This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.
1. This judgment DOES need redaction.
2. Redaction HAS been done.
district judge
shaiffudin saruwan
13 March 2026
In the state courts of the republic of singapore
[2026] SGDC 90
District Arrest Case No. DAC-907405-2025 & 7 Ors
Magistrate’s Appeal No. MA-9009-2026-01
Between
Public Prosecutor
And
JGJ
grounds of decision
[Criminal procedure and sentencing] – [Sentencing] – [Children and Young Persons Act Cap 38, Rev Ed 2001] – [s 5(1) punishable under s 5(5)(b)] - [Children and Young Persons Act 1993] - [s 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b)] – [ill-treatment of children]
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Public Prosecutor v JGJ
[2026] SGDC 90
District Court— District Arrest Case No. DAC-907405-2025 & 7 Ors Magistrate’s Appeal No. MA-9009-2026-01
District Judge Shaiffudin Saruwan 16 December 2025 & 2 January 2026
13 March 2026
District Judge Shaiffudin Saruwan:
Introduction
1 According to the Convention on the Rights of the Child, physical violence encompassed inter alia, inhuman physical punishment, physical bullying and hazing, and corporal punishment. Slapping, spanking, pushing, punching, kicking, chocking and burning all constituted physical violence. This abuse could be committed by anyone, but adults in positions of authority, like caregivers or teachers, were often cited as perpetrators.
2 In the present case, the accused was charged with the ill-treatment of his two biological sons. He pleaded guilty to two offences under s 5(1) punishable under s 5(5)(b) of the Children and Young Persons Act (Cap 38, Rev Ed 2001)(“CYPA”) and one offence under s 6(1) punishable under s 6(6)(b) of the Children and Young Persons Act 1993 (“CYPA 1993”). Two offences under the CYPA and three offences under the CYPA 1993 were taken into consideration (TIC) for the purposes of sentencing. It should be noted that the offence in both s 5(1) CYPA and s 6(1) CYPA 1933 was substantively the same offence.
3 The prosecution was conducted by DPP James Chew. The Accused was represented by counsel Ms Sara Ng Qian Hui of Covenant Chambers LLC.
The charges
4 The three proceeded charges were -
(a) DAC-907405-2025 (“2nd Charge”): Between February to early March 2020, the accused had pinched his elder son (“V1”) on his upper chest. V1 was then nine years old.
(b) DAC-907409-2025 (“6th Charge”): Sometime in early January 2024, the accused had hit V1 on his arms and thigh multiple times. V1 was then 13 years old.
(c) DAC-907411-2025 (“8th Charge”): On 24 April 2021, the accused had hit his younger son (“V2”) on the buttocks and legs multiple times with a cane. V2 was then six years old.
5 In the two TIC offences under the CYPA, the accused had pinched V1 on his chest area and hit V1’s buttocks with a belt. In the three offences under the CYPA 1993, the accused had hit V1’s face and body multiple times, pinched him on his upper body, biting V1 on his right forearm and, hitting and pinching V1’s body multiple times.
6 V1 was diagnosed with high functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder (“ASD”). He has high cognitive ability but social functioning difficulties, with deficits in social communication, reciprocal social interaction and adaptive skills.
The facts
7 The accused admitted to the following facts –
a. On 23 March 2024, the accused had lodged a police report against himself for using excessive force when disciplining V1. On 30 May 2024, the accused’s wife lodged a police report against the accused for family violence against V1 and V2 over the past five years with increases in frequency and intensity recently. She stated that when the accused was angry, he slapped, pinched, kicked or caned the boys, or at times used belts or cable wires to punish them. He had also made them kneel, or denied them meals, as forms of punishment.
b. Sometime between February and early March 2020, while disciplining V1 over an incident, the accused had pinched V1 on his upper chest, causing bruises at his chest area. On 12 March 2020, V1’s tuition teacher noticed these bruises and she took a photo of the bruises as she felt this was not normal. V1 was 9 years old at the time. This was the subject-matter of the 2nd Charge.
c. On 24 April 2021, at the house of the accused’s parents, the accused became angry with V2 over something that he did. The accused made V2 take off his pants and faced the wall. The accused then forcefully hit V2 on the buttocks and legs several times with a cane. V2 suffered multiple linear marks and abrasions over his buttocks and the back of his legs. V2 was 6 years old at the time. This was the subject-matter of the 8th Charge.
d. Sometime in early January 2024, while at home, the accused was angered by V1’s rudeness. He hit V1 multiple times on the arms and thighs with his hands. He also grabbed and swung a vacuum machine pole and threatened to hit V1 with it but was prevented from doing it by his wife when she stepped in between him and V1. The accused had also made V1 knelt on the floor for a period. As a result of the accused’s actions, V1 suffered bruises and scratches. V1 was 13 years old at the time. This was the subject-matter of the 6th Charge.
8 Following another incident between the accused and V1 on 23 January 2023, the accused’s wife moved out of the flat with V1 and V2 and stayed with her sister to ensure their safety. She sought help from a child protection specialist centre. Thereafter, she lodged a police report.
Antecedents
9 The Accused was a first offender.
The sentence
Prosecution’s submissions on sentence
10 The prosecution submitted for a global sentence of 16 to 18 months’ imprisonment. The breakdown of the individual sentences was as follows –
(a) 2nd Charge - Eight to 10 months’ imprisonment.
(b) 6th Charge - Four to six months’ imprisonment.
(c) 8th Charge - Eight months’ imprisonment.
11 DPP Chew made the following sentencing submissions –
(a) In the case of physical child abuse, deterrence and retribution were the key pillars of sentencing because of the need to protect children who were unable to protect themselves.
(b) This emphasis on the protection of children was underscored by the enhancement of the prescribed punishment for the CYPA and the CYPA 1993 offences in 2019
Foot Note 1
Originally the prescribed punishment was “a fine not exceeding $4,000 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 4 years or to both”. The amended punishment provision was “a fine not exceeding $8,000 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 8 years or to both”.
(“the 2019 amendment”), in that, the maximum prescribed punishment was doubled. The doubling of the punishment was intended to “provide stronger protection for those who [could not] protect themselves”
Foot Note 2
Singapore Parliamentary Debates, Official Report (6 May 2019) Vol. 94, Sitting No. 103 - per Minister for Home Affairs Mr K Shanmugam at the second reading of the Criminal Law Reform Bill.
.
(c) Against this backdrop, DPP Chew submitted that the sentencing precedents involving cases prior to the 2019 amendment should be assessed with it in mind. This similarly applied to the observation of the Court of Appeal (“CA”) in PP v BDB [2018] 1 SLR 127 (“BDB”) that the sentence for non-fatal child abuse cases was at least six months’ imprisonment (at [86] of the judgment) as BDB was decided before the 2019 amendment.
12 DPP Chew set out the aggravating factors below –
(a) Abuse of the trust and confidence reposed in the accused as the victims’ father.
(b) Bodily injuries were suffered namely bruises and scratches, as described at [7] above.
(c) The physical abuses were perpetrated over a sustained period.
(d) Five similar charges involving the same victims were taken into consideration for the purpose of sentencing.
13 In relation to V1, DPP Chew submitted that the starting point sentence on a claim trial basis should be 11 to 13 months’ imprisonment for the 2nd Charge, and six to eight months’ imprisonment for the 6th Charge. After factoring the accused’s plea of guilty, the final sentences should be eight to 10 months’ imprisonment for the 2nd Charge and four to six months’ imprisonment for the 6th Charge. DPP Chew submitted that these sentences were in line with the following case precedents –
(a) PP v JDK [2025] SGDC 40 (“JDK”). The offender, a 24-year-old domestic helper, pleaded guilty to physically abusing an 11-month-old boy under her care on three separate occasions. The charges were punishable under s 6(6)(b) CYPA. Two similar charges were TIC. For the two charges of biting, she was sentenced to 10 months’ imprisonment. For the charge of pinching, a sentence of seven months’ imprisonment was imposed. The total sentence imposed was 20 months’ imprisonment. These sentences were upheld on appeal.
(b) PP v GEC [2021] SGDC 236(“GEC”). The offender, a 38-year-old mother, pleaded guilty to seven charges of ill-treating a child under CYPA. Four similar charges were TIC. She was sentenced to eight months’ imprisonment each on five charges and 10 months’ imprisonment each on two charges. The total sentence imposed was 36 months’ imprisonment.
(c) PP v AQF [2011] SGDC 75 (“AQF”). The offender pleaded guilty to two charges of ill-treating his two nephews, aged nine and 11. His nephews had stayed with him for the purpose of managing their disciplinary issues. He had caned them multiple times, causing multiple linear marks and scars. The sentence of six months’ imprisonment was imposed on each charge and was ordered to run concurrently.
14 In relation to V2, DPP Chew submitted that a sentence of eight months’ imprisonment for the 8th Charge was appropriate. He set out the aggravating factors below –
(a) Abuse of the trust and confidence in the accused as the father.
(b) Used a cane to inflict pain and injury.
(c) V2 suffered multiple linear marks and abrasions. These injuries showed the intensity and excessiveness of the punishment. They were also indicative of the substantial force used and the pain suffered by V2.
15 Because of the above, DPP Chew submitted that the sentence on a claim trial basis should be around 11 months’ imprisonment. After factoring the sentencing discount, the appropriate sentence should be eight months’ imprisonment. In totality, DPP Chew submitted that the sentences in the 2nd Charge and 6th Charge should be made to run consecutively, making the total aggregate sentence 16 to 18 months’ imprisonment.
Mitigation plea
16 Ms Sara Ng submitted for an initial global sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment for V1. After applying the sentencing discount, which she argued should be pegged at the full 30%, the final total sentence should be 8.5 months’ imprisonment. Ms Ng broke down the individual sentence as follows - six months’ imprisonment for the 2nd Charge and four months’ imprisonment for the 6th Charge. In relation to V2, she submitted that a sentence of six months’ imprisonment for the 8th Charge was appropriate.
17 In relation to the 2nd Charge, Ms Ng pointed out that the accused had pinched V1 only once and on the fleshier part of his upper chest. His motive was to chastise V1 for his rudeness to his mother. Ms Ng also distinguished JDK on the facts, in that, the victim in JDK was an 11-month-old infant and the offender had lied about her offences and had only come clean when confronted with the CCTV footages. Therefore, compared to JDK, the accused’s culpability was much lower given the victims in the present case were much older and the accused had made no attempt to conceal his actions. In fact, he had lodged the first police report against himself. Because of these fators, Ms Ng submitted for a sentence of six months’ imprisonment.
18 In relation to the 6th Charge, the accused had hit V1 with his hands out of frustration at V1’s lack of attention when being reprimanded by the accused. Ms Ng stressed that although the accused had grabbed a vacuum cleaner pole, it was not used to hit V1. The harm caused to V1 was not at the most severe end of the spectrum. She submitted that a sentence of four months’ imprisonment sufficiently reflected the need for deterrence.
19 In relation to the 8th Charge, Ms Ng conceded that the beatings administered was excessive. But she pointed out that they were not malicious and not targeted at the vulnerable parts of the body. On the strength of AQF, she submitted for a sentence of four months’ imprisonment, pointing out that the offender in AQF had committed similar acts of abuse and the injuries suffered were also multiple linear marks and scars. Ms Ng also cited PP v Azlin bte Arujunah [2020] SGHC 168 (“Azlin”) as further support. She pointed out that the offender in Azlin was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment for hitting the victim with a broom on his body, back and legs. These beatings had resulted in the victim’s kneecap being misaligned and causing him to walk with a limp. Given that the beatings and the injuries in Azlin were more far serious, the accused’s sentence should not be higher than six months’ imprisonment.
20 Ms Ng sought to distinguish GEC on the facts. She highlighted that the acts committed in GEC were vicious comprising kicking the victim’s head, slapping the child’s face and throwing a marker at the child’s head. These were vulnerable parts of the body and could have led to serious or permanent injuries.
21 Ms Ng agreed with the prosecution that the sentences for the 2nd Charge and the 8th Charge should be made to run consecutively but emphasised that the overall sentence should not be a crushing one.
22 Ns Ng stressed that there was no malice in the accused’s actions. The underlying motive for the physical abuses was discipline, and to educate and regulate the victims’ behaviour. The accused acknowledged that he had allowed his frustrations to get the better of him. She attributed his actions to the extreme challenges he faced in raising a child with special needs and who was intellectually gifted. She gave an account of the accused’s exceptional devotion to the development of his sons, going to the extent of resigning his civil service job and relocating to another country. His efforts had led to V1 obtaining a degree at the Australian National University with a perfect GPA at the age of 13.
The sentence
23 After considering the respective submissions by parties, I sentenced the accused to the following –
(a) 2nd Charge - Seven months’ imprisonment.
(b) 6th Charge - Four months’ imprisonment.
(c) 8th Charge - Eight months’ imprisonment.
I ordered the sentences in the 2nd Charge and 8th Charge to run consecutively, making the total aggregate sentence 15 months’ imprisonment. My reasons were set out below.
24 The dominant sentencing considerations in cases involving the ill-treatment of children were deterrence and retribution. The ill-treatment of children should be severely denounced and an uncompromising stance should also be adopted against the offenders of child abuse. The sentences imposed should accurately reflect public outrage that the offenders had taken advantage of the children’s vulnerability and to deter like-minded offenders. Such abuses were often committed the parents or caregivers. Violent acts against children were particularly odious when they were committed within the setting of a familial relationship because they destroyed the bonds of trust and interdependency that existed between family members: PP v UI [2008] 4 SLR(R) 500 (“UI”) at [33].
25 The CYPA 1933 was the latest revised edition of the Act. It incorporated all amendments up to and including 1 December 2021 and came into operation on 31 December 2021. The 2019 amendment that doubled the maximum prescribed punishment came into effect when the Act was in its CYPA iteration. When the CYPA was revised to the CYPA 1933, that amended penal provision remained unchanged in the statute. The rationale for the amendments has been addressed by DPP Chew at [11(b)] above.
26 To be clear, the prescribed punishment for the two CYPA and one CYPA 1933 charges before me was “to a fine not exceeding $8,000 or to a term of imprisonment not exceeding 8 years or to both”. BDB was decided in 2018, before the amendment. When the CA observed that the indicative starting sentence for non-fatal child abuse cases was ‘at least six months’ imprisonment, this was against the backdrop of the prescribed punishment set at a fine not exceeding $4,000 or to imprisonment not exceeding 4 years. With the doubling of the punishment, I agreed with DPP Chew that the observation in BDB should be considered with the 2019 amendment in mind. This was consistent with the court’s duty to consider the full spectrum of the sentencing range as prescribed by Parliament. Although the indicative starting sentence would not automatically doubled, but it would be reasonable to expect that an upward revision to the indicative starting sentence might be appropriate according to the facts of the case. Similarly, when I considered the case precedents that were decided before the 2019 amendment, I should apply the same caution.
27 Across the three charges, I found that as the father of V1 and V2, there was an abuse of the trust and confidence reposed in the accused. V2 was only abused once but the incidents of physical abuse on V1 was over a sustained period of time namely from September 2019 to January 2024. I disagreed that these physical abuses were a “misguided attempt at correction”. From the injuries suffered by the victims, and the fact that seven out of the eight acts of abuse were perpetrated on V1 who has ASD, showed that the abuses were more likely acts of lashing out in anger, and not a “misguided attempt at correction”. And because the accused had lashed out in anger, this did not mitigate or minimise his actions. The fact that an offence “…is committed out of anger does not mean that the offender was not able to make rational decisions at the material time. The law expects a person to be in control of his emotions and conduct even in moments of grave anger, and to face the consequences of failing to do so. Deterrence is concerned with making it clear what those consequences are likely to be even if the proscribed act is done in a moment of anger”: BDB at [94].
28 In relation to the 2nd Charge, the injuries caused by the act of pinching V1’s upper chest as shown in the photographs revealed that significant force was exerted by the accused in pinching V1. It also gave an indication of the pain felt by V1. I noted that one of the TIC charges involved a similar act of pinching V1. In relation to the 6th Charge, the photographs of the injuries caused ie, to the back of V1’s neck and the upper arm of both hands, revealed the amount of force used by the accused to assault V1 with his hands. The fact that the injuries were inflicted on various parts of V1’s body suggested that the beatings were administered indiscriminately. The injuries also suggested that the pain caused to V1 must be significant.
29 In my view, taking all these factors into account, in relation to the 2nd Charge, had the accused been convicted after a trial, the sentence would have been between nine to ten months’ imprisonment. In relation to the 6th Charge, the sentence on a claim trial basis would have been between six to eight months’ imprisonment. After factoring the 30% sentencing discount, the sentence for the 2nd Charge was seven months’ imprisonment and the sentence for the 6th Charge was four months’ imprisonment.
30 In relation to the 8th Charge, a cane was used. The injuries as shown in the photographs revealed two significant things – one, the force used by the accused to administer the beatings and tow, the intensity of the beatings. Given that V2 was then only six years old, the pain felt by V2 must have been significant. Had the accused claimed trial and was convicted, I would have imposed a sentence between 11 to 12 months’ imprisonment. On account of the 30% sentencing discount, the sentence for the 8th Charge was eight months’ imprisonment.
31 These sentences were aligned with the case precedents cited by DPP Chew. These cases were decided after the 2019 amendment. In JDK, the offender was sentenced to seven months’ imprisonment for pinching the victim. In GEC, the offender was sentenced to eight months’ imprisonment each in relation to five charges involving slapping the face repeatedly, kicking the body repeatedly, and pulling the ears. It bore noting that in AQF, which was decided before the 2019 amendment, the offender was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment each for caning two boys multiple times. Given the doubling of the maximum punishment post-amendment, and after considering the full spectrum of the sentencing range prescribed by Parliament, the eight months’ imprisonment sentence meted out on the accused on the 8th Charge was not inconsistent with the sentence meted out in AQF.
32 Lastly, I ordered the imprisonment sentences in the 2nd Charge and 8th Charges to run consecutively. This was because these two charges were distinct offences and involved two different victims. The total aggregate sentence of 15 months’ imprisonment was, on the whole, proportionate to the gravity of the accused’s offences and his degree of culpability.
Conclusion
33 The Accused has lodged an appeal against sentence. He is presently on bail pending appeal.
Shaiffudin Saruwan District Judge
DPP James Chew (Attorney-General’s Chambers) for the Prosecution
Sara Ng Qian Hui (Ms) (Covenant Chambers LLC) for the Accused
This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.