a fine of $8,000, coupled with a bond under s 6(7) of the CYPA with treatment conditions.
4 I sentence Ms Rethi to 3 weeks’ imprisonment.
Ms Rethi’s Alleged Conditions hold no mitigating value
5 Ms Rethi asserts that she committed the offence under the Proceeded Charge because she was triggered by the following during Victim 1’s nap time:
Foot Note 6
MP_[21]-[26].
(a) Victim 1’s persistent singing in a high-pitched voice.
Foot Note 7
SOF_[5]; MP_[22].
(b) The darkened room during nap time, which made it more difficult for Ms Rethi to perform her duties.
Foot Note 8
MP_[21], [23].
(c) The severe menopausal symptoms she had been suffering.
Foot Note 9
MP_[24].
6 She relies on a few reports (“Reports”) to argue that mitigating weight should be given in light of the Alleged Conditions and the treatment she has voluntarily undergone:
Foot Note 10
MP_[11]-[20], [52].
(a) The Assessment Report dated 11 May 2026 prepared by Dr Jonathan Ee (“Dr Ee”), which indicated the following concerning Ms Rethi:
(i) She reported persistent and intrusive preoccupation with trigger sounds, which she indicated were present since childhood and had intensified over time, and required her to take “frequent efforts to avoid or suppress exposure to trigger sounds, including avoiding places or social interactions, diverting her thoughts, or attempting to stop the sounds” and that she would experience severe levels of irritation, anger and disgust when unable to avoid or stop the sounds.
Foot Note 11
MP_24-25.
(ii) Based on the Beck Anxiety Inventory, she appeared to have mild levels of anxiety since experiencing blurred vision from October 2024.
Foot Note 12
MP_22, 24-25.
(iii) Based on the Menopause Rating Scale, she appeared to have severe menopausal symptoms for around 3 years, including irritability, anxiety, physical and mental exhaustion.
Foot Note 13
MP_24-25.
(iv) Based on the Beck Depression Inventory II, she appeared to have moderate levels of depression after the offences were committed.
Foot Note 14
MP_24-25.
(v) Based on the Personal Inventory for DSM-5, she appeared to have:
Foot Note 15
MP_24-25.
(A) Elevated traits within the domains of disinhibition, psychoticism and negative affectivity.
(B) Facet-level elevations in impulsivity, distractibility, restricted affectivity, eccentricity and suspiciousness.
(vi) She was experiencing cumulative psychological distress and reduced emotional coping capacity “during the material period”, and “It is likely [that] the interaction of depressive symptoms, menopausal distress, chronic sensory sensitivity, health anxiety, and elevated stress-related personality traits likely contributed to impaired emotional regulation and reduced stress tolerance at the time”.
Foot Note 16
MP_25.
(b) A Memo dated 26 October 2026 written by Dr Ee, which indicated that Ms Rethi appeared to be engaging in “positive coping strategies” and had demonstrated “stable mood and improved emotional regulation”.
Foot Note 17
MP_97-98.
(c) A Medical Report in Otolaryngology dated 20 May 2026 prepared by Dr Amanda Tan, which indicated that Ms Rethi reported as being “bothered by high pitched sounds that a child produced, while she was working”.
Foot Note 18
MP_100-101.
(d) A Specialist Medical Report dated 15 July 2026 prepared by Dr Rupesh Agarwal, which indicated that Ms Rethi had a history of difficulty seeing objects in the dark.
Foot Note 19
MP_103-104.
7 However, none of the Reports establish a mental condition that is causally linked to the commission of the offence under the Proceeded Charge, which would reduce her culpability and constitute a mitigating factor (Public Prosecutor v BDB [2018] 1 SLR 127 (“BDB”); Public Prosecutor v Soo Cheow Wee and another appeal [2024] 3 SLR 972; CNK v Public Prosecutor [2024] 2 SLR 450). In this regard, the Assessment Report states that there “is no evidence to indicate severe mental illness or psychotic disorder”,
Foot Note 20
MP_25.
and Ms Rethi accepts that it “does not unequivocally diagnose an established psychiatric disorder that substantially diminished [her] responsibility at the time”.
Foot Note 21
MP_[17].
8 Consequently, I place no weight on the Alleged Conditions.
The applicable sentencing approach
9 The punishment for the Proceeded Charge is specified under:
(a) Section 6(6)(b) of the CYPA, which specifies a maximum fine of $8,000, a maximum of 8 years’ imprisonment, or both.
(b) Section 6(7) of the CYPA, which specifies that the court may, in lieu of or in addition to the punishment set out in s 6(6)(b) of the CYPA, order the offender to “execute a bond, with or without sureties, as the court may determine, to be of good behaviour for such period as the court thinks fit, and may include in such bond a condition requiring such person to undergo such counselling, psychotherapy or other programme as may be specified therein” (“Section 6(7) Bond”).
10 In BDB, the Court of Appeal set out the following sentencing principles for offences under s 5 of the Children and Young Persons Act (Cap 38, 2001 Rev Ed), which is the predecessor of s 6 of the CYPA:
Foot Note 22
MP_[30].
(a) The law recognises a special need to protect vulnerable persons, including children – an offender’s culpability is generally enhanced because the offender is seen as exploiting a relatively helpless person.
Foot Note 23
BDB_[34].
(b) Deterrence and retribution are primary sentencing considerations in the ill-treatment of young victims.
Foot Note 24
BDB_[85].
(c) Relevant aggravating factors include:
Foot Note 25
BDB_[63]-[70], [85].
(i) The nature of injury inflicted.
Foot Note 26
BDB_[79].
(ii) Whether the injury was inflicted wilfully – an offender who wilfully inflicts injury would generally be regarded as more culpable than an offender who acted unreasonably in doing so.
Foot Note 27
BDB_[86].
(iii) The extent of deliberation or premeditation.
(iv) The manner and duration of the attack.
(v) The victim’s vulnerability.
(vi) The use of any weapon.
(vii) Whether the attack was undertaken by a group.
(viii) Any relevant antecedents.
(ix) Any prior intervention by the authorities.
(d) Relevant mitigating factors include:
Foot Note 28
BDB_[71]-[75], [85].
(i) The offender’s mental condition.
(ii) The offender’s genuine remorse.
(iii) The offender’s personal financial or social problems. In this regard, the Court of Appeal stressed that the frustrations faced by an offender due to his or her difficult personal circumstances can never justify or excuse the abuse of young victims.
Foot Note 29
BDB_[75].
11 Based on the principles in BDB, the relevant factors for consideration in Ms Rethi’s case are as follows:
(a) Offence-specific factors:
(i) Victim 1 is a vulnerable victim – Victim 1 was 5 years old at the time of the offence and has autism spectrum disorder (with a “tendency to stand up or leave her seat, fidget, or start singing or engaging in self-talk”),
Foot Note 30
AOS_[4(a)(ii)]; Combined Full Specialist Developmental Evaluation Report of Victim 1_3.
and the offence was discovered only when the preschool reviewed the closed-circuit television footage after receiving a separate complaint about Ms Rethi (see [2(a)] above).
Foot Note 31
AOS_[4(a)(iii)].
Moreover, there was an abuse of trust, as Ms Rethi (as the preschool teacher) was entrusted with the care of Victim 1.
Foot Note 32
AOS_[4(a)(ii)], [4(b)]; BDB_[37], [65].
(ii) Ms Rethi slapped Victim 1’s head (which is a vulnerable region) twice during Victim 1’s nap time. In this regard, it is pertinent that Victim 1 had “the tendency to sing, engage in self-talk or engage in other self-soothing mechanisms when she is unengaged”, and had a habit of singing loudly before sleeping.
Foot Note 33
SOF_[5].
Further, even if Victim 1’s singing had been “exceptionally high volume and high pitched” that day (as submitted by Ms Rethi’s counsel at the hearing), I agree with the Prosecution that Ms Rethi’s slapping of Victim 1 was inexcusable for a preschool teacher, regardless of any sensitivity to trigger sounds.
(iii) There is no evidence of any visible injuries suffered by Victim 1.
Foot Note 34
SOF_[7].
(b) Offender-specific factors:
(i) The TIC Charge.
Foot Note 35
AOS_[4(c)].
(ii) Ms Rethi’s indication of her intention to plead guilty at Stage 1 of the Sentencing Advisory Panel’s Guidelines on Reduction in Sentences for Guilty Pleas, which entitles her to a reduction of up to 30% (“Stage 1 PG”).
Foot Note 36
MP_[29].
(c) For completeness, I place no weight on the Alleged Conditions for the reasons set out at [7] above.
12 Having considered the relevant factors, I find the custodial threshold to be crossed – while the harm caused may be at the lower end of low,
Foot Note 37
MP_[34]-[35], [37].
Ms Rethi’s culpability is more appropriately characterised as falling within the middle to upper range of low.
Foot Note 38
MP_[38]-[40].
Ms Rethi’s suggestion of a fine coupled with the Section 6(7) Bond is therefore inadequate, particularly given that deterrence remains a primary sentencing consideration.
Foot Note 39
BDB_[85].
13 A sentence of 3 weeks’ imprisonment is therefore appropriate, arrived at as follows:
(a) The starting point sentence had Ms Rethi been convicted after a trial is 4 weeks’ imprisonment.
(b) The starting point sentence is adjusted to 3 weeks’ imprisonment to account for:
(i) An uplift for the TIC Charge.
(ii) A reduction for her Stage 1 PG.
14 This sentence is necessarily higher than the sentence of 4 days’ imprisonment in Public Prosecutor v Alamelu d/o Paramaguru [2025] SGDC 217 (“Alamelu”), which Ms Rethi relied on:
(a) In Alamelu, the offender was a preschool teacher who pleaded guilty to one charge under s 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b) for ill-treating the victim by unreasonably doing an act which caused the 4-year-old victim unnecessary pain and physical injury – the offender had an isolated incident of kicking the victim’s right shin, causing the victim to suffer pain and a 1 cm x 1 cm shin haematoma. The offender kicked the victim after she felt that the victim had nearly tripped her, and thereafter did not bother attending to the victim who was hugging her right shin and had buried her face downwards (opting instead to scold and shout at the victim). The victim informed her mother about the incident, following which a police report was lodged and the victim was examined and treated for the haematoma.
(b) The District Court sentenced the offender to 4 days’ imprisonment, taking into account the following:
Foot Note 40
Alamelu_[13]-[18].
(i) The offending was an isolated act.
(ii) The victim was able to inform her mother about the incident.
(iii) The injury was not to a vulnerable part of the body, nor did it appear to be serious or long-lasting.
(iv) The offender was working in a high-stress environment which required the importance of deterrence in protecting preschool children to be “tempered by proportionality in relation to the severity of the offence committed as well as by the moral and legal culpability of the offender”.
Foot Note 41
Alamelu_[15].
(v) The offender did not assist the victim after the incident, nor did she own up to her wrongdoing initially.
(c) While Ms Rethi’s offence under the Proceeded Charge did not cause any visible injuries to Victim 1 (unlike the victim in Alamelu), the overall circumstances call for a higher sentence than in Alamelu for the following reasons:
(i) The offender in Alamelu performed one isolated act of kicking the victim’s shin,
Foot Note 42
Alamelu_[13(a)].
whereas Ms Rethi slapped Victim 1’s head (which is a vulnerable region) twice.
(ii) Victim 1 is more vulnerable than the victim in Alamelu, who was able to complain to her mother and did not have autism spectrum disorder.
(iii) The offender in Alamelu was charged under the limb of “unreasonably doing an act which caused [the victim] unnecessary pain and physical injury”,
Foot Note 43
Alamelu_[2].
whereas Ms Rethi has been charged under the limb of “wilfully doing an act which caused [Victim 1] unnecessary pain”.
15 Finally, I give no weight to the unreported cases referred to by the parties
Foot Note 44
AOS_[5(a)]; MP_[46]-[48].
as they are “without grounds or explanations” and it is not possible to establish “what had weighed on the mind of the sentencing judge or why the sentencing judge had approached the matter in a particular way” (Janardana Jayasankarr v Public Prosecutor [2016] 4 SLR 1288 at [13(b)]).
Conclusion
16 Ms Rethi is sentenced to 3 weeks’ imprisonment.
Samuel Wee District Judge
Jordan Kow (Attorney-General’s Chambers) for the Public Prosecutor;
Kanthan Raghavendra (Kalidass Law Corporation) for the Accused.
This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.