This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

In the state courts of the republic of singapore
[2026] SGDC 128
District Summons Case No 900808 of 2024
Magistrate’s Appeals No 9084 of 2026-01
Public Prosecutor
Against
Neo Eng Seng
grounds of decision
[Criminal Procedure and Sentencing] — [Sentencing]

This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Public Prosecutor
v
Neo Eng Seng
[2026] SGDC 128
District Summons Case No 900808 of 2024
Magistrate’s Appeals No 9084 of 2026-01
District Judge Ow Yong Tuck Leong
3 September 2025
26 March 2026
 
7 May 2026
District Judge Ow Yong Tuck Leong:
Introduction
1 On 26 March 2026, Mr Neo Eng Seng, a 70-year-old male Singaporean, (the “Accused”) pleaded guilty to the following charge:
You, on or before 7 December 2022, in Singapore, being an officer of Penta Landscape Pte. Ltd. (UEN: 199306739K) (“the Company”), of 61 Sungei Tengah Road, #ST-58, Singapore 698996, which was an employer at a workplace located at a public carpark adjacent to Toa Payoh South Community Club, near 1003 Toa Payoh Industrial Park, Singapore 319075 (“the Workplace”), which was a workplace under the Workplace Safety and Health Act 2006 (the “WSHA”), where the Company committed an offence under section 12(1) read with section 20 of the WSHA, by failing to take, so far as was reasonably practicable, such measures as were necessary to ensure the safety and health of the Company’s employees at work, to wit, the Company failed to:
a) establish and implement a lifting plan for the lifting operations carried out at the Workplace; and
b) deploy a competent lifting supervisor, rigger and signalman for the lifting operations carried out at the Workplace,
and you have thereby committed the same offence as the Company, pursuant to section 48(1) of the WSHA, and are liable to be punished under section 50(a) of the WSHA.
Prescribed punishment under section 50(a) of the Workplace Safety and Health Act 2006
Shall be liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding $200,000 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 2 years or to both.
Statement of Facts
2 The Accused admitted without qualification to the Statement of Facts (“SOF”) tendered by the Prosecution. I summarise the SOF below: 
1.  The accused is Neo Eng Seng … At the material time, he was the sole director of Penta Landscape Pte. Ltd. (UEN: 199306739K) (“Penta”) and was overall in-charge of Penta’s operations, which included workplace safety and health matters.
Background Facts
2.  The People’s Association (“PA”) had awarded a term contract to Eco Garden Pte. Ltd. (“Eco Garden”) in November 2019, for provision of horticulture and landscaping services to PA’s properties, including Toa Payoh South Community Club (“the CC”) located near 1003 Toa Payoh Industrial Park, Singapore 319075 (“the Workplace”), which was a workplace under the Workplace Safety and Health Act 2006 (“WSHA”).
3. Eco Garden then engaged Penta to perform tree cutting works to remove seven trees at the CC. The tree cutting works took place over the course of two days and was performed on 6 and 7 December 2022.
4. At the material time, Firoj … (the “Deceased”), a 28-year-old male Bangladeshi, was employed by Penta as a landscaping worker and had been carrying out such tree cutting works since February 2015. On the day of the fatal workplace incident, 7 December 2022, the Deceased was deployed to help with the tree cutting works at the CC.
Facts Surrounding the Fatal Workplace Incident
5.  For purposes of the tree cutting works at the Workplace, three of Penta’s employees were deployed to carry out the said works. They were the Deceased, and Hasan Mehedi (“Mehedi”) (employed since 29 February 2016) as the landscaping workers, and Shanmuganathan Ramesh (“Ramesh”) who was the lorry crane operator (employed since 8 February 2022) (collectively termed as the “Work Team”)
6. The seven trees that were to be felled and removed were located at one side of the CC building (“the CC side”), next to a storm drain which ran parallel to that side of the building. On the other side of the storm drain there was a sloped grass verge and pedestrian pavement, measuring approximately 1.2m wide. To the side of the grass verge and pavement, there was a side road, with parallel parking lots on either side.
7. For purposes of the works, the Work Team cordoned off a number of the parallel parking lots along the side road and parked a lorry crane bearing registration number LM242739V across two parking lots in the cordoned off area. It was intended that the lorry crane would be used to lift the sectioned trunks and branches of the felled trees from within the CC premises to then be placed either within the cordoned off area of the parking lots or onto the bed of the lorry crane. The lorry crane controls were located at its chassis at the side of the lorry, next to the base of the crane.
8. On 6 December 2022, the Work Team managed to complete the cutting of five trees and part of the sixth tree. The tree branches and trunks of the cut trees were then lifted and loaded onto the lorry bed of the lorry crane and sent for disposal on the morning of 7 December 2022.
9.  On 7 December 2022, at about 11.30am, the Work Team arrived at the Workplace to complete the cutting and removal of the remaining two trees.
10.  After performing some preparation work, the three workers went for lunch and resumed work at about 1pm. Ramesh operated the lorry crane and lifted Mehedi up via a man basket attached to the crane to cut down the branches and trunk of the remaining two trees. The Deceased who was stationed on the ground would then cut the fallen branches into smaller sections and stacked them on the grass patch beside the lorry crane.
11.  At about 2pm, Mehedi had cut the bottom of the trunk of the last tree as one long section (hereinafter referred to as “the load”). The load measured about 5.5m in length. The load was then hoisted over the nearby drain and placed on top of the other branches that had already been stacked on the grass verge next to the lorry crane. As it started to rain, the three workers halted their work.
12. When the rain subsided at about 3pm, the Work Team resumed their work. At the material time, Mehedi was at the CC side of the Workplace sharpening and cleaning the chainsaw that was used to cut the trees. As there were some branches below the tree trunk of the seventh tree (i.e., the load), the Deceased suggested to Ramesh to hoist the load away so that the branches below it could be cleared. Whilst Ramesh watched, the Deceased proceeded to rig the load with a webbing sling and hooked it onto the one of the lifting hooks on the crane’s boom.
13. The Deceased then moved a few steps away on the grass patch where he was standing and asked Ramesh to lift the load. Ramesh then lifted the load using the lorry crane’s controls to a height of about 1.5m when it suddenly swung, rotated, and struck the Deceased who happened to be standing within the lifting zone at the time. The Deceased then fell and hit his head against the pavement.
14. Ramesh immediately called Mehedi over for help. At that time, the load was observed to be on the ground beside the Deceased who was lying motionless on the concrete pavement and bleeding from the mouth. With the assistance of Mehedi, Ramesh lifted the load away from the Deceased back onto the grass patch, before calling for an ambulance. The Deceased was eventually conveyed to Tan Tock Seng Hospital, where he subsequently succumbed to his injuries at 4.20pm. The cause of death was certified as a head injury.
Penta’s breach of its duty as an Employer under section 12(1) read with section 20 of the WSHA
15.  As the employer to the Work Team, who were at work at the Workplace, Penta had a duty under section 12(1) of the WSHA to take so far as is reasonably practicable, such measures as are necessary to ensure the safety and health of its employees at work. Penta failed to discharge this duty as further elaborated in sections A and B below.
A. Failure to establish and implement a lifting plan for the lifting works carried out at the Workplace
16.  Under section 12(3)(b) of the WSHA, Penta’s duty as an employer under section 12(1) of the WSHA includes ensuring that adequate safety measures are taken in respect of any equipment or process used by its employees. In this case, Penta’s employees were to carry out lifting works using a lorry crane as part of the process of lifting cut tree trunks and branches. Section 12(3)(e) of the WSHA also states that the employer must ensure that its employees have adequate information as is necessary for them to perform their work.
17.  In addition, regulation 4(1) of the Workplace Safety and Health (Operation of Cranes) Regulations 2011 (“OOC Regs”) states that “where any lifting operation involving the use of any crane is carried out in a workplace by a crane operator, it shall be the duty of the responsible person to establish and implement a lifting plan which shall be in accordance with the generally accepted principles of safe and sound practice.”. The importance and purpose of a lifting plan is also set out in the Code of Practice for Safe Lifting Operations in the Workplaces where it is stated that the primary objective of the Lifting Plan is to facilitate common understanding amongst the lifting crew for a safe outcome and this is based on the underlying principle that foreseeable risks are able to be assessed and eliminated or mitigated.
18.  In this regard, Penta constituted the responsible person as the employer of the workers who were to carry out the lifting works. Investigations revealed that Penta did not establish and implement any lifting plan for the lifting works carried out at the Workplace.
19.  The failure by Penta to establish and implement a lifting plan meant that its employees were left to their own devices insofar as the lifting operations were concerned. It also meant that its employees lacked site specific information which would have been provided by a lifting plan – namely the details of the load and any unique hazards associated with it, details of the lifting equipment used, means of communications, personnel involved in the lifting operation, the physical and environmental considerations, the sequence involved in lifting and any special precautions to take (e.g. the cordoning of the work zone), as well as a sketch of the zone of operations.
20.  Separately, investigations also showed that webbing slings used on the day of the incident did not have any valid certificate of test and examination by an authorised examiner – a requirement under regulation 20 of the Workplace Safety and Health (General Provisions) Regulations. This was also contrary to Penta’s own Safe Work Procedure which set out that lifting gears with valid inspection certificates ought to be used.
B. Failure to deploy a competent lifting supervisor, rigger and signalman for the lifting operations carried out at the Workplace
21. Under section 12(3)(e) of the WSHA, Penta’s duty as the employer under section 12(1) of the WSHA would include ensuring that those persons at work have adequate training as is necessary for them to perform their work. Regulations 17, 18 and 19 of the OOC Regs also states that before any lifting operations involving the use of the lorry crane at the Workplace, a competent lifting supervisor, rigger and signalman must be appointed by the employer.
22. Investigations showed that Penta had failed to appoint and deploy a competent lifting supervisor, rigger and signalman for the lifting operations carried out at the Workplace. Rather, the Work Team was left to carry out the works based on their own experience (and not based on any formal training or certification) – and such included deciding on which point of the crane to rig the load for lifting, as well as the weight of the load to be lifted.
23. Specifically, the accused was the person who had appointed Mehedi as the supervisor and as the rigger/signalman for the lifting works at the Workplace. However, investigations show that Mehedi was not competent to be a lifting supervisor, or a rigger/signalman as he had not attended any of the relevant training courses. This meant that there was no competent lifting supervisor appointed to help ensure that a lifting plan was implemented, that there was a site-specific risk assessment, that the safe lifting procedures were implemented, and that there had been authorisation before commencing the lifting operation by a permit-to-work system.
24. Investigations also revealed that all three workers (i.e., the Deceased, Ramesh and Mehedi) were deployed by the accused to perform rigging of the cut branches and trunk sections of the trees on 6 and 7 December 2022 even though none of them had attended any rigger training course. Ramesh had also performed the lifting operations at the Workplace using the lorry crane without the presence of a competent signalman to guide him.
25. This was also contrary to Penta’s own Risk Assessment (Annex A) for tree pruning which had stated the provision of training and the provision of supervision as risk control measures for the use of a lorry crane and the lifting of tree branches.
26. By virtue of the abovementioned failures, Penta had breached its duty as an employer and has thereby committed an offence under section 12(1) read with section 20 of the WSHA.
27.  The abovementioned two failures constitute serious safety breaches that had contributed to the fatal workplace incident that caused the death of the Deceased.
The accused’s personal liability for the same offence as Penta pursuant to section 48(1) of the WSHA
28. Section 48(1) of the WSHA provides that where an offence under the WSHA has been committed by a body corporate, an officer of the body corporate shall be guilty of the offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly unless he proves that a) the offence was committed without his consent or connivance; and b) he had exercised all such diligence to prevent the commission of the offence as he ought to have exercised having regard to the nature of his functions in that capacity and to all the circumstances.
29.  The accused was Penta’s sole director and overall in-charge of the company’s operations, including matters related to workplace safety and health. The accused was also the one with the ultimate decision-making authority over all systems relating to workplace safety and in terms of deployment of workers to their relevant job scopes on the ground.
30.  In his position as the person running Penta, the accused had failed to put systems in place to ensure that a lifting plan was established and implemented before any lifting operations took place, and that only trained and competent personnel were deployed to perform such works.
31.  Instead, the accused had proceeded to deploy employees that were not competent (due to a lack of formal training and certification) to perform the lifting operations at the Workplace, and without establishing and implementing a lifting plan beforehand. This had exposed the employees to unnecessary safety risks. Investigations established that the accused did not know or apprise himself of the specific requirements regarding a lifting plan prior to the commencement of any lifting works, even though such information was publicly available and when Penta had been performing such lifting works for years.
32.  Investigations also revealed that the accused had deployed untrained and non-competent employees for at least four years as Mehedi had been deployed to carry out tree cutting works since sometime in 2019 and the said works involved lifting operations as part of lifting and moving of the cut tree branches and trunks. Mehedi was only certified to perform rigger and signalman tasks only after the fatal workplace incident, sometime around 6 October 2023.
33.  By virtue of the above, the accused has committed an offence under section 48(1) read with section 12(1) and section 20 of the WSHA, punishable under section 50(a) of the WSHA.
 
Antecedents
3 The Accused was traced for unrelated antecedents. On 16 September 2000, he was fined $4,000 under s 13D(1)(a) of the Miscellaneous Offences (Public Order and Nuisance) Act (Cap. 184) for using indecent, threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour towards a public servant. On the same day, he was fined $1,000 for disorderly behaviour under s 20 of the same Act.
Prosecution’s Address on Sentence
4 The Prosecution highlighted that the legislative intent of the WSHA is deterrence, to deter risk-taking behaviour and to ensure proactivity by companies in preventing incidents.
5 The applicable sentencing framework is the two-stage sentencing framework and sentencing benchmarks set out in the High Court decision of Koh Lian Kok v Public Prosecutor [2024] 4 SLR 1526 (“Koh Lian Kok”). In this case, given that death was caused, harm should be graded at the top end of the high range.
6 Moving to the point of culpability, the Accused had ultimate control and responsibility in the Company and could have prevented the failures by the Company. First, the Accused was the best person to prevent such failures given that he could essentially dictate the Company’s compliance with the WSHA. Second, the Accused had participated in the Company’s breach of the WSHA to a substantial extent. The Accused had assigned the employees their jobs based on his assessment of their suitability. Third, the period of offending was long with regards to the deployment of untrained workers. With respect to the failure to implement a lifting plan, the Company had been performing such works for years, but the Accused during investigations had admitted that he did not know or apprised himself of publicly available information on the need for a lifting plan.
7 In the case of Public Prosecutor v Yeo Teck Soon [2025] 4 SLR 1541 (“Yeo Teck Soon”), the High Court stated that where there was a direct nexus between the offender’s conduct and the company’s breach of the WSHA duty, the company culpability factors are relevant. In this case, there was a direct nexus present given that the Company’s failures fell within the Accused’s actual authority and responsibilities in the Company as the sole officer in charge of the Company’s operations and workplace safety measures.
8 The Prosecution emphasised that the failures by the Company were contrary to the Company’s own Risk Assessment for tree pruning that stated that the provision of training and the provision of supervisions were risk control measures for the use of a lorry crane and the lifting of tree branches but this was not done. The Company’s failures were egregious and systemic in nature.
9 All things considered, the Prosecution submitted that culpability must also be pegged at high. At Stage 1 of Koh Lian Kok sentencing framework, an offender of high harm and high culpability attracts a sentence of more than 12 months’ to 24 months’ imprisonment, the Accused’s starting sentence should be 15 to 16 months. While there was one less failure compared to Koh Lian Kok, that a risk assessment and safe work procedure were conducted in the present case, it was a paper exercise as there was no compliance with the safety documents.
10 At Stage 2 of the sentencing framework, the Prosecution submitted that there were no aggravating factors, and recognised that the sentence could be calibrated downward to 14 to 15 months’ imprisonment as the Accused had pleaded guilty midway through trial. While the Accused had been certified with major depressive disorder by the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”), it did not constitute an exceptional circumstance and did not cross the threshold requiring an exercise of judicial mercy.
Mitigation
11 The Defence acknowledged that the two-stage sentencing set out in Koh Lian Kok applied. The Defence submitted that the present case falls within the high harm and low culpability band.
12 There was a lack of direct nexus between the Accused’s conduct and the Company’s breach of its duty under the WSHA. The Accused had delegated safety responsibilities to Ms Chong Xiau Pei. Ms Chong had fallen short in discharging her responsibilities, including failing to ensure the necessary materials and documentation were properly prepared and provided.
13  The Accused consistently conducted safety briefings before the commencement of each task. The Accused included a letter dated 6 March 2026 endorsed by two workers presently working under his supervision, demonstrating that the Accused had instilled a culture of safety among his workers.
14 The Accused was unwell at the material time. He instructed the workers to cease work during heavy rain and left the site. The workers resumed work when the rain subsided and proceeded with lifting operations on their own initiative. While the Prosecution outlined regulatory lapses, this was not a case of deliberate disregard. It was a failure in oversight by an elderly director who did not personally supervise operations that afternoon.
15 Moving to the second stage of the sentencing framework, the Defence highlighted the following mitigating factors: (a) the Accused’s advanced age; (b) the Accused’s poor health condition; (c) the Accused’s remorse and sense of responsibility for the incident; (d) the Accused had made $10,000 compensation to the Deceased’s family who had forgiven him; and (e) the Accused was the primary caregiver living with his daughter who was unwell.
16  The Defence referred to Chew Soo Chun v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2016] 2 SLR 78 (“Chew Soo Chun”) and submitted for the court to exercise judicial mercy. The Accused suffered from major depressive disorder, had cardiac and neurological symptoms, his mind may occasionally turn blank and he may suddenly fall asleep. The Accused believed that given his advanced age and frail health, a custodial sentence may pose a serious risk to his life.
17 The Defence referred to a newspaper article titled “General manager of NEA’s Tuas facility fined $145,000 over 2021 explosion that killed 2 men”. The Defence highlighted that despite two fatalities and systemic regulatory breaches involving high-voltage operations, the sentence imposed on the officer was a fine, not imprisonment. The Defence submitted that the comparison underscores the importance of proportionality in sentencing. A fine was appropriate here as it did not involve multiple deaths, nor a complex institutional regulatory breakdown of the scale seen in the Tuas explosion case.
18 These factors weigh significantly in favour of a non-custodial sentence. The Defence submitted for a fine in the range of $175,000 to $200,000.
Court’s Decision
19 The High Court in Yeo Teck Soon held that the Two Stage Framework with the Koh Lian Kok sentencing benchmarks applies for sentencing individuals under s 48(1) of the WSHA who are liable for punishment under s 50(a) of the WSHA (Yeo Teck Soon at [21], [56] - [57]).
20 At the first stage, the court will determine the level of harm and culpability to arrive at an indicative starting point according to the Koh Lian Kok benchmarks (Koh Lian Kok at [79(a)]).
Culpability
Low
Moderate
High
Harm
Low
Fine of up to $75,000
Fine of more than $75,000 and up to $175,000
Fine of more than $175,000 and up to $200,000 or up to six months’ imprisonment
Moderate
Fine of more than $75,000 and up to $175,000
Fine of more than $175,000 and up to $200,000 or up to six months’ imprisonment
More than six months and up to 12 months’ imprisonment
High
Fine of more than $175,000 and up to $200,000 or up to six months’ imprisonment
More than six months and up to 12 months’ imprisonment
More than 12 months and up to 24 months’ imprisonment
21 In evaluating the level of harm, the court is to have regard to the following factors: (a) the seriousness of the harm risked; (b) the likelihood of that harm arising; (c) the number of people likely to be exposed to the risk of the harm; and (d) the actual harm that was occasioned by the risk that stemmed from the accused person’s negligent act. Where potential harm was likely to be death or serious injury, the harm may be considered high even if it did not materialise. If death or serious injury did occur, the harm would typically be assessed near the top end of the high range (Koh Lian Kok at [79(b)]).
22 In assessing the officer’s culpability, the court may have regard to the following factors: (a) the officer’s role in the company; (b) the extent of the officer’s participation in the company’s breach of its Part IV Duties; (c) the officer’s duration of offending; and (d) whether the officer’s offending conduct was motivated by financial gain or the avoidance of costs (Yeo Teck Soon at [56(b)]).
23 In assessing the officer's culpability where there is a direct nexus between the officer's acts and/or omissions and the company's breach of its Part IV Duties, the court may consider the following company culpability factors: (a) the number of breaches or failures; (b) the nature of the breaches; (c) the seriousness of the breaches; (d) whether the breaches were systemic; and (e) whether the breaches were intentional, rash or negligent. Whether a direct nexus exists depends on all the facts of the case, including but not limited to the following factors: (a) the extent of the officer’s involvement in the underlying breach; and (b) the officer’s role in the company. The officer’s culpability should be assessed independently and is not automatically pegged to his company’s level of culpability for its underlying breach of its Part IV Duties. (Yeo Teck Soon at [56(c) – 56(d)].
24 At the second stage, the starting sentence should be calibrated according to offender-specific aggravating and mitigating factors. Aggravating factors may include the following: (a) the offender evidently lacks remorse; (b) the presence of relevant antecedents; and (c) any offences taken into consideration for the purposes of sentencing. Mitigating factors may include the following: (a) the offender has voluntarily taken steps to remedy the problem; (b) the offender has provided a high level of co-operation with the authorities for the investigations, beyond that which is normally expected; (c) there is self-reporting and acceptance of responsibility; and (d) there is a timely plea of guilt (Koh Lian Kok at [79(d)] - [79(f)]).
25 In the present case, the parties did not dispute that the harm would be assessed high. I considered the Risk Assessment (Annex A), Ref 9 of the Risk Assessment, the work activity “Lifting of tree branches” identified the hazard as “fall onto someone” and resulting in “fatal, serious injury”. In my view, the potential harm was high. The lifting operations carried the risk of collision with the workers within the lifting zone. Here, death did occur and the harm should be assessed near the top end of the high range.
26  Turning to the Accused’s culpability, I considered the breaches. First, it was not disputed that there was a failure to establish and implement a lifting plan for the lifting works carried out at the Workplace. Investigations revealed that the Company did not do so, that the employees were left to their own discretion to conduct the lifting operations without proper safety considerations (SOF at [18] - [19]). The webbing slings used were not certified. This was contrary to the Company’s own Safe Work Procedure (SOF at [20]).
27 Second, it was not disputed that there was a failure to deploy a competent lifting supervisor, rigger and signalman for the lifting operations carried out at the Workplace. The Accused was the person who appointed the employee Mehedi as the supervisor, rigger and signalman even though he did not attend any training courses. This meant that there was no competent lifting supervisor appointed to help ensure that a lifting plan was implemented, that there was a site-specific risk assessment, that the safe lifting procedures were implemented, and that there had been authorisation before commencing the lifting operation by a permit-to-work system (SOF at [23]).
28 It was not disputed that the Accused had deployed the employees to perform rigging of cut branches and trunk sections even though none of them had attended any rigger training course (SOF at [24]). This was contrary to the Company’s own risk assessment for tree pruning (SOF at [25]). The two failures constitute serious safety breaches that contributed to the fatal workplace incident (SOF at [27]).
29 In my view, there was a direct nexus between the Accused’s acts and omissions and the Company’s breaches. It was not disputed that the Accused was the Company’s sole director and overall in-charge of operations including workplace safety and health matters. The Accused was the ultimate decision maker and decided the deployment of the workers and their job scopes (SOF at [29]). It was a bare assertion by the Defence to shift the responsibility to Ms Chong instead of the Accused.
30 It was not disputed that the Accused failed to establish proper systems for lifting operations, specifically in ensuring a lifting plan was in place before operations commenced and that only trained and competent personnel were deployed for such work (SOF at [30]).
31 It was not disputed that the Accused did not apprise himself of the legal requirements even though such information was publicly available, and the Company had been performing such lifting works for years (SOF at [31]). Investigations also revealed that the Accused had deployed untrained and non-competent employees for at least four years (SOF at [32]).
32 These serious breaches were systemic and not an isolated incident. The Defence said that the Accused cared about the workers’ safety. Yet, the reckless deployment of untrained and non-competent workers without a lifting plan said otherwise. This was a foreseeable risk. The fatal workplace incident could have been prevented. The load should be properly rigged by a competent rigger. The crane operator should be directed by a competent signalman. And the entire operation should be overseen by a competent lifting supervisor. The Deceased would have been stopped from rigging the load and directed away from the lifting area before the crane operator would be allowed to lift the load.
33 All things considered, I indicated the Accused’s culpability to be at the high range.
34 At the first stage of the Koh Lian Kok sentencing framework, the indicative sentencing range for an offender of high harm and high culpability was a sentence of more than 12 months’ to 24 months’ imprisonment. The indicative starting point given that death did occur, would be in the upper end of this range. I then lowered the indicative starting point on account of having a Risk Assessment plan. The sentence indicated at the first stage was 15 months’ imprisonment.
35 At the second stage of the sentencing framework, I considered that there were no aggravating factors.
36 I accepted the following mitigating factors. The Accused was remorseful and had compensated the Deceased’s family. Remedial action was taken to certify the employee Mehedi to perform rigger and signalman tasks.
37 The Accused claimed trial and did not plead guilty at the earliest opportunity. The trial commenced on 3 September 2025 before a different judge. The Accused decided to plead guilty midway. The Sentencing Advisory Panel Guidelines on Reduction in Sentences for Guilty Pleas (at paragraph 9) provides that a maximum sentence reduction of 5% applies where a person pleads guilty on or after the first day of trial. Both parties agreed that the 5% reduction should apply. All things considered, I gave the maximum 5% reduction in sentencing. The sentence would be 14 months’ imprisonment with rounding down.
38 I disagreed with the Defence on the following submissions. In general, the mature age of the offender does not warrant a moderation of the punishment. The degree to which the age of the offender may be mitigating depends on the facts of the case. Here, the duration of the sentence imposed was not a long-term sentence that effectively amounts to a life sentence for the Accused. Further, any mitigating weight that may be considered was negated by the fact that the Accused had deployed untrained and non-competent employees for a considerable period of at least four years (Koh Lian Kok at [94]). In my view, no weight should be accorded to the Accused’s age.
39 Taking guidance from Chew Soo Chun, there were no exceptional circumstances to justify a reduction in sentence or a non-custodial sentence on account of ill health. The Accused did not suffer from terminal illness, and a custodial sentence would not place the Accused’s life at substantial risk. There was no disproportionate impact of imprisonment.
40 According to the IMH report, the Accused had developed major depressive disorder after the fatal workplace incident but still retains the faculty of logical reasons. His prognosis, according to the doctor, should be optimistic provided he receives the requisite psychiatric treatment. The Singapore Prison Service had been apprised of his medical condition. The Accused would continue to receive medical care and attention deemed necessary by the medical professionals in a secure setting.
41 The Accused’s role as primary caregiver for his unwell daughter does not constitute an exceptional mitigating circumstance. The Accused would have to make alternative care arrangements for his daughter whilst serving his sentence.
42 The Defence referred to a newspaper article in their submission for a fine. That was the unreported case of Public Prosecutor v Ng Wah Yong (SC-907892-2023) (“Ng Wah Yong”). The Prosecution assisted by uploading the charge and SOF for the Defence’s reference. After considering these documents, the Defence maintained the submission for a fine.
43 It is well established that unreported decisions are of limited precedential value, see Jennifer Toh Suat Leng v Public Prosecutor [2022] SGHC 146 at [51]. In my view, after applying the Two Stage Framework here, the custodial sentence of 14 months’ imprisonment would not be inconsistent with the outcome in Koh Lian Kok.
44 In Koh Lian Kok, the 70-year-old offender was charged with failing to (a) conduct a risk assessment in relation to the safety and health risks posed to any person who might be affected by the transporting of the boom lift (“the Works”); (b) develop and implement a lifting plan for the Works; and (c) ensure that there was a trained and competent lifting supervisor, rigger, and signalman appointed for the works. Despite the offender's lapses clearly causing a death, the sentence was not based on the fact of death, as the Prosecution had agreed not to rely on the death at the sentencing stage and it was not appropriate to allow the offender to retract his plea and to remit the matter to trial. The starting sentence was indicated at 18 months’ imprisonment. On account of his guilty plea and cooperation, the starting sentence was calibrated down to 14 months’ imprisonment.
Conclusion
45 The courts will impose a sufficiently deterrent sentence to not only highlight the importance of workplace safety to all relevant stakeholders, but also to deter like-minded individuals in similar positions as the Accused from committing similar offences.
46 The Accused, being dissatisfied with the sentence has filed a notice of appeal against sentence. He is on bail pending the appeal.
Ow Yong Tuck Leong
District Judge
Melvyn Low and Teo Sijing (Ministry of Manpower) for the Public Prosecutor;
Tham Kok Leong (Tactica Law) for the Accused
Back to Top

This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.

Version No 1: 06 Oct 2026 (17:38 hrs)