This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

IN THE STATE COURTS OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2026] SGMC 27
Magistrate Arrest Case No. 909503 of 2024 and Others
Public Prosecutor
Against
Josephine Santos Ho
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT
Criminal Law — Offences — Employment of Foreign Manpower Act (Cap 91A, 2009 Rev Ed)
Criminal Procedure and Sentencing — Sentencing — Employment of Foreign Manpower Act (Cap 91A, 2009 Rev Ed)

TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION 1
BACKGROUND FACTS 3
THE PARTIES’ SUBMISSIONS 11
MY DECISION 11
SECTION 22(1)(D) OFFENCES 11
SECTION 22A OFFENCES 16
SECTION 10 OFFENCES 19
AGGREGATE SENTENCE 21
CONCLUSION 27
ANNEX A – SUMMARY OF THE INDIVIDUAL AND
COLLECTIVE SENTENCES 28

i

This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Public Prosecutor
v
Josephine Santos Ho
[2026] SGMC 27
Magistrate Arrest Case No. 909503 of 2024 and Others
District Judge Samuel Wee
23 February 2026
23 February 2026
District Judge Samuel Wee:
Introduction
1 Ms Josephine Santos Ho (“Ms Santos”) committed numerous offences under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act (Cap 91A, 2009 Rev Ed) (“EFMA 2009 Ed”) and the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act 1990 (2020 Rev Ed) (“EFMA 2020 Ed”). There is a difference in the version of the statute as the EFMA 2009 Ed applied to offences committed by Ms Santos prior to 31 December 2021, whereas the EFMA 2020 Ed applied to offences committed on or after 31 December 2021.
2 She has pleaded guilty to eight charges (“PG Charges”) and has admitted and consented to another eight charges being taken into consideration for the purposes of sentencing (“TIC Charges”).

1

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
(a) The PG Charges relate to:
(i) Three offences under s 22(1)(d) read with s 23(1), and punishable under s 22(1)(ii) of the EFMA 2009 Ed (“Section 22(1)(d) Offence”) for abetting the making of a statement to the Controller of Work Passes (“Controller”) which she knew was false in connection with an application for a work pass.1
(ii) Three offences under s 22A(1)(a) read with s 23(1), and punishable under s 22A(2) of the EFMA 2009 Ed (“Section 22A Offence”) for abetting the receipt of a sum from a foreign employee as a condition for employment.2
(iii) Two offences under s 10(1) read with s 23(1), and punishable under s 10(2)(a) of the EFMA 2009 Ed (“Section 10 Offence”) for abetting the self-employment of a foreigner without a valid work pass.3
(b) The TIC Charges relate to:
(i) Two offences under s 22(1)(a), punishable under s 22(1)(h) of the EFMA 2020 Ed (“Section 22(1)(a) Offence”) for contravening condition 5(a) of Part I of the Fourth Schedule of the Employment of Foreign Manpower (Work Passes) Regulations 2012 (“Regulations”) by allowing a foreign employee to reside at a residential address that was not stated in the work permit.4
1 C1-C3.
2 C4-C6.
3 C7-C8.
4 C9 and C11.
2

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
(ii) One Section 22(1)(d) Offence.5
(iii) Two Section 22A Offences.6
(iv) Three Section 10 Offences.7
3 For the reasons set out below, I sentence Ms Santos to an aggregate of 23 weeks’ imprisonment and a fine of $3,000 (in default 9 days’ imprisonment). A tabular summary of the individual and collective sentences (including the Prosecution’s and Ms Santos’s positions on sentence) is set out in Annex A.
Background Facts
4 There are several persons referred to in the PG Charges and TIC Charges.
(a) The first category relates to Ms Santos’s three conspirators, who are also facing criminal charges: (i) Ms Jennifer Choo Joo Kheng (“Ms Choo”); (ii) Mr Ng Boon Cheong (“Mr Ng”); and (iii) Mr Kang Guan Soon (“Mr Kang”).
(b) The second category relates to five foreigners who were involved: (i) Ms Josill Maratas David (“Ms Josill”);8 (ii) Ms Divina Xeres Cabuay Onzana (“Ms Divina”);9 (iii) Ms Perez Lovella
5 C10.
6 C12 and C13.
7 C14-C16.
8 C1, C4, C7.
9 C2, C5, C8 and C10.
3

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
Reybuenan (“Ms Perez”);10 (iv) Ms Tanodra Geralyn Alicaway (“Ms
Tanodra”);11 and (v) Ms Loida Tapanan Rellanos (“Ms Loida”).12
5 Ms Santos was an employment agent at Expert Business Management
& Consultancy LLP. She and Ms Choo devised a scheme (“Fictitious Employment Scheme”) whereby:13
(a) They would assist foreigners to obtain domestic worker work permits in Singapore, even though the foreigners would not actually work for the declared employers.
(b) The foreigners would find their own employment elsewhere, and would not live at their declared employer’s residence.
(c) The foreigners would pay Ms Santos a sum of money that would be used to cover their monthly foreign worker levy and also be distributed to Ms Santos, Ms Choo and the declared employer who assisted in the Fictitious Employment Scheme.
(d) Ms Santos would source the foreigners, while Ms Choo would source locals (such as Mr Ng and Mr Kang) who were willing to let their names be used as the declared employer.
6 I will classify the material events relating to the Fictitious Employment
Scheme based on each of the five foreigners.
10 C3, C6 and C15.
11 C9, C12 and C14.
12 C11, C13, C16.
13 SOF_[5]-[7].
4

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
7 In respect of Ms Josill:
(a) Sometime between January 2021 and February 2021, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo concerning the receipt of $7,500 from Ms Josill as a condition for her employment (ie. by applying for a work pass). Ms Josill paid $7,500 to Ms Santos, who retained $1,000.14 This is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909509-2024 for a Section 22A Offence.15
(b) On or about 27 February 2021, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo and Mr Ng in respect of the following:
(i) For a statement to be made to the Controller in an “Application for a Work Permit for a Domestic Worker” that Ms Josill would be employed as Mr Ng’s domestic worker even though they knew that Mr Ng had no intention to employ her.16 In this regard, the Ministry of Manpower would not have issued the work permit if they had been aware that Mr Ng had no intention to employ Ms Josill.17 This is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909503-2024 for a Section 22(1)(d) Offence.18
(ii) To allow Ms Josill to work as a self-employed part-time waitress or cleaner rather than as Mr Ng’s domestic worker. This
14 SOF_[9], [13].
15 C4.
16 SOF_[10]-[14].
17 SOF_[15].
18 C1.
5

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909513-2024 for a Section 10 Offence.19
(c) The Fictitious Employment Scheme for Ms Josill lasted around
11 months from 27 February 2021 to 30 January 2022 (when Ms Josill’s work pass was cancelled).20 During this time, Ms Josill worked as a part-time waitress or cleaner. She did not stay at Mr Ng’s residence and did not work as Mr Ng’s domestic worker.21
8 With regard to Ms Divina:
(a) In early April 2019, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with
Ms Choo concerning the receipt of $5,000 from Ms Divina as a condition for her employment (ie. by applying for a work pass). Ms Divina paid $5,000 to Ms Santos, who retained $1,000.22 This is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909510-2024 for a Section 22A Offence.23
(b) On or about 23 April 2019:
(i) Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo and Mr Kang for a statement to be made to the Controller in an “Application for a Work Permit for a Domestic Worker” that Ms Divina would be employed as Mr Kang’s domestic worker even
19 C7.
20 SOF_[16].
21 SOF_[17].
22 SOF_[22], [27].
23 C5.
6

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
though they knew that Mr Kang had no intention to employ her.24 In this regard, the Ministry of Manpower would not have issued the work permit if they had been aware that Mr Kang had no intention to employ Ms Divina.25 This is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909504-2024 for a Section 22(1)(d) Offence.26
(ii) Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo
to allow Ms Divina to work as a self-employed part-time cleaner or waitress rather than as Mr Kang’s domestic worker. This is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909515-2024 for a Section 10 Offence.27
(c) The Fictitious Employment Scheme for Ms Divina lasted around 1 year and 5 months from 23 April 2019 to 18 September 2020 (when Ms Divina’s work pass was cancelled).28 During this time, Ms Divina worked as a part-time cleaner or waitress. She did not stay at Mr Kang’s residence and did not work as Mr Kang’s domestic worker.29
(d) On or about 19 October 2020, Ms Santos was then involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo and Mr Ng for a statement to be made to the Controller in an “Application for a Work Permit for a Domestic Worker” that Ms Divina would now be employed as Mr Ng’s domestic worker
24 SOF_[24]-[28].
25 SOF_[29].
26 C2.
27 C8.
28 SOF_[16].
29 SOF_[31].
7

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
even though she knew that Mr Ng had no intention to employ her.30 This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909505-2024 for a Section 22(1)(d) Offence.31
9 As to Ms Perez:
(a) Sometime around 22 April 2021, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo concerning the receipt of $11,600 from Ms Perez as a condition for her employment (ie. by applying for a work pass). Ms Perez paid $11,600 to Ms Santos, who retained $1,000.32 This is the subject of a PG Charge under MAC-909511-2024 for a Section 22A Offence.33
(b) On or about 15 December 2021, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo in respect of the following:
(i) For a statement to be made to the Controller in an “Application for a Work Permit for a Domestic Worker” that Ms Perez would be employed as Ms Choo’s domestic worker even though she knew that Ms Choo had no intention to employ her.34 In this regard, the Ministry of Manpower would not have issued the work permit if they had been aware that Ms Choo had no intention to employ Ms Perez.35 This is the subject of a PG
30 SOF_[30].
31 C10.
32 SOF_[36], [39].
33 C6.
34 SOF_[37]-[39].
35 SOF_[41].
8

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
Charge under MAC-909506-2024 for a Section 22(1)(d) Offence.36
(ii) To allow Ms Perez to work as a self-employed part-time
cleaner rather than as Ms Choo’s domestic worker. This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909516-2024 for a Section 10 Offence.37
(c) The Fictitious Employment Scheme for Ms Perez lasted around
4 months from 15 December 2021 to 19 April 2022 (when Ms Perez’s work pass was cancelled).38 During this time, Ms Perez worked as a part-time cleaner. She did not stay at Ms Choo’s residence and did not work as Ms Choo’s domestic worker.39
10 In relation to Ms Tanodra:
(a) On 19 December 2021, Ms Santos received $2,000 from Ms
Tanodra as a condition for her employment (ie. by applying for a work pass). This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909508-2024 for a Section 22A Offence.40
(b) From late December 2021 to 13 April 2022:
(i) Ms Santos allowed Ms Tanodra to work as a self-employed part-time cleaner rather than as her domestic worker.
36 C3.
37 C15.
38 SOF_[42].
39 SOF_[40].
40 C12.
9

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909514-2024 for a Section 10 Offence.41
(ii) Ms Santos allowed Ms Tanodra to reside at a residential
address that was not stated in her work permit. This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909502-2024 for a Section 22(1)(a) Offence.42
11 Concerning Ms Loida:
(a) Sometime between August 2020 and September 2020, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo concerning the receipt of $7,500 from Ms Loida as a condition for her employment (ie. by applying for a work pass). This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909512-2024 for a Section 22A Offence.43
(b) From late September 2020 to mid April 2022, Ms Santos was involved in a conspiracy with Ms Choo and Mr Kang in respect of the following:
(i) To allow Ms Loida to work as a self-employed part-time cleaner. This is the subject of a TIC Charge under MAC-909517-2024 for a Section 10 Offence.44
(ii) To allow Ms Loida to reside at a residential address that was not stated in her work permit. This is the subject of a TIC
41 C14.
42 C9.
43 C13.
44 C16.
10

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
Charge under MAC-909507-2024 for a Section 22(1)(a) Offence.45
12 The Fictitious Employment Scheme was discovered by the Ministry of Manpower, and Ms Santos was arrested on 11 December 2024 and released on bail.46
The parties’ submissions
13 The Prosecution seeks an aggregate sentence of 28-32 weeks’ imprisonment and a fine of $3,000.47
14 Ms Santos has pleaded for an aggregate sentence of 15-18 weeks’ imprisonment.48
15 As mentioned at [3] above, a tabular summary of the Prosecution’s and Ms Santos’s positions on the individual and collective sentences is set out in Annex A.
My decision
Section 22(1)(d) Offences
16 The Section 22(1)(d) Offence carries a maximum fine of $20,000, maximum imprisonment of 2 years, or both.
45 C11.
46 SOF_[3].
47 AOS_[53].
48 MP_[7].
11

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
17 In Chiew Kok Chai v Public Prosecutor [2019] 5 SLR 713 (“Chiew Kok
Chai”), the High Court found that deterrence is the predominant sentencing consideration for Section 22(1)(d) Offences,49 a custodial sentence should be the norm,50 and that fines should be imposed to disgorge at least some of the profits made.51 The High Court also set out a two-stage sentencing framework:
(a) At the first stage, various factors are considered to ascertain the gravity of the offence and place it within one of the following bands:52
(b) Some relevant offence-specific factors to consider at the first stage are:53
(i) the materiality of the false representation;
(ii) the nature, sophistication and extent of the deception;
(iii) the consequences of the deception;
49 [49] of Chiew Kok Chai.
50 [62] of Chiew Kok Chai.
51 [69] of Chiew Kok Chai.
52 [25] and [63] of Chiew Kok Chai.
53 [67] of Chiew Kok Chai.
12

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
(iv) whether a transnational or syndicate element was present;
(v) the specific role played by the offender and the number of people involved in furnishing false information;
(vi) the gains obtained from the commission of the offence; and
(vii) the offender’s motive in circumventing the work pass framework.
(c) At the second stage, offender-specific factors, such as mitigating
factors, are considered.54
18 I find that Ms Santos’s Section 22(1)(d) Offences in respect of Ms Josill,
Ms Divina and Ms Perez fall around the middle range of Band 1 of the Chiew Kok Chai framework for the following reasons:55
(a) The false statements made were material, as the Ministry of
Manpower would not have issued work permits to Ms Josill, Ms Divina and Ms Perez if they knew that there was no intention for them to be employed as domestic workers by Mr Ng, Mr Kang or Ms Choo respectively (see [7(b)(i)], [8(b)(i)] and [9(b)(i)] above).
(b) The Fictitious Employment Scheme was planned and deliberate
(see [5] above), and was perpetuated over some time – around 11 months for Ms Josill, around 1 year and 5 months for Ms Divina, and around 4 months for Ms Perez (see [7(c)], [8(c)] and [9(c)] above).
54 [68] of Chiew Kok Chai.
55 AOS_[10].
13

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
(c) Ms Santos played an instrumental role in the Fictitious Employment Scheme – she sourced foreigners (see [5(d)] above); and she had three other conspirators – Ms Choo, Mr Ng and Mr Kang.
(d) The Fictitious Employment Scheme was created with the motive of financial gain (see [5(c)] above).
19 To this end, the indicative starting sentence at the first stage is as
follows:
S/N
Charge
No.
Offence
Foreigner
Involved
Indicative Starting
Sentence
(a)
MAC-
Section
Ms Josill
10 weeks’ imprisonment
909503-
22(1)(d)
2024
Offence
(b)
MAC-
Ms Divina
14 weeks’ imprisonment
909504-
2024
(c)
MAC-
Ms Perez
5 weeks’ imprisonment
909506-
2024
20 The indicative starting sentence should then be adjusted to account for the following:
(a) An uplift in sentence in light of the TIC Charge for a Section 22(1)(d) Offence relating to Ms Divina (see [8(d)] above), which I apply to the sentence for MAC-909504-2024 (which also relates to Ms Divina).

14

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
(b) A reduction of up to 30% under the Sentencing Advisory Panel’s Guidelines on Reduction in Sentences for Guilty Pleas (“PG Guidelines”).56
(c) Moreover, I am mindful that Ms Santos is untraced and is a first-time offender, and also cooperated with the authorities throughout the investigations.57
(d) For completeness, the personal and family circumstances raised by Ms Santos and the motivations behind her offending (ie. to help foreigners obtain better-paying opportunities in Singapore so they could provide for their families)58 are not mitigating factors. As established in Lai Oei Mui Jenny v PP [1993] 2 SLR(R) 406 at [10]: “The whole purpose of the law is to maintain order and discipline, and that is most necessary precisely when the citizen might be inclined to act to the prejudice of good order”.
21 All things considered, I find the appropriate sentence for the three PG
Charges for Section 22(1)(d) Offences is as follows:
S/N
Charge
No.
Offence
Foreigner
Involved
Sentence
(a)
MAC-
909503-
2024
Section
22(1)(d)
Offence
Ms Josill
7 weeks’ imprisonment
(b)
MAC-
909504-
2024
Ms Divina
12 weeks’ imprisonment
56 MP_[5]. While the Prosecution was unclear about whether Ms Santos’s date of indication of her intention to plead guilty was given during Stage 1 of the PG Guidelines, it indicated during the hearing that the reduction it had provided in the AOS was in any event close to 30%.
57 MP_[3]-[4].
58 MP_[8]-[17], [44]-[48].

15

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
S/N
Charge
No.
Offence
Foreigner
Involved
Sentence
(c)
MAC-
909506-
2024
Ms Perez
4 weeks’
imprisonment
22 These sentences are also consistent and proportionate with those given to Ms Josill (6 weeks’ imprisonment), Ms Divina (10 weeks’ imprisonment) and Ms Perez (3 weeks’ imprisonment) who also pleaded guilty to Section 22(1)(d) Offences for their involvement in making the false statements to the Controller that led to the issuance of their work permits,59 save that the sentences imposed on Ms Santos are higher to account for her greater culpability (eg. Ms Santos was the one who devised the Fictitious Employment Scheme).
Section 22A Offences
23 The Section 22A Offence carries a maximum fine of $30,000, maximum imprisonment of 2 years, or both.
24 I agree with the Prosecution that the following sentences are suitable for the three PG Charges for Section 22A Offences:60
S/N
Charge
No.
Offence
Foreigner
Involved
Sentence
(a)
MAC-
Section
Ms Josill
4 weeks’ imprisonment
909509-
22A
2024
Offence
$1,000 penalty
(b)
MAC-
Ms Divina
4 weeks’ imprisonment
909510-
2024
$1,000 penalty
(c)
MAC-
Ms Perez
4 weeks’ imprisonment
909511-
2024
$1,000 penalty
59 AOS_[22]-[25].
60 AOS_[38].
16

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
25 There is case law indicating that a fine would be an appropriate
punishment for Section 22A Offences:
(a) In Public Prosecutor v Islam Mohammad Tariqul [2021] SGMC 27, the Court imposed a $12,000 fine (in default 3 weeks’ imprisonment) and a penalty of $2,000 (in default 4 days’ imprisonment) for a Section 22A Offence where a foreign worker paid $4,000 as a condition for his employment (with the offender receiving $2,000), and a $12,000 fine (in default 3 weeks’ imprisonment) and a penalty of $1,500 (in default 3 days’ imprisonment) for a Section 22A Offence where a foreign worker agreed to pay $4,000 as a condition for his employment (with the offender receiving $1,500).
(b) In Public Prosecutor v Quek Keng Siang Billy [2023] SGMC 91, the Court imposed a $13,000 fine (in default 2 weeks’ imprisonment) and a penalty of $1,200 (in default 3 days’ imprisonment) for ten separate Section 22A Offences where a foreign worker paid $1,200 monthly as a condition for his continued employment over 10 months.
(c) In Public Prosecutor v Jacqueline Tan Poh Suan [2024] SGMC 25, the Court imposed a $10,000 fine (in default 1 month’s imprisonment) and a penalty of $1,300 (in default 1 week’s imprisonment) for three separate Section 22A Offences where the offender received $1,300 as a condition for the employment of three foreign employees.

17

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
26 In line with the precedents, a fine of $10,000 would have been suitable for each of the three PG Charges for Section 22A Offences,61 taking into account that Ms Santos only retained $1,000 from each offence.
27 However, as the Prosecution accepts Ms Santos’s indication that she will be unable to pay a fine and Ms Santos has pleaded for a custodial sentence instead of a fine,62 it is more appropriate to impose a custodial sentence (Yap Ah Lai v Public Prosecutor [2014] 3 SLR 180 at [17]; Tan Yu Qi Chelsea v Public Prosecutor [2022] SGHC 275 at [21]).63
28 In this regard, a sentence of 4 weeks’ imprisonment for each of the three PG Charges for Section 22A Offences is suitable, taking into account the following:
(a) There are offence-specific factors that are relevant:64
(i) Ms Santos collected $7,500 from Ms Josill, $5,000 from Ms Divina and $11,600 from Ms Perez, and retained $1,000 each time (see [7(a)], [8(a)] and [9(a)] above).
(ii) Ms Santos was the one who sourced the foreigners and liaised with them to make the said payments.65
(iii) The Section 22A Offence is difficult to detect due to its discrete nature. To this end, general deterrence is a significant consideration when determining the appropriate sentence
61 AOS_[36].
62 MP_[29].
63 AOS_[37].
64 AOS_[28]-[30].
65 SOF_[10], [13], [22], [27], [36] and [39].
18

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
(Public Prosecutor v Law Aik Meng [2007] 2 SLR(R) 814 at [25(d)]).
(b) There are offender-specific factors to account for:
(i) An uplift in sentence in light of the TIC Charges for Section 22A Offences relating to Ms Tanodra and Ms Loida (see [10(a)] and [11(a)] above), which I apply evenly across the three PG Charges for Section 22A Offences.
(ii) A reduction of up to 30% under the PG Guidelines (see [20(b)] above).
29 Further, Ms Santos is ordered to pay $1,000 (in default 3 days’ imprisonment) under s 23A(1)(a) of the EFMA 2009 Ed as she retained $1,000 from each of the Section 22A Offences. This results in an aggregate penalty of $3,000 (in default 9 days’ imprisonment) for the three PG Charges for Section 22A Offences.
Section 10 Offences
30 The Section 10 Offence carries a maximum fine of $20,000, maximum imprisonment of 2 years, or both.
31 The Prosecution indicated that a fine would be an appropriate punishment for the two PG Charges for Section 10 Offences. It relied on the case of Public Prosecutor v Rahman Mohammed Ataur [2020] SGMC 17, where the Court imposed a fine of $8,000 for a Section 10 Offence in which the offender worked as a self-employed foreigner without a valid work pass for 1 year and 6 months.

19

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
32 However, as Ms Santos will be unable to pay a fine and has pleaded for
a custodial sentence instead,66 I agree with the Prosecution that it is more appropriate to impose a custodial sentence (see [27] above).67
33 That said, the sentence sought by the Prosecution does not appear to be
appropriate.
(a) The Prosecution seeks 3 weeks’ imprisonment for the Section 10 Offence relating to Ms Josill who was able to work for around 11 months (see [7(c)] above), and 4 weeks’ imprisonment for the Section 10 Offence relating to Ms Divina who was able to work for around 1 year and 5 months (see [8(c)] above).
(b) However, this appears excessive when compared with the case of Public Prosecutor v Md Adnan Sheikh [2021] SGDC 224, where the Court sentenced an offender to 3 weeks’ imprisonment for a Section 10 Offence for working as a self-employed foreigner without a valid work pass for around 4 years.
34 Instead, the following sentences are suitable for the two PG Charges for
Section 10 Offences:
S/N
Charge
No.
Offence
Foreigner
Involved
Sentence
(1)
MAC-
Section
Ms Josill
7 days’ imprisonment
909513-
10
2024
Offence
(2)
MAC-
909515-
Ms Divina
10 days’ imprisonment
2024
66 MP_[35].
67 AOS_[49].
20

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
35 In deriving the sentences for the two PG Charges for the Section 10 Offences, I took into account the following:
(a) There are offence-specific factors that are relevant:68
(i) The period that the Fictitious Employment Scheme enabled Ms Josill to work for around 11 months, and Ms Divina to work for around 1 year and 5 months.
(ii) Ms Santos devised the Fictitious Employment Scheme (see [5] above) that allowed Ms Josill and Ms Divina to be self-employed.
(b) There are offender-specific factors to account for:69
(i) An uplift in sentence in light of the TIC Charges for Section 10 Offences and Section 22(1)(a) Offences relating to Ms Tanodra and Ms Loida (see [10] and [11] above), which I apply evenly across the two PG Charges for Section 10 Offences.
(ii) A reduction of up to 30% under the PG Guidelines (see [20(b)] above).
Aggregate sentence
36 The imprisonment terms for the three PG Charges for Section 22(1)(d) Offences should run consecutively, while the three PG Charges for Section 22A Offences and two PG Charges for Section 10 Offences should run concurrently. This satisfies the requirement under s 307(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code
68 AOS_[43]-[45].
69 AOS_[46].
21

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
2010 (2020 Rev Ed), whereby at least two of the terms of imprisonment for the eight PG Charges must run consecutively.
37 The one-transaction rule serves as a filter to sieve out sentences that
ought not, as a general rule, to be ordered to run consecutively. As explained in Mohamed Shouffee bin Adam v Public Prosecutor [2014] 2 SLR 998 (“Shouffee”), the Court may take into account the following when considering whether the one-transaction rule applies: proximity in time, proximity of purpose, proximity of location of the offences, continuity of design,70 unity (or diversity) of the protected interests;71 and the final analysis must be undertaken as a matter of common sense,72 bearing in mind the moral considerations at play.73
38 Based on the facts of the present case, I agree with the Prosecution that
the one-transaction rule applies to the Section 22(1)(d) Offence, the Section 22A Offence and the Section 10 Offence (collectively “Three Offences”) committed in respect of each distinct foreigner (but not to all of them collectively).
(a) The Three Offences in respect of each foreigner have proximity
in time, proximity in purpose, and continuity in design. The Fictitious Employment Scheme necessitated false statements to the Ministry of Manpower (ie. the Section 22(1)(d) Offence), which enabled each foreigner to enter Singapore to be self-employed (ie. the Section 10 Offence), whilst each foreigner effectively paid their own monthly
70 Shoufee_[28], [34], [40].
71 Shoufee_[31], [40].
72 Shoufee_[40].
73 Shoufee_[32].
22

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
foreign worker levy through the money they paid Ms Santos (ie. the Section 22A Offence) to enable them to continue being in Singapore.
(b) The Three Offences also have the same legally protected interest
– the integrity of Singapore’s work pass regime. This is apparent from the Second Reading of the Employment of Foreign Manpower (Amendment) Bill (see Singapore Parl Debates, Vol 89, Sitting No 7, [11 September 2012]), where the then Acting Minister for Manpower Mr Tan Chuan-Jin indicated the following:
Sir, the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act (EFMA) prescribes the responsibilities and obligations pertaining to the employment of foreign workers. We last amended the EFMA in 2007.
In the last few years, my Ministry has taken steps to moderate the inflow and raise the quality of foreign manpower in Singapore. We want to shift from a labour-driven to productivity-driven growth model. Our intent is to ensure that we support decent and sustainable economic growth that will create good jobs and wages for Singaporeans, and to ensure that our Singaporeans remain at the core of our workforce. The adjustments we have made to our employment framework and regulations are aimed at supporting this intent.
Employers in Singapore are, by and large, responsible, but there are some who seek to profit by circumventing our work pass framework. As we further tighten the policies on the hiring and retention of foreign manpower, we can expect errant employers to try harder to get around the rules. This is where we are not lacking in creativity. For example, we have found some declaring higher salaries than they are actually paying their foreign workers, asking foreign workers to foot their own levies and insurance premiums, contributing CPF to locals that do not really exist or, at least, are not actively in their employment, in order to meet the required ratio of local to foreign workers, and submitting forged certificates to qualify for skilled work passes.
Singaporeans ultimately suffer when employers fail to pay the true costs of hiring foreign manpower or hiring foreign manpower that they are not entitled to. Local
23

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
workers will lose out in employment opportunities. Honest employers who play by the rules are also unfairly disadvantaged. Besides errant employers, syndicates also profit from setting up sham operations to illegally import and supply foreign workers who otherwise should not be here. Syndicates have devised increasingly complex schemes to get around our enforcement approaches. Such operations exploit foreign workers and they also cost our local employment opportunities and cost us resources to assist stranded workers.
Sir, the proposed amendments to the EFMA will enhance the Government's ability to ensure the integrity of our work pass framework. Recognising that EFMA contraventions range widely from administrative infringements to criminal offences, these amendments will introduce a calibrated and appropriate response to different types of contraventions. In totality, the changes will allow my Ministry to step up enforcement actions against errant employers, errant foreign workers and syndicates more expeditiously and effectively, thereby enhancing deterrence against EFMA contraventions, which ultimately hurt Singaporeans.
[Emphasis added.]
39 As such, in line with the general rule of consecutive sentences for
unrelated offences (Public Prosecutor v Raveen Balakrishnan [2018] 5 SLR 799 (“Raveen”) at [41]), one of the sentences of imprisonment from each of the following three groups should run consecutively:
S/N
Foreigner Involved
Charge
No.
Offence
Sentence
Group 1
(a)
Ms Josill
MAC-
Section 22(1)(d)
7 weeks’
909503-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
(b)
MAC-
Section 22A
4 weeks’
909509-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
$1,000 penalty
(c)
MAC-
Section 10
7 days’
909513-
Offence
imprisonment
2024

24

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
S/N
Foreigner Involved
Charge
No.
Offence
Sentence
Group 2
(d)
Ms
MAC-
Section 22(1)(d)
12 weeks’
Divina
909504-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
(e)
MAC-
Section 22A
4 weeks’
909510-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
$1,000 penalty
(f)
MAC-
Section 10
10 days’
909515-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
Group 3
(g)
Ms Perez
MAC-
Section 22(1)(d)
4 weeks’
909506-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
(h)
MAC-
Section 22A
4 weeks’
909511-
Offence
imprisonment
2024
$1,000 penalty
40 The sentences of imprisonment set out at [39(a)], [39(d)] and [39(h)] above are to run consecutively, and the remaining sentences are to run concurrently – a tabular summary of the individual and collective sentences is set out in Annex A.
(a) I have taken the two longest sentences of 7 weeks’ and 12 weeks’ imprisonment to run consecutively (see [39(a)] and [39(d)] above, which are for Ms Santos’s Section 22(1)(d) Offences in respect of Ms Josill and Ms Divina). While there is no rule requiring the most severe individual sentences of imprisonment to run consecutively (Shouffee at [25] and [77]) and I am also mindful of the compounding effect of the sentences (Raveen at [77]; Muhammad Sutarno bin Nasir v Public Prosecutor [2018] 2 SLR 647 at [24]), I found this suitable in light of Ms Santos’s overall criminality and in keeping with the importance of

25

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
general deterrence for offences under the EFMA 2009 Ed (see [38(a)] above).74
(b) I have also taken the sentence of 4 weeks’ imprisonment for Ms
Santos’s Section 22A Offence in respect of Ms Perez to run consecutively (see [39(h)] above). While the custodial sentences for both Ms Santos’s Section 22(1)(d) Offence and the Section 22A Offence were identical (ie. 4 weeks), I elected to run the sentence for the Section 22A Offence consecutively instead to make clear that I am not treating the Section 22(1)(d) Offence with more gravity than the other offences.
41 The aggregate custodial sentence is therefore 23 weeks’ imprisonment.
This does not offend the totality principle as it is not substantially above the normal level of sentences for the most serious of the individual offences committed (bearing in mind that the custodial sentence for the Section 22(1)(d) Offence under Band 1 of the Chiew Kok Chai framework spans a range that is below 5 months’ imprisonment); and the sentence cannot be said to be crushing.

74 AOS_[5].

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
Conclusion
42 Ms Santos is sentenced to an aggregate of 23 weeks’ imprisonment and
a fine of $3,000 (in default 9 days’ imprisonment).


Samuel Wee District Judge

Justin Thia (Ministry of Manpower) for the Prosecution; Lim Hee Thuang Louis (Louis Lim & Partners) for the Defendant.

27

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
Annex A –
Summary of the Individual and Collective Sentences
S/N
Foreigner
involved
Charge No.
Offence
Prosecution’s Position on
Sentence
Defence’s Position on
Sentence
Court’s Decision
(1)
Ms Josill
MAC-909503- 2024 (C1)
Section 22(1)(d) Offence
6-8 weeks’
imprisonment
(consecutive)
6 weeks’ less 30%
imprisonment
(consecutive)
7 weeks’
imprisonment
(consecutive)
(2)
MAC-909509- 2024 (C4)
Section 22A
Offence
4 weeks’
imprisonment
(consecutive)
$1,000 penalty
1 week’s less 30% imprisonment (concurrent)
4 weeks’ imprisonment (concurrent)
$1,000 penalty
(3)
MAC-909513- 2024 (C7)
Section 10 Offence
3 weeks’ imprisonment (concurrent)
1 week’s less 30%
imprisonment
(consecutive)
7 days’
imprisonment (concurrent)
(4)
Ms Divina
MAC-909504- 2024 (C2)
Section 22(1)(d) Offence
10-12 weeks’
imprisonment
(consecutive)
9 weeks’ less 30%
imprisonment
(consecutive)
12 weeks’
imprisonment
(consecutive)
(5)
MAC-909510- 2024 (C5)
Section 22A
Offence
4 weeks’ imprisonment (concurrent)
$1,000 penalty
1 week’s less 30%
imprisonment
(consecutive)
4 weeks’ imprisonment (concurrent)
$1,000 penalty
(6)
MAC-909515- 2024 (C8)
Section 10 Offence
4 weeks’
imprisonment
(consecutive)
1 week’s less 30%
imprisonment
(consecutive)
10 days’
imprisonment (concurrent)
(7)
MAC-909505- 2024 (C10)
Section 22(1)(d) Offence
TIC Charge

28

Public Prosecutor v Josephine Santos Ho [2026] SGMC 27
Annex A –
Summary of the Individual and Collective Sentences
S/N
Foreigner
involved
Charge No.
Offence
Prosecution’s Position on
Sentence
Defence’s Position on
Sentence
Court’s Decision
(8)
Ms Perez
MAC-909506-
Section 22(1)(d)
3-4 weeks’
3 weeks’ less 30%
4 weeks’
2024 (C3)
Offence
imprisonment
imprisonment
imprisonment
(concurrent)
(consecutive)
(concurrent)
(9)
MAC-909511-
Section 22A
4 weeks’
1 week’s less 30%
4 weeks’
2024 (C6)
Offence
imprisonment
imprisonment
imprisonment
(consecutive)
(consecutive)
(consecutive)
$1,000 penalty
$1,000 penalty
(10)
MAC-909516-
Section 10 Offence
TIC Charge
2024 (C15)
(11)
Ms Tanodra
MAC-909508-
Section 22A
TIC Charge
2024 (C12)
Offence
(12)
MAC-909514-
Section 10 Offence
TIC Charge
2024 (C14)
(13)
MAC-909502-
Section 22(1)(a)
TIC Charge
2024 (C9)
Offence
(14)
Ms Loida
MAC-909512-
Section 22A
TIC Charge
2024 (C13)
Offence
(15)
MAC-909517-
Section 10 Offence
TIC Charge
2024 (C16)
(16)
MAC-909507-
Section 22(1)(a)
TIC Charge
2024 (C11)
Offence
Aggregate Sentence
28-32 weeks’
imprisonment
15-18 weeks’
imprisonment
23 weeks’
imprisonment
$3,000 penalty
$3,000 penalty (in default 9 days’ imprisonment)
29
Back to Top

This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

Version No 1: 22 Oct 2026 (21:46 hrs)