This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports. |
Public Prosecutor
v
Rinda Dwi Syaadah
[2026] SGDC 38
District Arrest Case No 925135 of 2025
District Judge Paul Quan
15 January 2026; 23 January 2026
23 January 2026 Judgment reserved.
District Judge Paul Quan:
Introduction
1 The accused, Rinda Dwi Syyadah (“Ms Dwi”), a 26-year-old Indonesian, is a foreign domestic worker (“FDW”). She has pleaded guilty to a single charge of theft-in-dwelling under section 380 of the Penal Code 1871 (2020 Rev Ed) for stealing jewellery and money from the victim, who is the 77-year-old mother of her employer’s son-in-law.
2 Ms Dwi is a first-time offender. The prosecution has sought an imprisonment term of six to seven months’ imprisonment to be imposed on her. Ms Dwi, who is self-represented, has expressed remorse. She had stolen to help with her sick grandmother’s hospitalisation bills.
3 I convicted Ms Dwi on 15 January 2026 and adjourned sentencing for Ms Dwi to consider how the stolen jewellery could be retrieved and also for the victim to attend the proceedings. I now sentence Ms Dwi to six months’ imprisonment. I explain why in this ex tempore judgment.
Sentencing FDWs who offend against employers and their employers’ household members
4 Because FDWs are regarded as a special class of vulnerable victims, employers and members of their households who commit offences against their FDWs are dealt with harshly. For instance, section 73(1) PC provides for enhanced penalties for offences committed against FDWs by employers and members of their households.
5 When FDWs turn against their employers and members of their households, the shoe then is on the other foot. What is sauce for the goose must be sauce for the gander. FDWs who commit offences against their employers and members of their households should therefore expect to be punished in equal measure.
Harm caused by the offence not low
6 In sentencing property-related offences, the economic value of the offence measured in terms of the benefit gained by the offender and the corresponding loss suffered by the victim is a proxy of the harm caused by the offence: Gan Chai Bee Anne v PP [2019] 4 SLR 838 at [42].
7 In this case, Ms Dwi stole S$11,778.72 worth of jewellery and S$500 worth of cash. The stolen jewellery and cash were not recovered from her. She has not made any restitution. She has also informed me today that she is unlikely to have the means of retrieving the jewellery. Consequential loss of more than S$12,000 was therefore lost, excluding the intrinsic value of the jewellery purchased over a long span of time in 1973, the 1990s and 2001. The harm caused by the offence is not low as such.
Ms Dwi’s culpability also not low
8 Ms Dwi’s employer and members of his household had reposed their trust in her as their FDW. This is evident from the fact that she knew the victim kept her jewellery, cash and safe deposit box key in her bedroom. She was opportunistic and committed the theft when the victim was away on holiday. She had access to the room even though the victim was not around. She stole the jewellery and cash from the victim’s safe deposit box secured in the victim’s bedroom wardrobe. Through her friend who was returning to Indonesia, she then passed the stolen jewellery to her family in Indonesia for her grandmother’s heart surgery expenses. She remitted the stolen cash back to her family in October 2025.
9 By committing theft under such circumstances and in her capacity as an FDW, she had abused the trust that was reposed in her with the knowledge she had of the victim’s property, the free and easy access to the victim’s bedroom, and the ample time she had with which she could dispose of the stolen items undetected from September 2025 when she committed the theft till December 2025 when her employer’s son-in-law reported her to the police. Notably, she remitted the stolen cash only later in October 2025.
Absence of criminal antecedents
10 It is a given that Ms Dwi would have a clean record, being employed in Singapore as an FDW. In any event, the absence of antecedents is at best a neutral factor; it is an absent aggravating factor, not a mitigating factor: BPH v PP [2019] 2 SLR 764 at [85].
Plea of guilt
11 Decidedly in her favour is her early plea of guilt, which carries mitigatory weight, for which I accord her the full 30% reduction in sentence as recommended by the Sentencing Advisory Panel in its guidelines in this regard.
Sentence of six months’ imprisonment imposed
12 The benchmark sentence for simple theft under section 379 PC where the value of the stolen items is below S$10,000 is in the region of three months’ imprisonment. The present offence of theft-in-dwelling committed in Ms Dwi’s capacity is a graver offence, with mandatory imprisonment of more than doubling of the maximum imprisonment term prescribed.
13 Having regard to the harm caused by the offence, Ms Dwi’s level of culpability, and her plea of guilt, I sentence her to six months’ imprisonment. I backdate her sentence to the date of her arrest on 19 December 2025. She was charged in court on 20 December 2025 and has since been in remand.
Compensation in the sum of S$12,278.72 ordered
14 The victim has attended today’s proceedings. She has applied for a compensation order in the sum of S$12,278.72, which is the value of the items in her possession that were stolen from her safe deposit box. There were properly itemised receipts for the items and also valuation documents submitted to support her claim. Ms Dwi does not dispute the loss that has been quantified by the victim. She has informed me that she does not have any means to pay compensation. The prosecution has consequently not sought compensation.
15 In considering whether a compensation order is appropriate, which is a matter that I must consider under the law, and if so to make the order: sections 359 (1) and 359(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 (2020 Rev Ed) (“CPC”); PP v AOB [2011] 2 SLR 793 at [27], I am cognisant that any order I make must not be oppressive and must be realistic, in that I must be satisfied that Ms Dwi either has the means available or will have the means to pay the compensation within a reasonable time: AOB at [25].
16 That said, Ms Dwi’s inability to pay compensation is not an absolute bar to the making of a compensation order, since the CPC provides for an in-default term of imprisonment for failing to pay the compensation. The maximum in-default term in this case is six months’ imprisonment: section 360(4) CPC. I am equally cognisant that a compensation order does not form part of the sentence, not is it an alternative to a sentence. It should not be used as further punishment of a convicted person: AOB at [25]. It is to deter a convicted person from not paying the compensation ordered.
17 This is an appropriate case to order compensation. I have already sentenced Ms Dwi to six months’ imprisonment on the theft charge. There is no reason to believe that she cannot expend greater efforts in recovering from her family the monies obtained from disposing the stolen items with the passage of time. I therefore order Ms Dwi to pay a compensation sum of S$12,278.72 before the expiry of her imprisonment term through the investigation officer (“IO”), who is to notify the court of the receipt of the compensation amount or default in payment. Payment is to be made between 8.30am to 3pm on weekdays. If Ms Dwi’s family members intend to pay the compensation on her behalf while she is in prison, they should contact the IO to inform him of their intention so that he can make arrangements with the victim in advance. Failing to notify the IO in advance may result in a delay in processing the payment.
18 If Ms Dwi does not pay the compensation sum, she will serve 12 weeks’ imprisonment in default.
Paul Quan
District Judge
Chng Leng Leng (State Prosecuting Officer) for the Public Prosecutor;
Accused self-represented.