This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

In the GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE high court of the republic of singapore
[2026] SGHC 235
Originating Claim No 609 of 2025
Between
Lu Zhen
… Claimant
And
(1)
Vivva Capital VCC
(2)
Quek Chin Chuan, Edward
(3)
Lau Zenan, Charles
… Defendants
judgment
[Contract — Breach]
[Tort — Inducement of breach of contract]
[Tort — Misrepresentation — Fraudulent misrepresentation]
[Tort — Misrepresentation — Section 2(1) of the Misrepresentation Act 1967]


This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Lu Zhen
v
Vivva Capital VCC and others
[2026] SGHC 235
General Division of the High Court — Originating Claim No 609 of 2025
Audrey Lim J
4–7, 11–12 August, 5 October 2026
13 November 2026 Judgment reserved.
Audrey Lim J:
Introduction
1 The claimant, Mr Lu Zhen (“Lu”), invested US$1m in the Vivva Energy Fund, a sub-fund of the first defendant, Vivva Capital VCC (“Vivva”). Vivva is a variable capital company incorporated in Singapore on 21 July 2022. The second defendant, Mr Edward Quek (“Quek”), has been a director of Vivva since 15 February 2024. The third defendant, Mr Charles Lau (“Lau”), was an employee and representative of Vivva at all material times. The Vivva Energy Fund was initially named the Vivva Macro Fund but was renamed in April 2024. I refer to the Vivva Macro Fund or the Vivva Energy Fund as “VEF”.
2 Lu claims the defendants made various representations which induced him to invest in the VEF, and those representations turned out to be false. He thus claims against them for fraudulent misrepresentation, or alternatively, under s 2(1) of the Misrepresentation Act 1967 (2020 Rev Ed) (“MA”). He further claims that Vivva had acted in breach of contract and that Quek procured or induced Vivva’s breach of contract.
Claimant’s case
3 As the chronology of events is largely undisputed, I set them out here.
4 Prior to the material events of HC/OC 609/2025 (“OC 609”), Lu and Quek had known each other for several years. Lu came to know Lau around 5 October 2023 when the latter contacted him on WeChat on Vivva’s behalf.
5 On 14 October 2023, Quek sent Lu some PowerPoint slides in English and Chinese (“Vivva Slides”) over WeChat. Lu claims the following representations were made in that WeChat conversation with Quek (“14 Oct Reps”):
(a) The Vivva Slides contained a chart in English (“1st English Chart”) and in Chinese (“1st Chinese Chart”), which represented that:
(i) from January to September 2023, the VEF made monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 3.79%; and
(ii) from January to September 2023, the VEF’s total profit was 21.44%, which outperformed investments in Brent Crude (“Brent”) and the Standard and Poor’s 500 Index (“S&P 500”) over the same period.
(b) The Vivva Slides represented that 80% of any capital invested with the VEF would be protected.
(c) Lu asked Quek if the fund described in the Vivva Slides was an investment product from Quek’s company. Quek affirmed this.
6 On 19 October 2023, Lu and Quek had another WeChat conversation (“19/10/23 WeChat”), and Lu claims the following representations were made (“19 Oct Reps”):
(a) Through voice messages, Quek stated that the VEF had profited over 3% that week and, due to ongoing military conflicts, it was changing its investment strategy as follows:
(i) The VEF would use 20% of the invested funds to buy oil futures and keep 80% for price differential trading in oil.
(ii) The VEF’s overall investment strategy was very stable because it would stop trading once the value of invested funds dropped by 20%, and 80% of the invested funds would be locked in price differential trading in oil which was very stable.
(b) Lu then asked Quek if this meant that the total annual profit would work out to be 150% to 250%. Quek did not refute Lu’s calculation but instead said that they could not admit that it had such large annual profit margins as clients would not believe them.
(c) Quek then sent Lu another chart setting out the VEF’s performance from January to September 2023 (“2nd Chinese Chart”). This chart represented that:
(i) from January to September 2023, the VEF made monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 3.79% from trading in oil;
(ii) the VEF’s total profit from oil trading from January to September 2023 was 21.44%, which outperformed investments in Brent and/or the S&P 500 over the same period; and
(iii) if the VEF could be invested without any constraints, its total profit from January to September 2023 would have been 250%.
(d) Lu asked Quek how much money the VEF had under its management. Quek replied that US$15m had been invested in the VEF, with another US$10m forthcoming (“AOM Representation”).
7 On 11 December 2023, Quek sent Lu three documents in English, namely: (a) a subscription application form for the VEF (“Subscription Form”); (b) a document titled “Documents to Accompany this Subscription Application Form”; and (c) a combined document containing an Information Memorandum for Vivva (“IM”) and a Private Placement Memorandum for the VEF (“PPM”).
8 Lu asked Quek if he had copies of the documents in English and Chinese. He also asked Quek if the three documents pertained to the VEF and Quek confirmed this. From this, and it is undisputed, Lu understood the Subscription Form was for him to subscribe to the VEF, which would be managed as described in the Vivva Slides.
9 On 22 December 2023, Lau sent Lu a document (“Chinese Marketing Materials” or “CM Materials”). The CM Materials contained an updated version of the 1st and 2nd Chinese Charts setting out the VEF’s performance up till November 2023 (“3rd Chinese Chart”). Lu claims the CM Materials set out these “CMM Reps”:
(a) from January to November 2023, the VEF made monthly profits from oil trading ranging from 1.14% to 4.5%;
(b) from January to November 2023, the VEF’s total profit from oil trading was 25.94%, which outperformed investments in Brent or the S&P 500 over the same period;
(c) the VEF’s returns would be independent of market direction;
(d) the VEF’s chief trader had 23 years’ trading experience in the energy market;
(e) the VEF would allocate roughly 65%, 20% and 15% of its moneys to oil market arbitrage trading, directional trading and scalping trading respectively;
(f) if the VEF’s value decreased by 10% from its initial value (based on principal sums invested by investors) (“initial value”), it would conduct a full portfolio review; and
(g) if the VEF’s value decreased by 20% from its initial value; the VEF would stop all trading to protect its capital from further erosion.
10 On 26 December 2023, Lu messaged Quek and Lau separately with a screenshot of the last page of the CM Materials, asking how the annual management and performance fees were calculated. Lau attests that he replied, directing Lu to the “Performance Test Scenario” page of the CM Materials which contained two fee examples, one for a normal scenario and one for a capital-constrained scenario, and that Quek also sent a message to Lu to state that Lau would explain the matter further in person to Lu.
11 Lu claims that, in reliance on the 14 Oct Reps, 19 Oct Reps and CMM Reps, he decided to invest in the VEF.
12 On the same day, Quek and Lau met Lu (“26/12/23 Meeting”). Lu claims the following occurred:
(a) After Lu indicated he was willing to invest US$1m, Quek and Lau provided Lu with hardcopies of the Subscription Form and a “Singapore Tax Questionnaire” (“26 Dec Documents”).
(b) Lu asked Quek and Lau if the 26 Dec Documents were consistent with the CMM Reps, and they both affirmed this.
(c) Relying on the 14 Oct Reps, 19 Oct Reps and CMM Reps made at the 26/12/23 Meeting, Lu signed the 26 Dec Documents.
(d) Lu then asked Quek and Lau why there was only one copy of the documents. Lau replied that scanned copies of signed documents were legal and valid in Singapore and that he would email a copy of the signed documents to Lu.
13 On 27 December 2023, Lau emailed Lu (copying Quek) to thank Lu for his support and attached the 26 Dec Documents signed by Lu, another copy of the CM Materials, and an annex with explanations on the effect of being treated as an accredited investor (“Lau’s 27/12/23 Email”). Lu claims the documents comprising the contract (“Contract”) were the CM Materials, Subscription Form (and its incorporated documents), PPM and IM. The defendants claim the contract documents did not include the CM Materials.
14 On 2 January 2024, Lu transferred US$1m (“Investment Sum”) to the VEF’s bank account.
Events after Lu’s investment
15 Subsequently, on 8 January 2024, Vivva entered a joint venture agreement (“JVA”) with Hendon Energy Pte Ltd (“Hendon”). In January 2024, Vivva remitted US$1.56m from the VEF to Hendon. Lu claims he was unaware of this at that time and believed that Vivva was investing the VEF’s moneys without any third-party involvement. He claims he only discovered Hendon’s involvement in the VEF in October 2024 (see [20]–[21] below). Quek and Lau attest that the US$1.56m remitted to Hendon included Lu’s Investment Sum.
16 On 18 April 2024, Lu asked Lau for an update on the VEF’s performance for the first quarter of 2024. On 22 April 2024, Lau emailed a report (“Q1 2024 Report”) to Lu, copying Quek. The Q1 2024 Report stated that the VEF made returns of 2.3% for the first quarter of 2024 and the net dividend Lu would receive was US$13,435.90.
17 Lu pleads that on 24 April 2024, Lau messaged him on WeChat to say that the VEF had only traded in the month of March for the first quarter of 2024, and Vivva would refund Lu two-thirds of the management fees paid by Lu amounting to US$3,333.33. Including the dividend due to Lu, the total moneys due to Lu were US$16,769.33. It is undisputed that Lu received this sum on 30 April 2024.
18 On 26 June 2024, Lu asked Lau for updates on the VEF’s performance for the second quarter of 2024. Lau gave no substantive response.
19 On 27 and 28 July 2024, Lu told Quek that he wanted to withdraw the Investment Sum (ie, to redeem all his participating shares in the VEF). Quek responded with holding replies. Quek and Lau attest that at that time, VEF’s moneys were already committed to the investment arrangement with Hendon. On 22 October 2024, Lu repeated his request to withdraw his Investment Sum. Lu claims that both times, Vivva took no steps to fulfil his requests, and that even as at 22 October 2024, he was unaware that the Investment Sum was not with Vivva but with Hendon.
20 On 24 October 2024, Lu met with Lau (“24/10/24 Meeting”). Lu claims as follows. Lau informed him that due to Hendon’s mismanagement, the VEF had lost almost all its value. When Lu asked for more information, he was redirected to one Alex Ng (“Alex”), who was present at the meeting. He was not informed that Alex was not an employee of Vivva but was in fact from Hendon. Therefore, Lu was led to believe that Alex was Vivva’s employee. Lu then asked Lau and Alex several follow-up questions but received no response. Lau attests that he had acted in good faith in updating Lu and informed Lu that Hendon had defaulted and failed to return the VEF moneys.
21 Lu further attests that: (a) he did not know of Hendon’s involvement in the VEF until the 24/10/24 Meeting; and (b) he only realised that Alex was not from Vivva, on around 2 December 2024. According to Lu, around December 2023, Quek and Lau introduced Alex to Lu, and stated that Alex dealt with oil investment trading and was an employee of Vivva. Lu claims he was not informed then that Alex would manage any trading for the VEF. Subsequently, in April 2024, Quek arranged a dinner with Lu and told him that he would also arrange for “[Vivva’s] trader” to attend. After Lu found out on 2 December 2024 that Alex was not Vivva’s employee but from Hendon, he stopped communicating with Alex.
22 On 29 October 2024, Lu reminded Quek of his request to withdraw the Investment Sum. Quek replied that he did not have information to update Lu on the status of the VEF. On 2 December 2024, Quek asked Lu to talk to Alex directly. As Lu knew then that Alex was from Hendon, Lu responded that he had no direct relationship with Alex and told Quek to discuss with Lau and liaise with Alex.
23 Lu claims that once again, Quek did not follow up on his request. On 9 January 2025, Lu wrote to VEF’s fund manager, Carrington RHT Investments Pte Ltd (“Carrington Investments”), demanding compensation. On 15 January 2025, Ms Lam Ching Ching (“Lam”), then a representative of Carrington Investments and signing off as the chief executive officer and director of the “Carrington group of companies”, replied that Vivva and Carrington Investments were working internally to resolve Lu’s concerns and blamed Alex for the losses. Again, Lu claims he received no substantial answers thereafter, save that two days later, Lam forwarded Lu a letter of demand from Vivva (dated 16 January 2025) to Hendon.
24 Lu subsequently discovered the following:
(a) Although the JVA was dated 8 January 2024 and Vivva had allegedly transferred US$1.56m to Hendon by 31 January 2024, a letter from Hendon’s lawyers dated 12 March 2025 (“Hendon’s 12/3/25 Letter”) to the defendants’ lawyers (“CTLC”) stated that Hendon had only commenced trading on 1 March 2024.
(b) The defendants had not fulfilled Lu’s request to withdraw from the VEF. Instead, Hendon’s 12/3/25 Letter showed that Hendon had continued trading even after the defendants were informed, on 23 October 2024, that the joint venture had lost almost all its funding due to an unexpected spike in the oil market.
(c) The defendants appointed or instructed Alex to operate Lu’s investments in the VEF without informing Lu that Alex was an undischarged bankrupt and a Hendon employee.
25 On 11 April 2025, Lu’s lawyers (Cairnhill Law LLC) sent a demand letter to Vivva (“11/4/25 Demand Letter”), stating that the defendants had made various misrepresentations that Lu had relied on to his detriment, and that Lu was thus rescinding the Contract and demanding the return of his Investment Sum.
26 On 5 August 2025, Lu commenced OC 609 against the defendants for fraudulent misrepresentation and other claims (see [2] above). In particular, Lu claims that in reliance on the defendants’ representations, he signed the Contract with, and transferred the Investment Sum to, Vivva. Had he known the representations were untrue, he would not have invested in the VEF.
27 On 24 December 2025, Cairnhill Law LLC wrote to CTLC for production of documents relating to the VEF investments from January to November 2023. On 5 January 2026, CTLC replied to state that the defendants did not have any documents dated 2023 as requested. On 7 January 2026, CTLC further stated that the VEF had no business before 2023 and thus there were no documents in 2023. Lu claims CTLC’s reply was a complete shock to him given the representations that: (a) US$15m had been invested in the VEF with another US$10m forthcoming (ie, the AOM Representation); (b) from January to November 2023, the VEF made monthly profits of between 1.14% to 4.5%; and (c) the VEF’s total profit from oil trading from January to November 2023 was 25.94%, which was better than the returns from investing in Brent or the S&P 500. On 16 February 2026, Quek and Lau confirmed, on affidavit, that Vivva did not carry on any business on or before 2023.
Defendants’ case
28 Quek attests as follows. In 2022, he approached Mr Raymond Lau (“Raymond”) to set up an entity as Quek wanted to enter the trading business in capital markets. Quek paid for the incorporation of Vivva in July 2022. At that time, Raymond informed him that Lam (Raymond’s wife) had to be appointed a director of Vivva because Carrington Investments would be Vivva’s fund manager. Quek assumed and believed that he was also a director from the time of Vivva’s incorporation. Sometime before February 2024 (when he performed a company registration search), he discovered he was not registered as a director and Lam was the sole director from Vivva’s incorporation. Quek was then formally made a director of Vivva on 15 February 2024 and remains its sole director, as Lam had ceased to be a director on 24 December 2024. Nevertheless, Quek had always been in charge of and running Vivva from its incorporation, he was the boss, and Lam had never interfered in Quek’s management of Vivva. Pertaining to Lu’s investment in the VEF, Quek had dealt with Lu as if he was the director of Vivva, and he also conveyed to Lu that he was the boss of Vivva and that Vivva was his company. By Quek’s own admission, he was the de facto director of Vivva at the material times.
29 The chronology of events (set out above) is largely undisputed. Particularly, it is undisputed that Vivva and the VEF never traded in 2023; the defendants stated the VEF only started trading in March 2024. I thus set out the salient points of departure from Lu’s version of events and the defendants’ defence.
30 In relation to the documents or materials that Quek or Lau had sent to Lu, the defendants claim as follows:
(a) The Vivva Slides contained disclaimers stating that the slides were for information purposes and did not constitute investment advice, that investors were encouraged to seek independent professional advice, that past performance or historical results were not indicative of future results, and that forward-looking statements were subject to risks and uncertainties (“Disclaimer”). Therefore, no binding representation or contractual assurance was given by Quek on 14 October 2023.
(b) Although Quek made the 19 Oct Reps, the defendants did not promise that they could generate annual profits of 150% to 250% (see [6(b)] above).
(c) As for the PPM and Subscription Form that Quek sent to Lu on 11 December 2023, the PPM likewise contained clear and express risk disclosure and disclaimers. Lu was also advised to seek legal advice.
(d) The CM Materials that Lau sent to Lu on 22 December 2023 again contained disclaimers and were for illustrative purposes and not intended as binding contractual promises.
31 Next, the defendants accept that, at the 26/12/23 Meeting, Lu was given the hardcopies of the 26 Dec Documents after he stated that he was willing to invest US$1m, and Lau informed Lu (after Lu had signed the documents) that scanned copies of signed documents were legal and valid in Singapore and that that he would email a copy of the signed documents to Lu (see [12(a)] and [12(d)] above). However, Lau denies that Lu had specifically asked him and Quek if the 26 Dec Documents were consistent with the CMM Reps (see [12(b)] above). Quek contends that by signing the documents, Lu expressly confirmed that he had read, understood and accepted the PPM, he was an accredited investor, he did not rely on any representations outside the PPM, and he understood the risk of total capital loss.
32 The defendants also plead and attest that Lu had always been aware that Hendon and Alex were involved in trading for the VEF. Lu had met Alex in December 2023 and been in “direct contact” with him. Further, Lu had acknowledged in writing that investment decisions would be made by the VEF or its appointed managers according to the PPM. Therefore, prior to signing the Contract, Lu would have known that any trading activities would be carried out by Hendon or Alex and not by Quek or Lau.
33 On 5 August 2024, Alex (on Hendon’s behalf) emailed Quek and Lau, reporting that, pursuant to the JVA in relation to the VEF, Hendon had a negative performance for the second quarter of 2024. On 23 October 2024, Hendon suffered “catastrophic losses” resulting in the total loss of the VEF’s capital. Thereafter, Lau met Lu on 24 October 2024 and updated him “in good faith” that Hendon had defaulted and failed to return the moneys in the VEF.
34 Thus, the defendants deny they made any misrepresentations, and that the loss to the moneys invested in the VEF was caused solely by Hendon’s or Alex’s fraudulent acts and breaches of the JVA. They further claim that Lu, as an accredited investor, had understood and accepted the risks, including risk of complete loss of capital.
35 On 16 January 2025, CTLC then issued a demand letter to Hendon on Vivva’s behalf. On 24 November 2025, the defendants filed a third-party notice against Hendon and Alex. However, they did not pursue this further. Quek claims this is due to a lack of resources and complications in taking action against Alex, who is a bankrupt.
36 Finally, the defendants claim that, when Lu asked to withdraw his Investment Sum in July and October 2024, they were unable to effect Lu’s requests as the VEF’s moneys had already been placed with Hendon. After entering the JVA, Vivva transferred US$1.56m to Hendon, comprising Lu’s Investment Sum, Quek’s personal funds of US$460,000, and other investors’ funds. Hendon (through Alex) was responsible for all trading activities and the defendants had no control or oversight of the trades. Instead, they relied on trading reports and updates by Hendon. In any event, Lu was not entitled to immediate redemption upon request as the PPM expressly provided that redemptions were not guaranteed or were otherwise subject to conditions.
37 The defendants thus deny that Vivva had breached the Contract or that Quek had procured any such breach.
Issues for determination
38 The following issues arise for my determination:
(a) whether Lu’s claim for misrepresentation is made out in relation to the 14 Oct Reps, 19 Oct Reps, CMM Reps, and essentially the representations made at the 26/12/23 Meeting as well as the re-sending of the CM Materials on 27 December 2023;
(b) whether Lu’s claim against Vivva for breach of contract is made out;
(c) whether Lu’s claim against Quek for procuring or inducing Vivva to breach the Contract is made out; and
(d) the appropriate reliefs, if any.
Fraudulent misrepresentation
39 For a claim in fraudulent misrepresentation, there must be a representation of fact by words or conduct, made with the intent that it should be acted on by the claimant. The claimant must have acted upon the false statement and suffered damage by so doing. Finally, the representation must be made with the knowledge that it is false; it must be wilfully false or at least made in the absence of any genuine belief that it is true (Panatron Pte Ltd v Lee Cheow Lee [2001] 2 SLR(R) 435 (“Panatron”) at [14]).
40 I begin by dealing with whether the 14 Oct Reps, 19 Oct Reps and CMM Reps (collectively, “Representations”) were made by Vivva, Quek and/or Lau; whether the Representations were false and whether the defendants made them knowing they were false or at least made them in the absence of any genuine belief that they were true. I then deal with whether the Representations were made to induce Lu to invest in the VEF and whether Lu relied on the Representations to so invest.
Whether the 14 Oct Reps were made by Vivva and Quek
41 It is undisputed that Quek sent Lu the Vivva Slides on 14 October 2023 with the 1st Chinese and English Charts, and that the slides pertained to the VEF. In that WeChat conversation, Lu asked Quek whether it was “a prospectus to your company’s investment products” whereupon Quek said “Yes”. This supports Lu’s claim at [5(c)] above. Quek admitted that he informed Lu he was the boss of Vivva and Vivva was his company (see [28] above).
42 Next, I accept Lu’s claim that the 1st Chinese and English Charts represented that from January to September 2023: (a) VEF made monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 3.79%; and (b) VEF’s total profit was 21.44%, which outperformed investments in Brent and S&P 500 over the same period (collectively, “Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results”).
43 I find the reference in the 1st Chinese and English Charts to the VEF’s “% Return” and “YTD 2023” conveyed the VEF’s actual returns year-to-date from January to September 2023. The notes below the charts also stated that the VEF’s returns were calculated as “profits paid out” or calculated based on “distributed profits” [emphasis in italics added].
44 In court, Quek admitted that the figures in the 1st Chinese and English Charts were for January to September 2023, being actual historical figures, and that they were accurate as at end September 2023 before he sent the Vivva Slides to Lu. He also admitted the charts represented that Vivva made a profit in each of the months stated therein (eg, 1.26% in January 2023 and 1.14% in February 2023) and that “YTD 2023” meant “year to date 2023”. In particular, he stated that the comparative figures in the charts for Brent and S&P 500 were actual historical figures. Lau confirmed this and he stated he obtained the figures for Brent and S&P 500 from online searches. Quek also conceded that the charts showed the overall performance for the VEF (from January to September 2023) at 21.44% was better than having invested in Brent and S&P 500; and that the comparison to Brent and S&P 500 in the charts was meant to convey to potential investors that the VEF had outperformed them in the previous nine months.
45 I disbelieve Quek and Lau’s qualification however, that the 1st Chinese and English Charts were merely “simulations” or a “forecast” of how the VEF might have performed from January to September 2023 and in contrast to the actual performance of Brent and S&P 500. Their explanation is unbelievable in light of what was presented in the charts (see [43]–[44] above) and an afterthought to explain away that VEF never traded in 2023 and only started trading in 2024. Indeed, the defendants admitted in their Defence to the representations made in the 2nd Chinese Chart (see [6(c)] above), which representations mirrored the 1st Chinese and English Charts at [5(a)] and [42] above. In court, Quek and Lau admitted the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results were fabricated.
46 The Disclaimer (see [30(a)] above) reflected in the Vivva Slides does not assist the defendants. It does not state that the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results were hypothetical, a “simulation” or a “forecast”. Instead, the Disclaimer stated that “Historical results are not indicators of future performance/results”, which conveys to a reader that the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results (being matters prior to October 2023, the date stated at the beginning of the Vivva Slides) were “historical”. Lau admits, albeit in relation to similar wording in the CM Materials, that the reader would be under the impression that there are historical results for the VEF. Moreover, the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results cannot be a “forecast” as Quek claims. In court, Quek admitted that a “forecast” is about forecasting into the future, and Lau admitted that a “projection” is forward- looking. Quek also accepted that the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results did not reflect a future event.
47 Finally, I accept that the Vivva Slides, which state “80% capital protection”, represented that 80% of any capital invested with the VEF would be protected. Quek admitted as much in court. He further explained that this meant that once the invested sum dropped by 20% in value, Vivva would have to halt the trading, and that it cannot continue to trade thereafter without getting the investor’s go ahead. In other words, without the investor’s approval to continue trading, the investor would get back 80% of his invested sum.
48 In sum, I find the 14 Oct Reps were made, as Lu claims.
49 Further, it is clear Vivva and Quek made the Oct 14 Reps to Lu. The Vivva Slides were sent to Lu by Quek on Vivva’s behalf. Although the Vivva Slides were prepared by Lau, this was based on Quek’s instructions and authorisation. In court, Quek confirmed he saw the Vivva Slides before they were sent to Lu and he authorised the representations therein to be made. Whilst Quek was not formally made a director at that time, it is undisputed that he was running Vivva and represented to Lu as such (see [28] above).
Whether the 14 Oct Reps were false and whether Vivva and Quek made them knowing they were false
50 Lu claims that the 14 Oct Reps were untrue and that Vivva and Quek made them knowing they were false. First, the VEF had no monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 3.79%, nor a total profit of 21.44%, from January to September 2023, as it had not even been active until March 2024. Second, it had no 80% capital protection mechanism, as evidenced by the loss of Lu’s entire Investment Sum. The defendants argue that they had a genuine belief that the 14 Oct Reps were true, because those representations were based on information they obtained from Alex / Hendon.
51 I find that the 14 Oct Reps, regarding the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results and 80% capital protection mechanism, were false and that Vivva and Quek had made them knowing they were false, or, at minimum, the representations were made recklessly without caring whether they were true or false.
52 First, I consider the representation in the 1st Chinese and English Charts regarding the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results. The 1st Chinese and English Charts were titled “Projected Results: Simulated Investment” and “Pro Forma Results: Portfolio Simulation” respectively. Each contained a graph, and a table showing the Jan–Sept 2023 VEF Results against the performance of Brent and S&P 500 over the same period (“1st Chart Table”).
53 Quek knew for a fact that the VEF made no profits from January to September 2023 because, as he claimed, it only started trading on 1 March 2024. In court, he further admitted he knew (before he sent the Vivva Slides to Lu) that the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results were false and should have been reflected as 0% from January to September 2023. Quek’s lack of credibility can be seen from the fact that he admitted in cross-examination that the Jan–Sept 2023 VEF Results were actual historical results of the VEF’s performance, but claimed inconsistently that this was a forecast of future performance although the 1st Chart Table was not referring to a future event. For completeness, Lau (who prepared the Vivva Slides) also knew the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results were false, as he knew that Vivva and the VEF had not started trading at the time the slides were sent to Lu. Indeed, as Lu’s counsel pointed out in court, if the defendants had intended to merely illustrate what the VEF could achieve in the future, there was no reason to have shown the Jan–Sept 2023 VEF Results in percentage returns right down to two decimal places. Clearly what the defendants were attempting to do was to make the figures as realistic as possible, to deceive Lu.
54 Thus, even if the defendants obtained the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results from Alex or Hendon, as they claim, this was immaterial to Lu’s claim for misrepresentation against the defendants. To begin with, there is no evidence that Lu knew at the material time that the defendants obtained the information for the Vivva Slides from Alex or Hendon. Quek also agreed that even if the information for the Vivva Slides were provided to Vivva by Alex or Hendon, Quek had a duty to verify the accuracy of the information that was eventually conveyed to Lu, as Lu was contracting with Vivva and not Hendon/Alex.
55 Next, I consider the representation regarding the 80% capital protection mechanism. The Vivva Slides stated that the VEF had a “Capital Protection Mechanism”, or a “stop-loss mechanism”, that provided “80% capital protection”. Again, I find this representation was false and that Vivva and Quek had made it knowing it was false. Whilst Quek admitted in cross-examination that the Vivva Slides represented that the VEF had a capital protection mechanism of 80% (see [47] above), this representation was made in conjunction with the representation that Vivva was already trading in January 2023 (viz. the Jan–Sep 2023 VEF Results) which was untrue.
56 In any event, even if the representation pertaining to the 80% capital protection was a statement of intent, this statement may give rise to an actionable misrepresentation of fact, if it can be shown that at the time Vivva and Quek made the representation, they did not honestly hold the intention they were expressing or did not intend to follow through with what was represented (Tan Chin Seng v Raffles Town Club Pte Ltd [2003] 3 SLR(R) 307 at [12]–[13]; Yong Khong Yoong Mark v Ting Choon Meng [2022] SGHC(A) 21 at [17]–[18]). I find that, at the time of making the representation, Vivva and Quek (and Lau, who prepared the Vivva Slides) did not honestly hold the intention they expressed and did not intend to follow through with what was represented.
57 At the time of the 14 Oct Reps, even Hendon had not traded with the VEF funds. However, Quek claims that Vivva had already been negotiating the terms of the JVA with Hendon a few months before Vivva intended to set up the VEF. Yet, when Vivva entered into the JVA with Hendon in January 2024 (see [15] above), more than two months after the 14 Oct Reps, the JVA provided for a stop-loss of 25% of the invested amounts. This was more disadvantageous (to investors of the VEF) than the stop-loss of 20% represented in the Vivva Slides. Clause 5.3(a) of the JVA provided that:
Unless otherwise agreed by VIVVA Capital in order not to effect closure of the Joint Venture, in the event the Joint Venture suffer losses from the Business on any given day amounting to 25% of the Principal Investment Amount, Hendon shall close all existing trading positions immediately on best efforts basis to recover investment monies (the “Stop Loss Closure”). Hendon shall immediately report to VIVVA Capital VCC on the state of the Joint Venture.
In the event that the Joint Venture suffers an overnight intra-day loss of more than 10% of the Principal Investment Amount on any given trading day, Hendon shall report to VIVVA Capital on the latest state of the Joint Venture accordingly on immediate basis no later than close of business/market on the following day.
[emphasis in original]
58 Quek and Lau would have known of the terms of the JVA (including cl 5.3(a)) as Quek signed the JVA on Vivva’s behalf and this was witnessed by Lau. In cross-examination, Quek could not explain why he had agreed to the above term in the JVA although (as he claimed) he and Vivva had been negotiating the terms of the JVA some months before Vivva intended to set up the VEF. There was, in effect, no 20% stop-loss mechanism in place and thus no guaranteed 80% capital protection, regardless of which entity eventually traded with the VEF’s funds, and I find the defendants knew this when the Vivva Slides were prepared and sent to Lu. Quek’s assertion that the trading was not within the VEF’s control but was done by Hendon merely reinforces my finding that at the time Vivva and Quek made the representation (pertaining to the 80% capital protection), they did not have any genuine belief in its truth. In any event, Quek’s assertion does not explain why he/Vivva chose to sign a JVA with Hendon providing for a stop-loss mechanism of 25% instead.
Whether the 19 Oct Reps were made by Vivva and Quek
59 I turn to the 19 Oct Reps which occurred during the 19/10/23 WeChat between Lu and Quek (see [6] above). I find they were made by Vivva and Quek.
60 In their Defence, the defendants admit to making the representations save that they did not promise that annual profits of 150% to 250% could be generated for Lu (see [6(b)] above). That said, in court, Quek admitted that he made the 19 Oct Reps to Lu. He agreed that Lu had asked him in the 19/10/23 WeChat whether the returns on the VEF were between 3% to 5% in the few days prior to 19 October 2023, whereupon Quek replied that “We definitely earned from the spread of the price differential, these few days this week definitely exceeded 3%”. Quek agreed he was conveying to Lu about the VEF. Quek also admitted to what transpired between Lu and him as stated in [6(a)], [6(b)] and [6(d)] above and that he responded to Lu regarding the VEF when he sent the 2nd Chinese Chart to Lu. In particular, when Lu asked Quek on WeChat “How much capital have you managed on this project?”, Quek replied essentially to state US$15m with another US$10m forthcoming. Conspicuously, neither Quek nor Lau’s affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) mentions the 19/10/23 WeChat conversation.
Whether the 19 Oct Reps were false and whether Vivva and Quek made them knowing they were false
61 Lu claims the 19 Oct Reps were false and that Vivva and Quek made them knowing they were false. First, the VEF had no monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 3.79%, nor a total profit of 21.44%, from January to September 2023, because it had not been active until March 2024. Second, as of 19 October 2023, the VEF did not have US$15m invested or another US$10m in investment forthcoming. The VEF remitted only US$1.56m to Hendon on 8 January 2024, which was almost 100% of the total moneys invested in the VEF (including Lu’s Investment Sum).
62 I find that the 19 Oct Reps were false and that Vivva and Quek had made them knowing they were false, or were, at the minimum, reckless as to their truth.
63 The information conveyed to Lu regarding Vivva’s past performance (such as Quek informing Lu that VEF had profited over 3%, or Vivva and Quek sending Lu the 2nd Chinese Chart pertaining to Vivva’s performance from January to September 2023) was patently false. The VEF did not trade at all in 2023 and the defendants knew that. I reiterate my findings at [43]–[45] and [53]–[54] above.
64 Likewise, the AOM Representation was false. Vivva did not then have US$15m under its management, nor another US$10m forthcoming. Quek claims the reference to US$15m (conveyed to Lu) was based off assets handled by Hendon and Alex. Even if this were the case, I find he had conveyed the AOM Representation to Lu fraudulently. Quek admitted that the US$15m in funds purportedly handled by Hendon and/or Alex had nothing to do with the VEF. He claimed also that the second tranche of US$10m was merely a “potential”, as he/Vivva had approached an investor but this did not materialise. I disbelieve Quek’s claim as such, as it was not supported by any evidence. Importantly also, the defendants never mentioned or represented to Lu (including in any of the materials sent to Lu prior to Lu investing in the VEF) that it was Hendon / Alex that would be trading for the VEF or that the US$15m pertained to assets under Hendon’s or Alex’s management. Ultimately, Quek admitted that as of 19 October 2023, the VEF did not have any assets/moneys invested or under management and that his statement about the assets/moneys managed by the VEF was inaccurate. Indeed, the JVA between Vivva and Hendon in January 2024 further showed that only US$1,550,000 from the VEF was transferred to Hendon (although Quek attested that it was US$1,560,000, but the difference is immaterial). From this sum, US$1m was from Lu’s Investment Sum.
Whether the CMM Reps were made by the defendants
65 I find the CMM Reps were made when Lau sent the CM Materials to Lu. The CMM Reps were reinforced by Quek and Lau at the 26/12/23 Meeting when Lu asked them if the 26 Dec Documents were consistent with the CMM Reps they had made earlier, whereupon they replied in the affirmative (“Affirmation”). The defendants do not dispute that Lau sent to Lu the CM Materials containing the 3rd Chinese Chart, and which were prepared by Lau. Quek accepts that he had authorised Lau to make the representations therein. It is clear also that the representations are attributable to Vivva.
66 In court, Lau agreed that the CM Materials (which he sent on Quek’s instructions) reflected the CMM Reps as set out at [9(c)]–[9(g)] above. Quek also agreed that the CM Materials: (a) similarly represented that the VEF had a “Capital Protection Mechanism” with the 20% stop-loss mechanism, that was the same as what was conveyed in the Vivva Slides as “80% capital protection” (see [47] above); and (b) represented that if the VEF’s value decreased by 10% from its initial amount invested by investors, that Vivva would do an internal review to decide whether the VEF should continue to trade.
67 I accept also, that the CM Materials which contained the 3rd Chinese Chart represented that from January to November 2023: (a) the VEF made monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 4.5%; and (b) the VEF’s total profit was 25.94%, which outperformed investments in Brent and S&P 500 over the same period (collectively, “Jan–Nov 2023 VEF Results”). The figures in 1st Chart Table on the performance of the VEF vis-à-vis Brent and S&P 500 (see [52] above) were replicated in the 2nd Chinese Chart. The 3rd Chinese Chart contained the figures as the 1st Chart Table, save that it was arranged in a different format, and (as Quek admitted in court) the figures were updated to November 2023.
68 Having found the 14 Oct Reps and 19 Oct Reps were made, ie, that the 1st Chinese and English Charts and the 2nd Chinese Chart conveyed the VEF’s actual returns from January to September 2023, it is clear also that the CM Materials containing the 3rd Chinese Chart was likewise meant to convey to Lu the VEF’s actual performance as well and updated to November 2023 (as the CM Materials were sent to Lu in December 2023). I reiterate again my findings at [43]–[46] above.
69 Next, it is undisputed that the 26/12/23 Meeting took place, that Lu informed Quek and Lau that he would invest US$1m in the VEF, that they then provided Lu with the 26 Dec Documents which Lu signed, and that Lu then asked them why there was only one copy of the documents whereupon Lau replied that scanned copies of signed documents were legal and valid in Singapore and he would email a copy of the documents to Lu thereafter.
70 I further accept Lu’s testimony that Quek and Lau had given the Affirmation. Lu had pleaded the above matters that transpired at the 26/12/23 Meeting (see [12] above) and attested to them in his AEIC. This is in contrast to Quek’s and Lau’s AEICs where, despite having known Lu’s version of events of the 26/12/23 Meeting, they merely attested that Lu had signed the 26 Dec Documents. Quek and Lau’s Affirmation is further supported by the fact that the very next day, Lau email Lu (copied to Quek) a copy of the 26 Dec Documents that he had signed together with a copy of the CM Materials (see [13] above). In court, Quek testified that: (a) Lau had sent the documents attached to his email, on Vivva’s behalf; and (b) in attaching the CM Materials to the email, Lu was given the impression that he was investing in the VEF based on what had been represented in the CM Materials and that the CM Materials formed part of the Contract.
Whether the CMM Reps were false and whether the defendants made them knowing they were false
71 Lu claims the CMM Reps were false for the following reasons:
(a) The VEF had no monthly profits ranging from 1.14% to 4.5%, nor a total profit of 25.94%, from January to November 2023, as it had not even been active until March 2024.
(b) The VEF’s returns were not independent of market direction because Hendon’s failed investment on 23 October 2024 purportedly resulted in the entire loss of the VEF and its returns.
(c) As of 27 December 2023, the VEF had no intention to allocate roughly 65%, 20% and 15% of its moneys to oil market arbitrage trading, directional trading and scalping trading respectively. Instead, it remitted close to 100% of its moneys in a lump sum to Hendon through the JVA.
(d) As of 27 December 2023, the VEF had no intention or means to conduct portfolio reviews even if its initial value decreased by 10% (“10% Value Decrease”), since its moneys had been transferred to Hendon. Moreover, cl 5.3 of the JVA only required Hendon to immediately close all trading positions upon the VEF incurring an intra-day loss of 25% or an overnight loss of 10%.
(e) As of 27 December 2023, the VEF had no intention or means to stop trading to protect its capital from further erosion when its initial value decreased by 20% since its moneys had been transferred to Hendon. Moreover, cl 5.3 of the JVA only required Hendon to immediately close all trading positions upon the VEF incurring an intra-day loss of 25% or an overnight loss of 10%.
72 In so far as the CMM Reps relate to the performance of the VEF from January to November 2023, it is clear that the representations at [71(a)] above were false, and that the defendants knew as such as they knew at the material time that the VEF had yet to trade. The defendants also do not dispute that the “chief trader” described in Vivva’s CM Materials (see [9(d)] above), and which turned out to be Alex, was not a trader of or from Vivva, but was from a third party (Hendon), and that both Alex and Hendon were never mentioned in the CM Materials or any previous materials sent to Lu. As for the representation pertaining to the 80% capital protection or 20% stop-loss mechanism, I reiterate [55]–[58] above.
73 Turning to the representations relating to the VEF’s trading strategy and conduct of portfolio review, being statements of intent, I similarly find that at the time of making the representations, the defendants did not honestly hold the intention they expressed and did not intend to follow through with the representations.
(a) There is nothing to show that the defendants had intended or honestly believed that the VEF would allocate its funds roughly at 65%, 20% and 15% to oil market arbitrate trading, directional trading and scalping trading respectively, or that the VEF’s returns would be independent of market direction. There is also no evidence that Lu’s Investment Sum (or the VEF’s funds) had been allocated for trading in the manner the defendants had represented. Pertinently, Vivva had handed all the VEF funds to Hendon to manage and trade, and Vivva has not shown that even Hendon adhered to this allocation for trading. As Quek admitted in court, the JVA was silent as to how the VEF’s funds would be allocated for trading, and Vivva had no way of ensuring that Hendon would abide by this allocation for trading; yet Quek accepted the JVA as is and signed it.
(b) There is also nothing to show the defendants ever intended to conduct a full portfolio review once the 10% Value Decrease in the VEF occurs. Indeed, by handing over the VEF funds to Hendon for Hendon to manage and trade, it is unclear how Vivva could have been able to conduct an internal portfolio review if the 10% Value Decrease occurred. Whilst cl 5.3 of the JVA obliged Hendon to report to Vivva immediately when the 10% Value Decrease occurs (see [57] above), I find the defendants never intended to hold Hendon to this obligation or to conduct an internal portfolio review. There was no mechanism in the JVA for Vivva to check on Hendon’s performance in trading the VEF funds or on the accuracy of any reporting by Hendon in relation to its trades. The defendants had no control or oversight of the trades done by Hendon (see [36] above). As Quek stated in court, Vivva would only do a portfolio review on receiving an official report from the clearing house on the status of the trades, but he further admitted that only Hendon (and not Vivva) had access to the clearing house. It is also clear that no such review was ever done, whether by Vivva or Hendon.
(c) Importantly, despite Lu having particularise in his pleaded case the misrepresentations relating to the CM Materials and 3rd Chinese Chart, Quek and Lau had merely attested that the materials sent to Lu were not meant to be binding promises, representations or the like.
Whether there was inducement and reliance
74 I find that the Representations were made to induce Lu to invest in the VEF and enter the Contract, and that Lu had invested in the VEF in reliance on the Representations.
75 The defendants agree the Vivva Slides were made to attract investors. In court, Quek agreed he asked Lau to prepare the slides, which were a “marketing deck” for potential investors. He also agreed that the purpose of giving Lu information pertaining to the VEF in the Vivva Slides and the 3rd Chinese Chart, was to enable Lu to assess the VEF’s performance and decide whether to invest in the VEF. As Quek admitted, the comparison to Brent and S&P 500 in the 1st Chart Table and 3rd Chinese Chart was meant to convey to potential investors that the VEF had in the past (ie, January to November 2023) outperformed them, and that the past performance of a fund would be a relevant consideration for any potential investor. Quek also agreed that the Vivva Slides conveyed to a potential investor that if he were to invest in the VEF, that 80% of the capital invested would be protected. Even if Lau claims the Vivva Slides were only an “internal working copy”, he nonetheless knew that it “may be shown to potential investors”, which must have been for the purpose of enticing them to invest. Indeed, Lau conceded that the materials were provided for potential investors to assess whether to invest in the VEF and that such materials may affect their decision as to whether to so invest.
76 The defendants admit in their Defence that when Quek sent Lu the Subscription Form, IM and PPM, Lu understood that they pertained to the VEF which would be managed as described in the Vivva Slides. I accept Lu’s claim that as of 26 December 2023, he believed and relied on the Representations to sign the 26 Dec Documents.
77 I pause to deal with Quek’s assertion in court that Lau had “explained every paragraph” of the 26 Dec Documents to Lu before Lu signed them, which I disbelieve. Lu’s testimony in court, that at the 26/12/26 Meeting he saw the Subscription Form for only a few minutes and was not given time to read the form before he signed it, was not challenged by defence counsel.
78 In any event, even if Lu could have read the 26 Dec Documents before signing them (having been given a draft of the Subscription Form on 11 December 2023), or he was a seasoned investor, these did not mean that he was precluded from relying on the Representations. Reliance can be established so long as the representation plays a real and substantial part in inducing a claimant to act; the representation need not be the sole inducing cause (Panatron at [21]–[23]; Alwie Handoyo v Tjong Very Sumito [2013] 4 SLR 308 at [187]–[188]). Additionally, that Lu should have done his own due diligence did not mean that the defendants can escape the consequences of the false representations made unless Lu came to know of the misrepresentations before, or did not rely on them when, entering into the Contract and investing in the VEF (Jurong Town Corp v Wishing Star Ltd [2005] 3 SLR(R) 283 at [113]–[114]). As Lu explained, when deciding whether to invest in a fund, he would consider three material aspects, namely the risk of the investment, the returns on the investment, and how much assets are already under management in the fund, all of which one or more of the defendants made representations to him.
79 I turn to consider the defendants’ defence that Lu was precluded from relying on the Representations because of various clauses in the PPM. This defence is without merit. The PPM does contain any clause to exclude Vivva’s liability for misrepresentation nor expressly contradict the Representations made. Further, exclusion clauses cannot exclude liability for fraud assuming fraud is established (POA Recovery Pte Ltd v Yau Kwok Seng [2022] 1 SLR 1165 at [115]). A principal cannot exclude liability for fraudulent misrepresentation or fraud by it or its employee (Pertamina Energy Trading Limited v Credit Suisse [2006] 4 SLR(R) 273 at [63]). In any event, Quek and Lau are not parties to the Contract and are thus personally liable for any fraudulent misrepresentations they each made. They cannot rely on any of the clauses in the Contract in the absence of privity of contract (H8 Holdings Pte Ltd v RIC Dormitory (SG) Pte Ltd [2024] SGHC 177 (“H8 Holdings”) at [107]). In particular, whilst the defendants plead that cl 7 of the PPM stated that “Investors … are deemed to acknowledge that no representation, warranty or assurance is made except as set out in this [PPM]”, Quek admitted in court that such phrase/wording was not found in the PPM.
80 The defendants further rely on the IM which states that “No person has been authorised to give any information or to make any representations other than as contained in the [IM] and any representation or information not contained herein must not be relied upon as having been authorised by the Fund Manager or the Fund” (“Clause”). This Clause does not assist the defendants. If the defendants were intending to raise an evidential estoppel, they cannot succeed. The “no-reliance” or “no-representation” Clause is not clear and unequivocal and there was no intention that Vivva intended the Clause to be acted on to the exclusion of the CM Materials that were provided to Lu (see Orient Centre Investments Ltd v Société Générale [2007] 3 SLR(R) 566 at [44]). As Quek agreed in court, Vivva regarded the CM Materials as forming part of the Contract with Lu. As I have found, Quek and Lau made the Affirmation to Lu. Lau then emailed a copy of the signed 26 Dec Documents with a copy of the CM Materials to Lu, giving Lu the impression that he was investing in the VEF based on the representations in the CM Materials (see [65] and [70] above). As such, any reliance by the defendants on a contractual estoppel would not succeed. I reiterate also that such clauses cannot exclude liability for fraud (see [79] above).
81 My findings above applies equally to the defendants’ reliance on cl 5(iii) of the Subscription Form, which states that Lu made the subscription application solely on the terms and provisions contained in the “Documents” (defined as including the Subscription Form and IM) and not in reliance on any representations not set out in the Documents.
Conclusion
82 In summary, I find Lu has made out his claim for fraudulent misrepresentation against: (a) Vivva and Quek pertaining to the Representations; and (b) Lau in respect of the CMM Reps. It is clear that but for the Representations, Lu would not have parted with the Investment Sum and which, according to the defendants, were completely wiped out when the VEF’s capital suffered a total loss.
83 It is thus unnecessary for me to deal with Lu’s claim under s 2 of the MA, which his counsel confirms is pursued only against Vivva. That said, I would have found Vivva liable thereunder. For a claim under s 2(1) of the MA, the representee must have been induced to, and did, enter into a contract after an actionable misrepresentation was made to him. The burden then lies on the representor to show that he had reasonable grounds to believe and did believe up to the time the contract was made that the fact represented was true (Lim Koon Park v Yap Jin Meng Bryan [2013] 4 SLR 150 at [38]–[39]; RBC Properties Pte Ltd v Defu Furniture Pte Ltd [2015] 1 SLR 997 (“RBC Properties”) at [79]; Fujifilm Business Innovation Singapore Pte Ltd v Federal Marketing & Printing Pte Ltd [2026] SGHC 225 at [33]). The evidence and my findings above support also that Lu was induced into investing in the VEF and executing the Contract after the Representations were made to him, and that Vivva did not have reasonable grounds to believe nor did it believe, up to the time the Contract was executed, that what it had represented was true. For completeness, Vivva cannot rely on the exception of “reasonableness” under s 3 of the MA. It did not plead nor show how this exception applies to it. I have also found the Representations were made fraudulently, and it would not have been in the parties’ contemplation for a contractual clause to have excluded liability for fraud (H8 Holdings at [105]). I reiterate [79]–[80] above.
84 As a final point, Lu claims in the alternative against the defendants for negligent misrepresentation. I note that in his pleaded case, Lu does not rely on negligent misrepresentation under common law but merely relies on the negligence of the defendants in making the representations for the purposes of his claim under s 2(1) of the MA. Be it as it may, there is no need for me to consider this alternative claim given my findings above.
Breach of contract
85 Having found the defendants liable for fraudulent misrepresentation, it is unnecessary to consider Lu’s claim for breach of contract and for procuring or inducing Vivva’s breach of contract. Nevertheless, I deal with them for completeness.
86 Lu claims that Vivva breached the following terms of the Contract:
(a) The VEF would allocate roughly 65%, 20% and 15% of its moneys to oil market arbitrage trading, directional trading and scalping trading respectively (“1st Term”).
(b) The VEF would conduct a full portfolio review if the VEF’s value decreased by 10% from its initial value (“2nd Term”).
(c) If the VEF’s value decreased by 20% from its initial value, the VEF would stop all trading to protect its capital from further erosion, such that investors would not lose more than 20% of capital invested (“3rd Term”).
(d) Pursuant to cl 5.2 of the PPM, the VEF’s investments would be “wholly … in the energy sector and in cash or cash equivalent while not invested” and that “each position shall not exceed 10% of the Net Asset Value” (“4th Term”).
(e) Pursuant to cl 9.1 of the PPM, any requests for redemption of participating shares in the VEF were to be effected by Vivva within the first five business days of every calendar month (“5th Term”).
87 The defendants deny the above five terms are incorporated into the Contract. They claim that the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Terms are drawn from the CM Materials, but the CM Materials do not form part of the Contract. They plead that the Contract comprised the Subscription Form, PPM and “other incorporated documents”. As for the 4th and 5th Terms, the defendants assert that cll 5.2 and 9.1 of the PPM do not have the effect that Lu claims. Therefore, they deny that Vivva breached the Contract.
88 Lu claims the CM Materials form part of the Contract. This is on the basis that Quek and Lau had made the CMM Reps, referred to the CM Materials when answering Lu’s questions on 26 December 2023 (see [10] above) and gave Lu the Affirmation before he signed the 26 Dec Documents; and by Lau’s 27/12/23 Email where Lau re-sent to Lu a copy of the CM Materials together with the signed 26 Dec Documents.
89 I accept the CM Materials were incorporated into the Contract. In court, Quek conceded that by attaching a copy of the CM Materials to the signed 26 Dec Documents in Lau’s 27/12/23 Email, Vivva had regarded the CM Materials as forming part of the Contract (see [70] above). There would have been no reason to re-send to Lu the CM Materials together with the signed 26 Dec Documents, in Lau’s 27/12/23 Email, if the CM Materials were merely “explanatory and marketing materials” (as Quek alleged) and when they were already sent to Lu before he signed the 26 Dec Documents. Tellingly, when queried in re-examination why Lau had sent the CM Materials together with the signed 26 Dec Documents to Lu, Quek stated that it was “mandatory to…send the contract over once it’s signed by the client”.
90 As I find the CM Materials formed part of the Contract documents, the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Terms were thus part of the Contract terms. I find that Vivva had breached these terms. First, the VEF did not allocate its funds in oil market arbitrage trading, directional trading and scalping trading with a rough allocation of 65%, 20% and 15% respectively. On the contrary, it is undisputed that all the moneys in the VEF were handed to Hendon for Hendon to trade. I reiterate my findings at [73(a)] above. Second, the VEF or Vivva also never conducted any portfolio review when the VEF’s value decreased by 10% from its initial value. Quek admitted that despite discovering from Hendon, on around 5 August 2024, that the VEF had suffered a 12.3% loss, Vivva did not conduct any portfolio review. I reiterate my findings at [73(b)] above. Third, Vivva and the VEF Fund did not halt trading when it began to suffer a loss of 20% from its initial value and Lu was not informed nor was his approval obtained (in order to continue trading) at that point. This is although Vivva had to ensure that, once the VEF suffered a 20% loss, 80% of the investor’s capital remain protected – as Quek agreed. I reiterate my findings at [57]–[58] above. It is undisputed that the VEF suffered a total loss eventually.
91 As for the 4th and 5th Terms which pertain to cll 5.2 and 9.1 of the PPM, it is undisputed that the PPM formed part of the Contract. Lu claims that cl 5.2 of the PPM was breached as Vivva had placed all the VEF funds with Hendon, resulting in the purported eventual entire loss of Lu’s investment. However, it is unclear how cl 5.2 was breached merely by the VEF being managed by Hendon (rather than Vivva) or because it turned out that all the investments in the VEF were eventually (purportedly) wiped out. However, I agree that the 5th Term was breached. The defendants accept that Lu had informed Quek on 27 and 28 July 2024 of his desire to redeem his Investment Sum, whereupon Quek gave Lu holding replies to indicate that he had communicated Lu’s requests to Vivva. It is undisputed that Vivva never took any steps to process Lu’s request. Quek explained that the VEF moneys had been committed to Hendon, thus they were not in Vivva’s control and the VEF could not direct a unilateral redemption without Hendon’s cooperation. But this is not a defence to a breach of the 5th Term. Quek’s explanation merely reinforces that Vivva could not have complied with the 5th Term once the VEF funds were handed over to Hendon.
92 In the round, I find that Vivva had breached the Contract. Even if I am wrong on this, I have found nevertheless that Vivva was liable for fraudulent misrepresentation pertaining to the Representations.
Procuring the breach of Contract
93 I turn to Lu’s claim that Quek procured or induced the breach of Contract. To establish the tort of inducement of breach of contract, Lu must show the following: (a) Quek knew of the existence of the Contract; (b) Quek intended to interfere with Lu’s contractual rights; (c) Quek directly procured or induced Vivva to breach the Contract; (d) the Contract was in fact breached; and (e) Lu suffered injury as a result of the breach of contract (Turf Club Auto Emporium Pte Ltd v Yeo Boong Hua [2018] 2 SLR 655 at [311]).
94 It is clear the requirements of (a), (d) and (e) at [93] above are met. Particularly, although Quek was only formally appointed a director of Vivva on 15 February 2024, he was the de facto director and in charge of running Vivva at all material times. He participated in making the Representations to Lu, was present when Lu signed the 26 Dec Documents, was copied on Lau’s 27/12/23 Email, and conceded in court that the CM Materials formed part of the Contract (see [89] above).
95  The evidence also supports that Quek intended to interfere with Lu’s contractual rights and directly induced Vivva’s breach of the Contract. He caused the VEF’s moneys to be handed to Hendon to trade. The JVA that Quek caused Vivva to enter with Hendon did not require Hendon to allocate the VEF funds as per the 1st Term. Quek knew this at the time he executed the JVA (see [73(a)] above). As for the 2nd Term, Quek admitted that despite knowing, on around 5 August 2024, that the VEF had suffered a 12.3% loss, he did not cause Vivva to conduct a portfolio review (see [90] above). As for the 3rd Term, it is also clear that Quek knew and acquiesced to the JVA terms which provided for a stop-loss of 25% that was more disadvantageous than the stop-loss of 20% represented in the Vivva Slides and CM Materials (see [57]–[58] above). Moreover, when VEF began to suffer a loss of 20% of its initial value, there is no evidence that Quek did anything to prevent further trading on the VEF. Quek did not even inform Lu at the material time let alone obtain his approval on whether trading should continue in relation to his invested moneys. Pertaining to the 5th Term, Quek did not take any steps to cause Vivva to process Lu’s request (see [91] above).
96 Finally, Quek cannot avail himself of the immunity under the principle in Said v Butt [1920] 3 KB 497. By directly procuring Vivva’s breach of the terms of the Contract, which he knew would cause Vivva to incur liability to its investors (such as Lu), Quek has not acted in Vivva’s best interests but had breached his personal legal duties to it.
97 I thus find Quek liable for the tort of inducement of breach of contract.
Miscellaneous
98 I deal briefly with the defendants’ assertion that, prior to signing the Contract, Lu knew the trading activities on the VEF would be carried out by Hendon or Alex and not by Vivva (see [32] above). This does not assist the defendants. Even if Lu knew that Hendon or Alex was performing the trades for the VEF, this is irrelevant to Lu’s claims for misrepresentation (being based on representations made by the defendants), breach of the Contract (which was executed between Vivva and Lu) or the tort of inducing or procuring the breach of Contract (which was committed by Quek).
99 In any event, I disbelieve the defendants’ assertion that Lu had been aware at the material times that Hendon and Alex were involved in trading for the VEF and particularly before Lu signed the 26 Dec Documents. I accept Lu’s testimony that he only discovered Hendon’s involvement in the VEF in October 2024 and discovered thereafter that Alex was from Hendon and not Vivva (see [21] above). First, the defendants do not dispute that none of the documents (up until the execution of the Contract and the Contract) that Lu received, expressly mentioned Hendon or Alex. In fact, they consistently mentioned Carrington Investments as the fund manager. Indeed, Vivva and Hendon only executed the JVA in January 2024, after Lu had executed the Contract with Vivva and (as Quek claims) Hendon did not even start trading in the VEF until March 2024. In court, Quek admitted that Lu was unaware, and Quek did not inform Lu, that the VEF moneys would be handed to Hendon for Hendon to manage.
Remedy
100 As a general rule, a representee who can establish misrepresentation is entitled to rescind the contract such that the parties are restored to their pre-contractual positions (Strait Colonies Pte Ltd v SMRT Alpha Pte Ltd [2018] 2 SLR 441 at [33], citing RBC Properties at [56]).
101 Lu seeks a declaration that the Contract was validly rescinded as of 11 April 2025, ie, when Cairnhill Law LLC sent the 11/4/25 Demand Letter to Vivva (see [25] above). The letter stated that Vivva had through Quek and Lau sent various materials to Lu (eg, the 2nd Chinese Chart and CM Materials) which contained various representations, such as the representations at [5(a)], [9(e)], [9(f)] and [9(g)] above. The letter further stated that Lu had relied on the various representations in deciding to invest in the VEF. In particular, Lu claimed that the representation regarding the 80% capital protection mechanism, among other representations, was false and thus he was rescinding the Contract and demanding repayment of the Investment Sum with interest from 2 January 2024. I find that Lu was entitled to and did validly rescind the Contract by the 11/4/25 Demand Letter.
102 As such, I allow Lu’s claim for the sum of US$983,230.67 (being US$1m less US$16,769.33 that Lu received on 30 April 2024 (see [17] above)). The defendants are jointly and severally liable for this sum.
103 I further allow Lu’s claim for pre-judgment interest under s 12(1) of the Civil Law Act 1909 (2020 Rev Ed) at the default rate of 5.33% per annum: (a) on the sum of US$1m from 2 January to 29 April 2024; and (b) on the sum of US$983,230.67 from 30 April 2024 to the date of judgment. Pre-judgment interest serves to compensate a successful claimant for the time value of money the use of which was lost between the date his cause of action arose and the date of judgment. As a matter of principle, a claimant who has been kept out of pocket without basis should be able to recover interest on money that is found to have been owed to him from the date of his entitlement until the date it is paid (Grains and Industrial Products Trading Pte Ltd v Bank of India [2016] 3 SLR 1308 at [137]–[138]). Lu had in the 11/4/25 Demand Letter stated that he was claiming interest at 5.33% per annum from 2 January 2024 (when he transferred the Investment Sum to the VEF’s account). There is no reason why the present case would justify a departure from the default interest rate of 5.33% per annum, and the defendants have also not submitted otherwise. The defendants are thus also jointly and severally liable for the pre-judgment interest.
104 I will hear the parties on costs.
Audrey Lim
Judge of the High Court
Derek Kang Yu Hsien and Nicholas Phung-Zhang (Cairnhill Law LLC) for the claimant;
Han Wah Teng, Koh Kok Kwang and Kenii Takashima (CTLC Law Corporation) for the defendants.
Back to Top

This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

Version No 1: 16 Nov 2026 (17:39 hrs)